Originally posted by Zwervervriend:People hear what they want to hear. After Berlin 2018 a lot of people said it was their last show (incl myself tbh) but it became clear pretty fast that was not the case.
Bono pondered the same in his memoir, didn't he? So you were in good company. I think the reality is - none of us are getting any younger, myself included, and you can't always predict for or plan the future. That's not intended to sound morbid or negative, it's just... we've been so incredibly lucky, and I think we're perhaps being a bit unrealistic wanting to know precisely what is going to happen next. We've all been extremely spoilt by having our favourite band consistently in our lives for 50 years - and they're still here, new album, new tour - if this was in a movie, everybody would scoff and find it completely unrealistic. Also worth considering what Larry said in the Zane Lowe interview - there isn't a 'formula' for what they do - so it's impossible for them to predict what's next.
Edge to Zane Lowe: One of the main themes I think of of the record is acknowledgment that certain things are coming to an end. And that you can look at that as a very fearful and an anxiety inducing reality or you can see it as the opportunity for something new to come.
Bono: The greatest show on earth is is about the end of something and and a kind of mourning . . . in terms of the storytelling you start with the end, then you retell it.
I don't think they're "saying goodbye" but talking about how everything is coming to an end all the time - everything and everyone is temporary.
They’ve said multiple things about saying goodbye and saying hello. They have done that with Rattle and Hum to Achtung Baby. They all seem in a very good spot and seem excited for the future. I think people read way too much into things including Larry’s comment about how long he can drum. Larry would not have risked that surgery for just one more album and tour. They recently re did all the U2.com website and that would not have happened for just one more album and tour. Also if this is the planned ending I can almost guarantee they would advertise it as that instead of not saying anything about it
Originally posted by cmkuz1:They’ve said multiple things about saying goodbye and saying hello. They have done that with Rattle and Hum to Achtung Baby. They all seem in a very good spot and seem excited for the future. I think people read way too much into things including Larry’s comment about how long he can drum. Larry would not have risked that surgery for just one more album and tour. They recently re did all the U2.com website and that would not have happened for just one more album and tour. Also if this is the planned ending I can almost guarantee they would advertise it as that instead of not saying anything about it
Exactly, we can't read too much into that as such. Only a few years ago people were speculating Larry was probably leaving U2.
On a personal note only a couple of weeks ago I got my head bitten off in a forum chat for suggesting the tour might or might not be called TGSOE. Oh no they said, it's gonna be called Carnaval they said. π
The band will finish when they physically have to most probably, I think the next few years for them are going to be interesting.
An artist's urge to scratch the itch won't stop, especially for U2 , you have bands like bon jovi who never stoped touring and bands like u2 who come then go then comeback again
Aerosmith announced the end and then came back, you never really know when a band is truly done, but U2 seems like a band that still has a lot of music yet to see the light of day
If this album lives up to the generally very strong early reviews/reactions (a big if still…) the greatest gift U2 could give us is this massive world tour through 2028 and then gracefully say goodbye. End on a high note. Bow out with grace.
Originally posted by ap5:If this album lives up to the generally very strong early reviews/reactions (a big if still…) the greatest gift U2 could give us is this massive world tour through 2028 and then gracefully say goodbye. End on a high note. Bow out with grace.
Honestly don’t think they are planning any sort of ending.
Edge and Bono have both suggested they are going to keep on going with Edge saying he could see them still giving performances into their 80s. Larry was told to retire and chose to have surgery to attempt to return to drumming with U2. He seems to be enjoying being back. Adam was recently asked about comments he made back about 15 years ago where he said he didn’t see playing into his 70s. Wasn’t a direct answer, but he also didn’t say he was retiring.
There’s already plans afoot for a next album, and even some work done on it. There’s talk of an arena tour down the road as well. Adam mentioned this cycle would take them to 2030 so those plans probably include whatever they have planned now. With U2 that could take a few years longer as we all know.
One of the big drivers of this end of the band talk here is Dublin being the end of the tour - but if you go to U2Com where the statement is, it reads more that Dublin is the end of the second European leg. And there are rumours that there will be another leg that follows Europe.
The other big driver is Bono’s talk that the album is about endings. It is. In a number of ways. But don’t think it’s literally an album about the band saying goodbye. Loss of innocence and youth. Saying goodbye to the world we thought we were living in and waking up to a new reality. Saying goodbye to family over politics. And some rebirth as well. Trying to take the light back.
Will the work slow down? It already has. But I suspect as long as the health is good, and that they can do more they’ll come back to it.
Do we even want to see U2 performing in their 80s?? Not me.
They’ll tour Carnaval for 2-3 years. I get the vibe that the irish sci-fi project and Songs of Ascent aren’t albums meant for big world tours. I don’t even think they want to release Ascent anytime soon, it’s become a running gag everytime they do promo for the next album- but it will be released someday.
I think after Carnaval, U2 has 1 more “world” tour in them for whatever album that is. Eno Sci-fi is released in between Carnaval and the next big album. Songs of Ascent is released as the final goodbye. If U2 calls it done after 2035, I will accept it because it’s been an amazing 60 years.
I also don’t want to see them play without Larry again.