1. I can't listen to Torn all the way through. No disrespect to Dolly and the great things she did and stood for, but her voice sounds like nails on a chalkboard to me here. This should have been a stand along single from Dolly Parton, featuring Bono / U2. It does not fit on Carnaval de Luz IMHO.
  2. I don't think this ends the album on a downer, it has a great message and Dolly's singing is lovely. I understand the sci-fi folk approach too. It's sad in that this is her final vocal performance ever, but what a beautiful song.
  3. Like the song never Saw that happen on a u2 album
  4. This song gets slated if Dolly was still with us.
  5. song is very poignant to me (as an american) as I have seen strained and fractured relationships over the past 10 years with friends and family who went down the Trump/MAGA rat hole. And I do expect to see some typical MAGA culture war criticisms of the song and U2 n the coming days.
  6. Edge's work on this is so good.
  7. Originally posted by LostSailor:I can't listen to Torn all the way through. No disrespect to Dolly and the great things she did and stood for, but her voice sounds like nails on a chalkboard to me here. This should have been a stand along single from Dolly Parton, featuring Bono / U2. It does not fit on Carnaval de Luz IMHO.
    100% exactly my thoughts. The album should end with Cant Stop Us Now
  8. No this is really great, they know what they're doing. It's The Wanderer, but more heartfelt. The soundscape behind the vocal is immense. Very Joshua Tree. This is a huge ending for the album.
  9. Originally posted by ZooropaMan:No this is really great, they know what they're doing. It's The Wanderer, but more heartfelt. The soundscape behind the vocal is immense. Very Joshua Tree. This is a huge ending for the album.
    +1. It’s brilliant
  10. She hit those beautiful notes. Crazy she hit those notes at 80. It's a very beautiful song
  11. Beautiful song. We miss Dolly Parton