1. Has anyone pre-ordered from U2.com? I can't figure out if they're intending to ship CDL so it arrives on release day.
  2. I didn't order from U2.com, because they NEVER ship in time to arrive on release day. In the past, i ordered IE Live from Paris and SOS Chrystal Clear Vinyl. Both arrived a couple of weeks later than release date
  3. Originally posted by Zwervervriend:[..]
    I didn't order from U2.com, because they NEVER ship in time to arrive on release day. In the past, i ordered IE Live from Paris and SOS Chrystal Clear Vinyl. Both arrived a couple of weeks later than release date
    Same. I did that for the Fontaines album and it shipped on release day lol. So I'm just going to buy in a shop, ideally they have the full EP and album set
  4. Oh dear! Lesson learned. I did at least get to use my 25% off discount as a subscriber
  5. From someone in Australia who listened to CDL:

    Spoiler (click to toggle)


    Initial thoughts:

    I think a lot of long time fans will be happy. ❤️ (I am).



    There are sounds that take me to The Unforgettable Fire era, some that echoed tracks of Achtung Baby… and others that sound very early career.



    Some tracks sound quintessentially U2 and others are the band pushing into new territory. I thought there were more harmonies/vocal effects than I’m used to hearing too.



    On first listen, my standouts were Midnight Sunshine (I have a sweet spot for U2’s track 10 songs - ultra violet, breathe, original of the species , exit etc), The Greatest Show on Earth, Superficiality, Glorify (great to hear this and remember the outro at the Sphere shows) and probably If The World Is At War We Better Not Be.



    Listening to it in a professional recording studio in Dolby atmos was a next level treat. It just wish I had the lyric sheet to read as I listened.



    Obviously I’m not a music critic and I’m very biased but that’s my first impression.

  6. Originally posted by iamcrazytonight:From someone in Australia who listened to CDL:

    Spoiler (click to toggle)


    Initial thoughts:

    I think a lot of long time fans will be happy. ❤️ (I am).



    There are sounds that take me to The Unforgettable Fire era, some that echoed tracks of Achtung Baby… and others that sound very early career.



    Some tracks sound quintessentially U2 and others are the band pushing into new territory. I thought there were more harmonies/vocal effects than I’m used to hearing too.



    On first listen, my standouts were Midnight Sunshine (I have a sweet spot for U2’s track 10 songs - ultra violet, breathe, original of the species , exit etc), The Greatest Show on Earth, Superficiality, Glorify (great to hear this and remember the outro at the Sphere shows) and probably If The World Is At War We Better Not Be.



    Listening to it in a professional recording studio in Dolby atmos was a next level treat. It just wish I had the lyric sheet to read as I listened.



    Obviously I’m not a music critic and I’m very biased but that’s my first impression.

    Interesting and thoughtful review, and lucky them getting to hear it early and in a professional studio.

    Love the thoughts around 'track 10 songs' and the ones he's mentioned are brilliant examples. This has to be a future topic, surely.
  7. I think it is the worst review i have seen yet...

    https://www.pastemagazine.com/music/u2-carnaval-de-luz-review


    "pedantic and ambiguous, rife with centrist pandering that ends up saying nothing at all."
    forgettable songwriting, uninspired instrumentation, hollow optimism, and clichéd lyrics, arguing that the band relied too heavily on grandiose production and familiar musical formulas while trying to deliver vague political commentary and "crowdpleasing platitudes" that ultimately said little of substance.

    failed Dolly Parton-U2 collab, calling it a "real tragedy that this ended up becoming one of the final recorded vocal performances from Parton, a legend whose legacy deserves so much better."
    Furthermore, Sharples saw U2's awkward attempts at incorporating Spanish into the songs as a real misfire. He also thought the songs sounded more like generic commercial music (ie. Imagine Dragons) than inspired rock music. To sum things up, the new album is a hot mess.

    The takeaway:

    "Whereas U2’s greatest songs have indelible hooks that feel as big as the set dressing around them, the songs on Carnaval De Luz consist of nothing but set dressing. Some of the signifiers are there: you’ve got the Edge’s unmistakable guitar tone and Bono’s ubiquitous vocals, but those signifiers have nothing to latch on to. This new record seems like nothing more than an excuse to commemorate the band’s fiftieth anniversary. If only the celebration actually sounded like one."


    In less than three days, "Carnaval de Luz" will be released worldwide. Based on what you've already heard via "Street of Dreams," "Silencio," and "The Greatest Show on Earth," are you worried this review might be more honest about the new album than many of the four star reviews you've already seen/read?


    #U2 #CarnavalDeLuz #pastemagazine #grantsharples #thegreatestshowonearth #StreetOfDreams #silencio #dollyparton
  8. The review was discussed in this topic already, go back a few pages.
  9. Would ignore that review that is just someone who has a dislike of the band
  10. I wouldn't believe all the positive reviews. Let's wait and see what it's like. Fingers crossed it is good but SOE had many 4 star reviews etc...