1. Originally posted by juandicorrea:It's just so hard to explain, I haven't heard such a "complete" U2 song in so many years...

    Little Things, EBW, and MOS seem lacking something when compared to this song...

    This is mix of All I Want Is You, Joshua Tree, Achtung Baby, and Unforgettable Fire in terms of quality.

    If the album has 3 more songs with this quality, I think we could rank it high in their discography.
    It’s Edges chiming melodic beat ( yes I know it’s technically not a beat ) … but that dotted delay drives the song!!

  2. This is by far the biggest single they have released for 25 years. Check this out, this is a comprehensive music review and data website. They give Critic and Public scores averaged out of 100 section category.

    Check out the other singles they have released scores for comparison.
  3. To me this is a great track that could have fit on SOI, the production breath SOI atmosphere of it, its more of a flirt with SOI than anything else they released.
    Works well with Iris and EBW.
  4. This song is on par with Bad for me now. It hasn't just got me in the feels, it has blown me away completely.

    To only think a year or so ago people thought this band were done, even I was losing interest after Songs Of Surrender, then Days Of Ash surprised us all, followed by some of their best work in Easter Lily. And now this monster of a tune, I appreciate taste and opinion are subjective but if this were the last song the band ever released I would be happy. I'm just glad they're continuing.
  5. Originally posted by EridescoFly:This song is on par with Bad for me now. It hasn't just got me in the feels, it has blown me away completely.

    To only think a year or so ago people thought this band were done, even I was losing interest after Songs Of Surrender, then Days Of Ash surprised us all, followed by some of their best work in Easter Lily. And now this monster of a tune, I appreciate taste and opinion are subjective but if this were the last song the band ever released I would be happy. I'm just glad they're continuing.
    I keep saying to myself that surely I can’t rate this track as being right up their with previous work. It is though
  6. For me it’s the cascading scales of the guitar and keys that work so well. It’s a great framework and wide open for Bono to fly.
  7. The song is a masterpiece, magic and wonderful. U2's next level. Everything is just perfect. The Edge's guitar is mesmerizing. The structure of the song and the distribution of musical elements very unusal and surprising. Its success on the charts shows that people are eager to hear U2 songs that are really U2 songs, nothing more - nothing less. Together with "Song For Hall", this is the best single thing they've done since 1993. Bravo, guys! Thanks!
  8. Originally posted by Peterrrrr:To me this is a great track that could have fit on SOI, the production breath SOI atmosphere of it, its more of a flirt with SOI than anything else they released.
    Works well with Iris and EBW.
    Disagree here. SOI still sounds flat to me 12 years later. Greatest Show sounds glorious, far above Iris and EBW, which just sound like basic pop songs with generic production compared to this (live version different of course.)

    Not to turn this into a SOE vs. SOI debate at all, but I’m glad the band is continuing to work with Jacknife rather than Tedder (yes I know he had an additional production credit on Silencio).
  9. They have found something in the production of this song (and Silencio too) that just lifts it up and out of the murk that was the previous two albums. Every Breaking Wave, Iris, Little Things, Landlady, Sleep Like a Baby, The Troubles, Summer of Love but to name a few just all have a muted dullness to them. Like they are all under a blanket.

    This song escapes that entirely.
  10. I'm still blown away by how good this tune is, both musically and lyrically. Definitely sits among their top work🔥
  11. I hear Disappearing Act here
  12. Originally posted by germcevoy:They have found something in the production of this song (and Silencio too) that just lifts it up and out of the murk that was the previous two albums. Every Breaking Wave, Iris, Little Things, Landlady, Sleep Like a Baby, The Troubles, Summer of Love but to name a few just all have a muted dullness to them. Like they are all under a blanket.

    This song escapes that entirely.
    The eno effect