1. I'm jumping back in here to say that Carnaval de Luz is a masterpiece. This is the U2 promised (but never realized) way back in Night and Day and the AB outtakes.

    I hear lightness and joy, depth and light, and a band that sounds like they're having fun. There's so much delight and surprise for me on listening to this. Start to finish I find this the best thing they've released in forever.

    This is the music that might have naturally come out of their 90s work if they hadn't got sidetracked with trying to make crowd-pleasing anthem dad-rock.

    U2 Ole!
  2. This album will probably end up somewhere in the middle of the pack for me, but it definitely has a lot going for it and a lot going on to digest. In broad buckets…

    Tracks I am definitely coming back to:
    Go
    La Reina
    Mirror Maker
    TGSOE
    Glorify
    Can’t Stop Us Now
    Get Back to Now
    Silencio

    Tracks I’m not sure of:
    If the World is at War
    Midnight Sunshine
    Torn (all 3 versions, but more favorable to Kent Wells version)

    Tracks I just don’t think will ever work for me:
    SOD
    Superficiality
  3. It is definitely a diverse album, not immediately clear on a first listen, and it certainly deserves more than one, if not two or three. It feels to me like they wanted to bring back the Achtung Baby formula, surprising fans and the audience right from the start with the most experimental track on the record, very much in the style of Zooropa or Pop.
    At the moment, the main problem with the album seems to be the lack of a clear, single direction: at times it leans toward experimentation, and at others toward their classic pop-rock formula in the style of their previous albums.
    There are definitely some highlights, including Go, La Reina (even though it's too inspired by EBTTRT), The Mirror Maker (aside from Bono's nonsense in the pre-chorus), and the transition between Superficiality and Bono’s almost spoken-word interlude where he reflects on the band and its 50 years.
    The best song remains The Greatest Show On Earth, a strong, powerful, emotional track where Brian Eno leads the band to bring back an atmosphere that recalls their '84–'87 masterpieces. It's the most successful piece, along with Can’t Stop Us Now, also with Brian Eno (I wonder why).
    Glorify appears in this "stripped" version, which isn't horrible, though. Still, maybe the 2023 version, if properly finished, would have been better—and even the best song on the record.
    The album closes with Torn, an unexpected duet with Dolly Parton and Bono emotionally chasing a story about two brothers who hate each other (?).
    To sum it up, it's definitely an interesting album—the first time they have released such a diverse record worth exploring in depth since NLOTH. However, I couldn't quite figure out the goal of this "carnival": experimenting (tracks 1, 2) or the usual 2010s-style pop-rock approach? I don't know how to feel about this record yet, though I will definitely have clearer ideas after a second or third listen.
  4. This is perfect. 10 songs, no more, no less.

    Go
    La Reina
    Mirror Maker
    Superficiality
    If The World Is At War
    Greatest Show On Earth
    Glorify
    Midnight Sunshine
    Can't Stop Us Now
    Torn
  5. Originally posted by juandicorrea:This is perfect. 10 songs, no more, no less.

    Go
    La Reina
    Mirror Maker
    Superficiality
    If The World Is At War
    Greatest Show On Earth
    Glorify
    Midnight Sunshine
    Can't Stop Us Now
    Torn
    I just "hid" SOD and Silencio
  6. este album ha despertado mi deseo de un album con Brian Eno
  7. Regardless of if we like them or not, all songs are going to work great live
  8. TGSOE the song has taken on new meanings surrounded by its 11 or 12 siblings.
  9. Cool thing is we have 24 songs to make our own run list and album
    Nice problem to have
  10. I think we will need to sit with Carnaval de Luz for more than a day before we have a sense of how it stacks up against their other albums, but I think the deluxe version of this album contains the best stuff they have done in decades. For the last twenty-five years, I have been hearing the following complaints about later U2 albums:

    1. They are following the same formula (e.g. All That and forward is basically the same album). This album is innovative and different. I love Damasio's comments about how they have been influenced by recent bands like Fontaines D.C. and Geese. I have been waiting for a different kind of album from them for years (what they tried to do with No Line) and this is it.
    2. There are a few lyrically cringe-inducing songs that ruin the album (e.g. Yahweh and Love and Peace or Else on Atomic Bomb, Boots and Stand-Up Comedy on No Line, California on Songs of Innocence, American Soul, Get Out of Your Own Way, and The Blackout on Songs of Experience). With the exception perhaps of the line about not giving up on your dreams in SOD, I don't really feel that on this album. Superficiality is fine -- light, playful, and fun lyrics alongside a great tune.
    3. There is not a cohesive theme that unifies a disparate group of songs (the chief complaint about Atomic Bomb). Carnaval, together with the two EPs, may be their most thematically cohesive project yet.
    4. Lack of great or "classic" U2 Songs. Greatest Show on Earth, Tears of Things, Torn, Glorify are destined to be U2 classics, and there's also La Reina, Songs of Hal, In a Life, Scars, One Life at a Time, and so many other great and really emotionally resonant songs across the three discs.

    So I don't see Carnaval de Luz as having the flaws that have accompanied all the other albums that we have heard by them this century. The other thing that often affects our evaluation of an album long-term are the tour that accompanies it and the place it plays in the cultural zeitgeist. We will have to see that, but the message of defiant hope and joy on Carnaval, combined with the combination of protest and spiritual transcendence on the EPs, means quite a bit to me listening to this in America right now (the transition between "Torn" and "American Obituary" really hits in the gut). Carnaval is the perfect thing to listen to after the midterm elections -- so it is a timely album at least.

    I don't really know what I will think of this album in two years time in comparison to all the other u2 albums I love, but this is my ranking of them at the moment:

    1. Joshua Tree
    2. Achtung Baby
    3. War
    4. Carnaval de Luz (Deluxe version)
    5. All That You Can't Leave Behind /Unforgettable Fire (tie)
    6. Pop
    7. Atomic Bomb
    8. Boy
    9. Zooropa
    10. Rattle and Hum
    11. No Line on the Horizon
    12. Songs of Innocence
    13. October
    14. Songs of Experience
    15. Passengers
  11. Don’t know if it’s only me but I think that the album is somewhat strangely sequenced. Just a little tinkering would help it flow better imho. First of all I’d put CSUN as the opener of Side B and change places with GSOE. It would help both songs as CSUN has so much energy that you don’t want to listen to tranquil Torn straight after it and want the album to continue to play. Likewise GSOE, being high point of the album, would sound great as last but one song.

    I’d also put Street Of Dreams after Mirror Maker not before it. I think the first three songs being Go, La Reina and Mirror Maker would be killer as all are in same vein and SOD is a different mood and would fit better with Superficiality.

    I also don’t like the position of Silencio and I think it’s awkward that it closes side A. I don’t know where it should go though.
  12. man i love Go