1. I think there will be 3 standout tracks, including GSOE.

    Go, La Reina, If The World Is At War, Glorify, Torn seem very solid.

    While Mirror Maker, Superficiality, Can’t Stop Us Now, and Midnight Sunshine seem experimental…

    I think we will end up liking the album, but, of course, thinking In A Life, Resurrection Song and Tears of Things could have made the cut. But maybe the project could be rated 5 stars as a whole: Carnaval-Ash-Lily.
  2. Originally posted by edthorpe:Perhaps they have spread themselves a little thinly over this year’s releases – one 12-track album forged from the EPs and Carnaval’s best tracks could have landed a whopping comeback.

    I am sure that will be a future thread here - the 12 track masterpiece that could have been.


    I am hoping there will be a debate between the 12 track (or maybe 15 track) masterpiece that could have been vs. the 24 track masterpiece that is. Can't wait to hear the album.
  3. Originally posted by juandicorrea:I think there will be 3 standout tracks, including GSOE.

    Go, La Reina, If The World Is At War, Glorify, Torn seem very solid.

    While Mirror Maker, Superficiality, Can’t Stop Us Now, and Midnight Sunshine seem experimental…

    I think we will end up liking the album, but, of course, thinking In A Life, Resurrection Song and Tears of Things could have made the cut. But maybe the project could be rated 5 stars as a whole: Carnaval-Ash-Lily.
    Maybe so. I will be evaluating the deluxe version of the album including the two EPs in terms of where it stands in the U2 canon, rather than just the single-disc version of Carnaval.
  4. Originally posted by juandicorrea:I think there will be 3 standout tracks, including GSOE.

    Go, La Reina, If The World Is At War, Glorify, Torn seem very solid.

    While Mirror Maker, Superficiality, Can’t Stop Us Now, and Midnight Sunshine seem experimental…

    I think we will end up liking the album, but, of course, thinking In A Life, Resurrection Song and Tears of Things could have made the cut. But maybe the project could be rated 5 stars as a whole: Carnaval-Ash-Lily.
    If the World is at War seems to be a continuation of Co-Exist musically. Not my favourite type of U2 song.
  5. You have heard the album, right ?
  6. The suspected next vinyl variant, might it be targeted for RSD Black Friday?
  7. I enjoy those kind of musical landscapes / experimental pieces from time to time.
    But not that close to each other. That's why Passengers isn't a favourite of mine
  8. If true then that’s going to make for a really jarring listening experience going from World at War into Silencio and then GSOE.

    I can’t imagine it makes sense but this is also the same band that did Vertigo into Streets at the sphere haha πŸ™ƒ
  9. Originally posted by Bonoboy92:[..]
    If true then that’s going to make for a really jarring listening experience going from World at War into Silencio and then GSOE.

    I can’t imagine it makes sense but this is also the same band that did Vertigo into Streets at the sphere haha πŸ™ƒ
    Will have to get up and flip the record after “Silencio” lol. πŸ™‚