Originally posted by hedyzera:[..]
I'll listen again at midnight, but the ones I mentioned like that are the ones I really can't see improving over time, Summer of Love is an example of one from SOE that just never captivated me since the first time I heard it
Initial listens have me thinking that this is the strongest album since ATYCLB (with this being more consistent but lacking that album’s strong A side). I’m not loving The Mirror Maker (which sounds like American Soul coming back to haunt us) and Can’t Stop Us Now (which sounds like a mashup of an AB outtake and a Queen B side) but other than that, it’s excellent and fresh. I was expecting more from Torn, based on press previews (TGSOE > Torn).
An arena tour with predominantly CDL material would’ve been very interesting! Roll on the vinyl of this arriving asap
go (carnaval de luz) - weird U2 is the best U2. most likely gonna be the tour opener. kinda short, would have liked at least a 3 min song.
la reina - loving the first half of the song. a little bit uncanny-valley for the last minute…fells like 2 demos mashed together. it picks up in the end when the full band comes back.
sod - never really been a fan of the intro. when it kicks off with the chorus it’s just an ok U2 song for me. would probably add it to my U2 playlist but skip it pretty much any time it pops up, just like Miracle of Joey Ramone.
mirror maker - catchy tune. loving the riff, the bass, the drums…bono’s voice seems like it could really shine more, but it seems to me as if he’s holding back.
supericiality - not really my favourite. i feel like it’s pretty weirdly mixed? i feel like the vocals - instruments don’t really blend together in a organic mix. feels as if the vocal volume is louder than the instruments. might be just me. more of a pop song. it will maybe grow on me on later listens.
if the world is at war we better not be - the 2 minute mark vocal effect kills me. it seems weird that the effect is only used for a couple of lines and then abandoned. weird choice for my taste.
silencio - Rock U2. loved it since it was launched. would have loved it to be at least 3 mins long.
the greatest show on earth - the best song on the album. just like The Little Things That Give You Away was the diamond from SOE. amazing song.
glorify - i can’t help wonder how this would sound with a full-band setup. seems like it’s a little diluted/stripped down version. would love to hear a more “full” version.
midnight sunshine - again, not my favourite along with superficiality. maybe if will grow on me over time.
can’t stop us now - Breathe 2. at least the drum part reminds me of NLOTH’s Breathe.
torn - feel like the lyrics are a bit repetitie? at least on the chorus. not really a fan of this and not sure if it really works as a closer for the album.
all in all, i think it’s a solid record. a blend of the experimental POP-era with some Elevation/Vertigo-coded-era songs, sprinkled with a bit of SOS-era. I feel as if some songs would work better with a slightly different mix? And also I get the feeling that Bono is really not using his full vocal potential, except on TGSOE. we’ll see how the songs fly-off in the live-tour-versions. i do think that the Easter Lilly and Days of Ash have stronger songs. But i'm always happy getting a new U2 record.
Just had my first listen. I need to listen to it more times. I feel like it's going to grow on me quite a lot. I like it! Not blown away, but I do like it. It sounds familiar, yet new. Conventional, yet experimental. It's interesting. It sounds like almost what I'd expect U2 to sound like with 50 years of experience under their belt; in a way, sonically, it's like a marriage between their past records.