1. La Reina and CSUN are my two standout tracks for now.
  2. After listening a third time, I'm sorry but it's not good at all. The Greatest Show on Earth is amazing, but (almost) everything else is mehh (La Reina) or very, very, very bad (Superficiality).

    Disappointed and a (bit) suprised after the two LP's. ☹️
  3. I now think that CdL only makes sense as part of a trilogy of releases and this is the way it should be heard. Alone how it was sequenced makes no sense and it includes some songs that it could get rid of. But listened to like Beatles’ White Album it is actually fantastic and it suddenly all makes sense. It’s a very interesting and clever way to put out a covert double album!

    If you don’t have time to listen to the whole thing, it’s better to make a playlist with most songs from CdL and some songs from EPs than listening to CdL alone, but otherwise only listen to deluxe 24-song album, it’s a wholly different experience. And in this form it will rank much higher on my list of U2 albums as well.

  4. surely someone made this and dedicated it to me.
  5. WAIT A MINUTE U2 forgot to upload the lyric videos
  6. I honestly think between the 3 releases this year they’ve got something pretty special. A top 10 would make a brilliant album. There are a few songs that it’s hard to tell where they’ll sit in years to come but I feel like I could easily pick 10 songs that I’m confident will still sound strong in years to come.
  7. Hear me out. The first 50 seconds of "Go" are taken straight from Deep Purple's "Highway Star."
  8. Originally posted by tuf392664:I honestly think between the 3 releases this year they’ve got something pretty special. A top 10 would make a brilliant album. There are a few songs that it’s hard to tell where they’ll sit in years to come but I feel like I could easily pick 10 songs that I’m confident will still sound strong in years to come.
    They keep making poor decisions , but that's indicative of things post Paul McGuinness.
  9. CARNAVAL DE LUZ: My thoughts on the new album

    As a U2 fan of 20 years, someone who first discovered them by seeing them outside the stadium where they were performing back in 2006, who had tickets for the 360° Tour but was too young to attend, and who has only managed to see them perform live inside a venue once, back in 2017…

    I think it’s time to show my claws and share my thoughts on the new album, “Carnaval de Luz.”

    1. Go (Carnaval de Luz)

    It reminds me a lot of songs like “Zoo Station”, “Mofo”, and maybe a little bit of “The Blackout”.
    It’s definitely better than I expected, but it’s way too short. A guitar solo would’ve been great.

    2. La Reina

    We had already heard this one at the end of the 2016 Fender promo video for The Edge’s signature guitar.

    It has some roots in “Blow Your House Down”, with a little bit of “Even Better Than the Real Thing”.
    It’s got a great vibe, and I really hope we get to see it performed during the 2027 tour.

    3. Street of Dreams

    Oh boy, what a controversial song this has turned out to be.
    Well, sorry to all the haters, but I think this song is incredible.

    First of all, my seven-year-old daughter absolutely loves it.
    She’s been making me play it several times a day ever since it came out.

    As a father, that makes me genuinely happy.
    It’s wonderful knowing that U2 managed to connect with my little girl.

    As a Coldplay and OneRepublic fan as well, I have to say there’s nothing wrong with pop music.
    As long as it’s good pop, bring it on!

    Stop hating on this song.
    Eventually, you’ll all be singing along to it on tour anyway.
    Stop pretending to be purists who only want obscure deep cuts.

    4. The Mirror Maker (Rosalía)

    I have to admit that I wasn’t feeling this song at all when I first heard the snippet a few days before its release.
    The idea of singing a song to Rosalía felt a little cringe to me.

    But after listening to it several times, I’m actually glad to hear Jacknife Lee’s influence.
    It brings back memories of “Fast Cars”.

    It’s a good song. It’s got a nice groove, it’s enjoyable, and it doesn’t get boring.

    5. Superficiality

    Look, this is a great song, and one where The Edge’s guitar really holds everything together.
    It reminds me of the October and War era.

    I love that feeling of euphoria in the chorus, bringing to mind songs like “Beautiful Day”.

