1. Originally posted by juandicorrea:[..]
    the guy gave TGSOE the same rating as the new Rolling Stones song, which is weird because almost all Rolling Stones songs sound the same
    The stones could release an album of Mick composing various audible farts he produced between albums and it would be rated 4 or 5 stars.
  2. From minute 3 this is pure magic.

  3. Forgot to pack the teleprompter I see.
  4. Lyric video’s up
  5. I was thinking how cool it’d be for Bono to replace “somewhere” in the “it’s a beautiful night somewhere” part with the name of the city they’re playing in. Nice way to get the whole crowd going and get us hyped during the slow build of the song.
  6. Ok I'm gonna say this, things that are "bad" about this song:

    - I get really depressed when it's finishing at the very end, like a beautiful dream you don't wanna wake up from;

    - gives me a rush of anxiety on top of all the other emotions when I play on the speakers because I can't help myself and it's always loud so I'm anticipating a neighbor knocking on my door hehehe;

    - it outdated a lot of other U2 songs that I love but I'm happy to give them a break for some time now.


    I'm sorry I can't get over how much they knocked it out of the park with this one!!!! The other day I had goosebumps for 3 minutes straight listening to it.

    It's a thin line not to overplay a song you really love but I also think you can eventually break through that so I'll keep the repeat-1 set for now 😃
  7. Don’t know how to explain it… this song is devastating… in the best possible way. I’m completely blown away.
  8. I'm still trying to process what this song is about.
  9. I've finally had a chance to listen to this with my partner and although it's okay it's nothing fantastic the way people on here have been gushing about it

    Yeh I know all music is subjective but we're all be U2 fans here so I'm entitled to my opinion

    I think what it is is that a lot of members seem to rate ATYCLB which is a good album but not a great album let down by a weak production

    Then there's the fans who love HTDAAB again a good album but not a great album and an album where U2 seemed to take this (now long trodden) path of overly long and overly earnest songs and songwriting - again not my thing

    Then we have the NLOTH fans which is another good album but not a great album full of a mish-mash of poor pop songs and overly long prog stuff really

    So yeh if you look at those albums then I can see why a lot of you think this is the best thing since AB but for me it's just okay - it doesn't make the hairs on the back of my neck stand up or give me chills

    And to those who scrutinise lyrics - well, for me its about the music but I appreciate good songwriting and good lyrics BUT good lyrics do not always make a good song otherwise we'd all be listening to a cappella or printing off the lyrics to read

    Sorry to be THE FLY in the ointment

    Again - it's good it's okay - but nothing more

    Of course I'll listen to it a few more times to see if it grows on me but I don't think it will to the stage where I think it's as amazing as you all seem to think it is
  10. I’d agree ‘the greatest show on earth’ isn’t the best song since AB. I could name quite a few songs in that time I like more. What I do think they have with the 2026 work so far is a lot of strong material. Have they released a 10/10 song? No I wouldn’t say so. But I think they’ve released a few 7’s and 8’s which is a good standard. I could pick a 10 song album from the year already that doesn’t have a bad song on it. Very high standard of work. But no they haven’t released the next ‘One’, ‘Bad’, or ‘without or without’.