1. Originally posted by struukangeren:Unpopular opinion, but I’m finding the album really disappointing after listening to it a few times.
    Then again, I’ve had that happen before with U2 albums; perhaps it will grow on me after a few more attentive listens.
    Jammer, wou je net een GA voor Lisbon 2 slijten πŸ™‚
  2. I was just reading the Jackknife Lee interview in Propoganda and I have to say having listened to CdL twice today I feel quite moved by what we have been given this year.

    It is clear from the interview that there was a question mark as to whether Larry would be able to play again in any capacity. I think the fact that this record and EPs exist at all is testament to some great strength and dedication not just from Larry but from all of the members of U2 and their wider creative team.

    It is also clear from the interview that they have been working incredibly hard in recent years to realise this concept. The album wasn’t finished when they decided to work on the EPs and they were still working on Torn up until the vinyl deadline in June (doesn’t sound like U2 at all?!).

    I think there is a huge amount to take in and enjoy over 24/25 songs (if you include Fireflies). It’s U2 we are talking about so of course there are going to be some mis-steps but for me apart from Yours Eternally there is nothing downright embarrassing.

    If I’m being honest there are probably 3 really strong EPs here (c.18 songs) - I think the Financial Times reviewer said something similar - however the songs that I would put on those EPs would be different to everyone else. Just because I’m not wild on Yours Eternally (or Midnight Sunshine) doesn’t mean that others don’t really love those songs - I really like Song Of The Future and that might not be everyone’s favourite and that’s just fine.

    I think (most of us) probably agree that GSOE is one of their best songs period and I think there are some really strong songs over the 3 releases. On first few listens to CdL I find Torn very affecting.

    The joy of streaming is that we can all make our favourite CdL album now anyway. The band have given us 24 songs - you choose your 12. Make that your album. As they’ve always said when the songs are released they are no longer their property. They go on to live in the lives of us as fans and our own unique and powerful connection to them.

    I think what I like about the record(s), and Jacknife picks up on this - is the references in the sounds and music that are unmistakably U2 from across their career and how they’ve managed to incorporate them and make them sound both fresh and familiar.

    I think we as fans can expect too much it doesn’t mean we can’t or shouldn’t critique however these 4 men do not need to do this. They are wealthy beyond our imaginings. They could if they felt they needed to take a much easier course of action but they want to do it the hard way. They want (like all of us) to matter in some way and they’ve clearly put a lot of themselves into this and they are about to dedicate the next 2 years to playing these songs to countless thousands around the world. These are not going men. They are in the Edges case grand dads. As I’ve said before I find this 50 year celebration extraordinary. What a wonderful story and journey & long may it continue.
  3. Also, where is the edge on this album? He hasn’t come up with anything memorable or innovative at all, really poor
  4. One amazing song (TGSOE), and that’s already more than I expected. I also really like Torn for the lyrics.

    As with everything they’ve released since 2004, too much of it won’t stand the test of time for me. The comparisons to their great older songs don’t work for me either. When I see people mention classics like Zoo Station and EBTTRT, I just smile and shake my head.

    But... super happy with TGSOE!! πŸ˜ƒ
  5. I had the same yesterday. There's no clear-out outstanding guitar solo.
  6. Does he ever do anything flamboyant on record though? There is room to grow when these songs get the love treatment.

    He has regressed though. Lots of little short repetitive riffs.
  7. It's more Adam's record

  8. I wondered about that. I was surprised that the Deluxe Edition on Spotify didn't have the order of the discs arranged like that
  9. Def felt this. I'm very much a Bono guy so can sometimes miss the instruments - but this one so clearly has him shining.

    Off to try and find the triple boxset in a shop.. the novelty!
  10. Maybe now solos out front, but definitely some interesting guitar work and licks overall, just not front and centre?
  11. Random request..... can someone send me a photo of the thank you notes from the booklet? I'm not receiving my album for another few days and I always enjoy reading them for some reason πŸ˜‚
  12. Originally posted by Reach1985:I was just reading the Jackknife Lee interview in Propoganda and I have to say having listened to CdL twice today I feel quite moved by what we have been given this year.

    It is clear from the interview that there was a question mark as to whether Larry would be able to play again in any capacity. I think the fact that this record and EPs exist at all is testament to some great strength and dedication not just from Larry but from all of the members of U2 and their wider creative team.

    It is also clear from the interview that they have been working incredibly hard in recent years to realise this concept. The album wasn’t finished when they decided to work on the EPs and they were still working on Torn up until the vinyl deadline in June (doesn’t sound like U2 at all?!).

    I think there is a huge amount to take in and enjoy over 24/25 songs (if you include Fireflies). It’s U2 we are talking about so of course there are going to be some mis-steps but for me apart from Yours Eternally there is nothing downright embarrassing.

    If I’m being honest there are probably 3 really strong EPs here (c.18 songs) - I think the Financial Times reviewer said something similar - however the songs that I would put on those EPs would be different to everyone else. Just because I’m not wild on Yours Eternally (or Midnight Sunshine) doesn’t mean that others don’t really love those songs - I really like Song Of The Future and that might not be everyone’s favourite and that’s just fine.

    I think (most of us) probably agree that GSOE is one of their best songs period and I think there are some really strong songs over the 3 releases. On first few listens to CdL I find Torn very affecting.

    The joy of streaming is that we can all make our favourite CdL album now anyway. The band have given us 24 songs - you choose your 12. Make that your album. As they’ve always said when the songs are released they are no longer their property. They go on to live in the lives of us as fans and our own unique and powerful connection to them.

    I think what I like about the record(s), and Jacknife picks up on this - is the references in the sounds and music that are unmistakably U2 from across their career and how they’ve managed to incorporate them and make them sound both fresh and familiar.

    I think we as fans can expect too much it doesn’t mean we can’t or shouldn’t critique however these 4 men do not need to do this. They are wealthy beyond our imaginings. They could if they felt they needed to take a much easier course of action but they want to do it the hard way. They want (like all of us) to matter in some way and they’ve clearly put a lot of themselves into this and they are about to dedicate the next 2 years to playing these songs to countless thousands around the world. These are not going men. They are in the Edges case grand dads. As I’ve said before I find this 50 year celebration extraordinary. What a wonderful story and journey & long may it continue.
    Not sure why everyone seems so stuck on albums having to adhere to 12 songs. I like making 80 minute cds. Sometimes it's a solid 80 minutes, sometimes it's 55 minutes, and I classify the last 25 minutes as bonus tracks. With Songs Of Carnival, and Songs Of Easter Ash, they have achieved what I wanted. I just wanted a few great songs, and multiple good ones. The only filler to me is Coexist and Yours Eternally. Easter Parade is decent filler, but mostly a skip for me. The industry has already dictated that album length adhere to vinyl standards in the industry's quest to kill off the cd. A shame.