    It’s euphoric and danceable at the same time.
    I absolutely love it.

    6. If the World Is At War We Better Not Be

    I feel like this works as an interlude leading into “Silencio”, while also serving as the reflective moment of the album.

    My only issue is that the title is ridiculously long for such a short song.
    A little unnecessary, if you ask me.

    7. Silencio

    Another song that seems to have a lot of haters.
    Once again, my daughter is completely in love with this one.
    It’s almost as if U2 wanted to experiment with some garage rock.

    Actually, let’s put it this way: imagine “Vertigo” mixed with “Volcano”, and you get something raw, direct, and straight to the point.

    I can’t wait to hear this one live. Every time I play it, it makes me want to pick up my guitar and play. (I’m a guitarist, by the way.)

    8. The Greatest Show On Earth

    My favorite song on the entire album.
    It brings me so much joy and excitement every time I play it.

    Bono’s voice roars like a lion.
    The Edge gives us those beautiful atmospheric guitar riffs.
    Adam and Larry, as always, bring the adrenaline at exactly the right moments.

    I’m a huge fan of songs like:

    * The Little Things That Give You Away
    * The Luckiest Man in the World
    * Book of Your Heart
    * City of Blinding Lights
    * Please

    And I genuinely believe this song is going to join that special club of U2 songs that make you feel hopeful about life.

    Honestly, U2 absolutely nailed this one.
    BRAVO!

    9. Glorify

    Honestly, why lie? I was expecting something much more dance-oriented, more heavily produced, with Adam and Larry bringing all the punch, and The Edge giving us a massive guitar sound.

    But apparently, we got the Songs of Surrender version instead.
    It’s not a bad song, but it could’ve been so much better.

    10. Midnight Sunshine

    After almost ten listens, believe me, this song still hasn’t stuck with me.
    It’s just not the kind of style U2 usually explores very often.

    It’s not bad, but nothing about it stays in my head.

    Let’s put it this way: if they had left it off the album, nothing would’ve changed for me.
    Sorry, Bono.

    11. Can’t Stop Us Now

    I like it.
    Very Zooropa.
    But at the same time, it has its own original touch.

    It’s an absolute ride of a song.
    Even though the chorus is slow, it’s incredibly catchy. I’m really looking forward to seeing this one performed live next year.

    12. Torn

    This is where everything comes together.
    A quiet, reflective ending.
    A moment where life gets serious and makes us stop and think about the relationships and connections we have with others.

    13. Get Back to Now

    In my entire damn life, I’ve never bought a digital version of an album, but look at me now, consuming whatever U2 puts in front of me.

    I actually think this would’ve worked much better as the closing track on the standard edition of CdL, with “Midnight Sunshine” left off instead.

    The Edge shines once again.
    It reminds me of “One Tree Hill”.
    A beautiful song.

    - Bonus tracks -

    > Days of Ash

    Honestly, everything’s fine here. Nothing bad, but nothing particularly surprising either.
    And then there’s “The Tears of Things”.
    What a great track!

    > Easter Lily

    Perfect from beginning to end.

    Looking back at 2026…
    By the end of the year, we’ll have 26 new U2 songs:

    * Carnaval de Luz: 12
    * Bonus track: 1
    * Days of Ash: 6
    * Easter Lily: 6
    * Plus “Fireflies”.

    I feel genuinely happy about everything U2 has given us this year.

    * 2 EPs
    * 1 collaboration
    * 1 new studio album
    * 1 new tour

    Let’s enjoy our band as they celebrate their 50th anniversary!

    Long live U2! ❤️
  10. I am really enjoying the album. Have listened to it a few times all the way through and keep hearing new things I didn’t catch before with each listen.

    My buddy, who is a casual U2 fan, listened to the album with me and his immediate thoughts were that it was very good and that the album had a good amount of “drive” and “force” behind it. He rated it pretty high after one listen.

    Overall I think it sounds fresh and has more depth and feel to it than some are realizing. A great mix of fun, joy, sadness, hope, and introspection. I am excited every time I start the album to hear it again.

    Great job U2!!