1. Okay I rarely analyse any of the bands songs as they can be somewhat open to interpretation and mean something that’s very individualistic.

    But this keeps nawing at me.

    I think The Greatest Show on Earth is a sequel to Until the end of the World.

    Hear me out.

    Both have themes of a struggle with faith. “Until the End of the World” has the urgency of a confession hurtling towards its inevitable conclusion, while “The Greatest Show on Earth” feels more reflective … someone looking back at an extraordinary relationship and trying to decide what it meant.

    One is caught in the act of reckoning while the other is trying to make sense of the aftermath.

    What do we think?
  2. There are definitely similar themes. UTEOTW had the particularity of being quite explicitly written from the perspective of Judas talking to Jesus after the fact. TGSOE is less specific in that way, I think.

    TGSOE can be read on at least three levels: 1. as being about the band, 2. as being about a human relationship/marriage, 3. As being about the relationship between people and God and, specifically, dealing with the Fall in the Biblical/theological sense.
  3. Originally posted by dstankie:There are definitely similar themes. UTEOTW had the particularity of being quite explicitly written from the perspective of Judas talking to Jesus after the fact. TGSOE is less specific in that way, I think.

    TGSOE can be read on at least three levels: 1. as being about the band, 2. as being about a human relationship/marriage, 3. As being about the relationship between people and God and, specifically, dealing with the Fall in the Biblical/theological sense.
    From the fact that Bono has explicitly said that it was inspired by the recent Elvis’ movie, I think that this song is about the band itself. I thought about the band reflecting and going back to their “Rock’s Hottest Ticket” week when I think they were at the maximum of their popularity globally. If you think about it, TGSOE is adjacent to One in some sense with the meaning
  4. U2 are probably the best band to start a song slow and build it into a great crescendo
  5. The Little Things That Give You Away should have been this good. But they just didn’t make the music part of it much good.
  6. Yeah, the music is great here. Iris is another song that could have been top level in my opinion but that doesn't quite nail it musically. I think that Jackknife is doing great work, production-wise. There is an amazing clarity of sound to these tracks that was lacking on the last couple albums.

    BTW, not that anyone cares or is keeping score, but I am revising my earlier bland assessment of this song. Now I agree that it is quite powerful and a significant achievement. It took me many, many listens to start to hear what is distinctive about it.
  7. Originally posted by germcevoy:The Little Things That Gove You Away should have been this good. But they just didn’t make the music part of it much good.

    Agreed, the Album version is much worse than the 2017 tour version.


    With Street of Dreams, I don't think so. We're talking about an album with NO mid songs.
  8. Originally posted by dstankie:Yeah, the music is great here. Iris is another song that could have been top level in my opinion but that doesn't quite nail it musically. I think that Jackknife is doing great work, production-wise. There is an amazing clarity of sound to these tracks that was lacking on the last couple albums.

    BTW, not that anyone cares or is keeping score, but I am revising my earlier bland assessment of this song. Now I agree that it is quite powerful and a significant achievement. It took me many, many listens to start to hear what is distinctive about it.
    I like Iris, but live preferably. The album version's chorus isn't as powerful, it should have really lifted there.
  9. Originally posted by tchezao:[..]

    Agreed, the Album version is much worse than the 2017 tour version.

    [..]

    With Street of Dreams, I don't think so. We're talking about an album with NO mid songs.
    I get you, but honestly after listening to Greatest Show on repeat for a day, Street of Dreams is like fresh air

    Even though I am well aware that SOD is a 6/10 and GSOE is 9,5/10
  10. If they didn't released another single until Nov 13 I would be happy

    I would have even been happy if this song were the only released single before the album

    That's how good it is
  11. It's just so hard to explain, I haven't heard such a "complete" U2 song in so many years...

    Little Things, EBW, and MOS seem lacking something when compared to this song...

    This is mix of All I Want Is You, Joshua Tree, Achtung Baby, and Unforgettable Fire in terms of quality.

    If the album has 3 more songs with this quality, I think we could rank it high in their discography.