1. Mirror Maker also sounds like a different mix to me. More atmospheric and less garage-y

  2. Not bad 👍 both of my main ideas were implemented: Go, La Reina and Mirror Maker are first three songs on the album and GSOE and CSUN switched places.

    I thought I’d miss Song For Hal, In A Life and COEXIST but Hal doesn’t fit and other two already have their very similar counterparts (Scars and CSUN) so they would be redundant.

    My main concern with that playlist would be losing smooth transition between CSUN and Torn. Maybe use one of the other two versions of Torn instead of the album version?
  3. 1. Achtung Baby
    2. Joshua Tree
    3. All That You Can’t Leave Behind
    4. Zooropa
    5. How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb
    6. The Unforgettable Fire
    7. Carnival De Luz
    8. Songs Of Innocence
    9. Rattle And Hum
    10. No Line On The Horizon
    11. War
    12. Songs Of Experience
    13. Pop
    14. Boy
    15. October
  4. Originally posted by Damonio123:The most significant change I’ve noticed on this album is that they’ve broken the formula. They typically relied on a song structure like that of "Beautiful Day," "With or Without You," or "Vertigo"—but that’s not really the case here. Tracks like "Go" or "Silencio" are highly unusual for U2; they are not interludes, they are full-fledged songs. Newer Bands: U2 has shifted their approach to song structure on this record. Gone are the epic bridges and the 40-second guitar solos—the kind where it feels like The Edge is about to transport us to paradise. "Silencio" is a prime example; while it’s not necessarily off-putting, those expecting the "old" U2 will need some time to adjust to this new version. Brian Eno: His influence is clear on the tracks he contributed to, pushing the band toward deconstruction—though on this record, it’s taken to the extreme. As The Edge hinted, it’s intentionally chaotic. I would have liked to see Eno take on a more comprehensive role across the entire album. Bono: It’s a nice touch that he uses vocal effects and, at times, speaks in the background—as he does on "The Mirror Maker." On *Songs of Experience*, he was almost always front and center; here, he’s more integrated into the band’s sound, helping to build atmosphere ("Go" is the perfect example). Newer Bands: The influence of groups like Fontaines D.C. explains why U2 decided to shake up their formula. If you were hoping for the kind of "fan service" found in their recent EPs—a nod to the "old" U2—you won’t find it here. The band is driven by an urgent, direct approach: short songs, a prominent bassline, and—to reiterate—a focus on delivering a punch rather than crafting an anthem. Geese: Perhaps the most notable influence; this band often shifts rhythms—sometimes three times in a single track—without any warning. U2 attempts something similar (though not quite to that extreme), and they make no apologies for it. No one would deny the legacy this band has built, but don’t expect that from this album—they’ve decided to adopt the formula used by newer bands (which, for me, is fine, as the EPs were already enough). It’s not that they’ve lost their touch; rather, the band wants to hold its own against these newer acts. The songs have a carnival-like quality—twisted, chaotic, short, and colorful—and if you don’t like one, just wait; an even shorter one is coming up. There’s something here that doesn’t quite sound like U2, yet at the same time, it does; to me, it’s an intriguing attempt to blend their past (think The Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby) with the musical structures of today.


    I personally think Fontaines DC have been an influence on their approach to this record. Not with the sounds or any ideas, just the concept of doing short songs that take in all different directions in a single record.
  5. And also the idea that the vocals are important, but they don’t have to try to overshadow everything the band is trying to do. Sometimes they can just sit with the music and it’s cool.
  6. I think it does not make any sense to rank the albums including CDL on day 1.

    I really like it a lot. So happy with it

    But time will tell, where it gonna be.
  7. Originally posted by Steinbock_1969:I think it does not make any sense to rank the albums including CDL on day 1.

    I really like it a lot. So happy with it

    But time will tell, where it gonna be.
    Personally, I never rank the U2 albums because it never stays that rigid for me.
  8. Originally posted by Steinbock_1969:I think it does not make any sense to rank the albums including CDL on day 1.

    I really like it a lot. So happy with it

    But time will tell, where it gonna be.
    For me, is U2’s best album in over 20 years, though it falls short of being a masterpiece; it contains three filler tracks. In cold, my initial rating: 8/10 (the album’s intent elevates it to an 8—nothing more, nothing less). If they had removed "Street of Dreams" or "Midnight Sunshine," it would be a 8.50. - It’s not a 9 on the level of Achtung Baby; it’s a record that reveals more upon a second or perhaps third—listen.
    Compared to Songs of Experience: That record felt like Bono with U2 as his backing band; here, for the first time in a while, you can truly sense all four members together in the same room. Recall that Experience suffered from an infamous mix where Larry was barely audible, on this album, his presence is clear, as the record was designed with live performance in mind.
    Compared to Songs of Innocence: That was the "museum" album, Dublin, Bono’s mother, which had everything going for it but ultimately fell victim to overproduction (Every Breaking Wave). Carnaval de Luz may lack the lyrical depth of a track like "Iris (Hold Me Close)," but it possesses far more risk and energy. - Compared to No Line on the Horizon: This album comes closest. No Line on the Horizon attempted to be experimental, a vision that largely went misunderstood. compounded by a poor selection of singles (I’ll Go Crazy/Street of Dreams).
    Compared to How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb: This is its true rival. Atomic Bomb features "Vertigo," "City of Blinding Lights," and "Sometimes You Can’t Make It on Your Own" for me, three anthems that Carnaval de Luz lacks, though those tracks were also very much tailored for radio. How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb edges it out, song for song, by a narrow margin. Meanwhile, Carnaval de Luz represents another attempt by U2 to let their guard down, have some fun, and experiment with their sound, even tweaking the formulas they’ve relied on in the past, as I mentioned earlier.

    - Negative points of the album: There are interesting songs, such as "Superficiality," but I doubt in the album this song will be memorable. It’s also strange that, given the existence of the EPs, they didn’t swap some of the tracks around. "Street of Dreams" actually makes more sense when not viewed as a single, though it still suffers from sounding like "U2 on Autopilot." Again, these are good songs, but I don’t think they’ll be particularly memorable…unlike "Midnight Sunshine," the band’s oddest experiment, which I personally didn’t enjoy, even after several listens.
    - Positive points:
    "Greatest Show on Earth": People weren’t lying when they said this would be the standout track; it’s very likely to become a song that’s long remembered.
    - "Glorify": This track grows on you the more chances you give it; it’s hard to imagine anyone disliking it enough to skip it.
    - "Go," "La Reina," and "Silencio": These best represent the shift in structure and formula I mentioned earlier. In short, this is the first U2 album where I feel they didn’t just fall back on "U2 on autopilot"…a very welcome change, especially after they completely lost their identity on what was arguably their worst album ever: Songs of Experience. They’ve embraced structural shifts, avoided simply repeating the "classic U2" sound found on Easter Lily, and, much like Fontaines D.C. moved away from a "copy-and-paste" approach that at the end, it sounds fun.


  9. You’ve just helped me connect Alex descends into hell with Resurrection song, the minor to the major chords (easter weekend). So cool!
  10. Nice AI reponses 😂
  11. Do I sound Superficial(ity)? Haha