1. Hard to believe the differences of opinions on this one.

    I'm gonna play the "fan since 1984" card. Sorry!

    I think this is a fantastic record, start to finish.

    What I most love is how surprising and different the sound is. Back in the glory days, each new U2 release was a surprise, sounding nothing like the U2 we thought we knew, while still sounding like U2/expanding our sense of what U2 music sounded like. This record is the first time since ATYCLB that I have had that old, wonderful experience.

    I'm gonna get killed for this opinion, but I don't think GSOE is the best song on the album. It's the best "U2" song in that it revisits and reconfigures classic U2 sounds and gestures in a masterful way. It's a good song, for sure. But it remains grounded (stuck?) in the past (which, I hasten to add, is appropriate given its theme).

    This is the first U2 record since Pop or ATYCLB for me that feels like the future. It's light yet deep, playful and masterful, diverse yet unified. Amazing that men in their 60s could sound so fresh and artful. It also perfectly nails the post blue-wave (in the states) hopefulness and "defiant joy." It is very much the record the world needs from U2 right now.

    I think it's a smashing success. I can't listen to it without laughter, smiles, and tears.
  2. I don't realy mind, because i also have the cd version, which is correct. And i don't like Coexist anyway.

    I do hope (but don't expect) a repress, so this incorrect version will be more valueable 💲💲💲💰💰💰😉😉
  3. Originally posted by Zwervervriend:[..]
    I don't realy mind, because i also have the cd version, which is correct. And i don't like Coexist anyway.

    I do hope (but don't expect) a repress, so this incorrect version will be more valueable 💲💲💲💰💰💰😉😉
    A replacement is needed as intended. It’s crazy how bad quality control is these days.
  4. It’s definitely top 5 or 6 for mine. Some songs start of promising but then either meander or they suddenly cut off after 2 and a half minutes ( like Go and Solencio ).

    I wonder who’s idea it was the have these short song lengths?

    I mean it was obviously intended. It works I guess in the albums narrative and song order.

    Again all my fav tracks are the ones that all are over 4 and a so so seconds long.

    The songs needed a chance to breathe.
  5. Originally posted by dstankie:Hard to believe the differences of opinions on this one.

    I'm gonna play the "fan since 1984" card. Sorry!

    I think this is a fantastic record, start to finish.

    What I most love is how surprising and different the sound is. Back in the glory days, each new U2 release was a surprise, sounding nothing like the U2 we thought we knew, while still sounding like U2/expanding our sense of what U2 music sounded like. This record is the first time since ATYCLB that I have had that old, wonderful experience.

    I'm gonna get killed for this opinion, but I don't think GSOE is the best song on the album. It's the best "U2" song in that it revisits and reconfigures classic U2 sounds and gestures in a masterful way. It's a good song, for sure. But it remains grounded (stuck?) in the past (which, I hasten to add, is appropriate given its theme).

    This is the first U2 record since Pop or ATYCLB for me that feels like the future. It's light yet deep, playful and masterful, diverse yet unified. Amazing that men in their 60s could sound so fresh and artful. It also perfectly nails the post blue-wave (in the states) hopefulness and "defiant joy." It is very much the record the world needs from U2 right now.

    I think it's a smashing success. I can't listen to it without laughter, smiles, and tears.
    Agree with everything you have said!
  6. Originally posted by hedyzera:I've listened to the album about 6 times already. It's the same opinion I have about every new album from the band since NLOTH, it's fun to listen to and it has some great songs, but it's far from an epic listen (which in my opinion we haven't had since HTDAAB).

    I believe the band peaked in 2004 and since then they've been releasing good songs on decent albums.



    The bands creative peak was Achtung Baby/Zooropa if we are being honest. Pop & Popmart underperformed in the US and everything since has been an attempt to remain commercially relevant and a big band, and do cash cow tours. I love the new album by the way and I have been on the U2 train since 1983.
  7. I love the record. Some songs more than others, but I have been hearing it all and not skipping any song. Even Street of Dreams has grown on me. The Greatest Show on Earth remains my favorite, but Go, La Reina, Can't Stop Us Now and Glorify are definitely bangers.
  8. Originally posted by dstankie:Hard to believe the differences of opinions on this one.

    I'm gonna play the "fan since 1984" card. Sorry!

    I think this is a fantastic record, start to finish.

    What I most love is how surprising and different the sound is. Back in the glory days, each new U2 release was a surprise, sounding nothing like the U2 we thought we knew, while still sounding like U2/expanding our sense of what U2 music sounded like. This record is the first time since ATYCLB that I have had that old, wonderful experience.

    I'm gonna get killed for this opinion, but I don't think GSOE is the best song on the album. It's the best "U2" song in that it revisits and reconfigures classic U2 sounds and gestures in a masterful way. It's a good song, for sure. But it remains grounded (stuck?) in the past (which, I hasten to add, is appropriate given its theme).

    This is the first U2 record since Pop or ATYCLB for me that feels like the future. It's light yet deep, playful and masterful, diverse yet unified. Amazing that men in their 60s could sound so fresh and artful. It also perfectly nails the post blue-wave (in the states) hopefulness and "defiant joy." It is very much the record the world needs from U2 right now.

    I think it's a smashing success. I can't listen to it without laughter, smiles, and tears.
    Well said. They sound like they’re exploring new ground while still sounding like themselves.
  9. Originally posted by dstankie:Hard to believe the differences of opinions on this one.

    I'm gonna play the "fan since 1984" card. Sorry!

    I think this is a fantastic record, start to finish.

    What I most love is how surprising and different the sound is. Back in the glory days, each new U2 release was a surprise, sounding nothing like the U2 we thought we knew, while still sounding like U2/expanding our sense of what U2 music sounded like. This record is the first time since ATYCLB that I have had that old, wonderful experience.

    I'm gonna get killed for this opinion, but I don't think GSOE is the best song on the album. It's the best "U2" song in that it revisits and reconfigures classic U2 sounds and gestures in a masterful way. It's a good song, for sure. But it remains grounded (stuck?) in the past (which, I hasten to add, is appropriate given its theme).

    This is the first U2 record since Pop or ATYCLB for me that feels like the future. It's light yet deep, playful and masterful, diverse yet unified. Amazing that men in their 60s could sound so fresh and artful. It also perfectly nails the post blue-wave (in the states) hopefulness and "defiant joy." It is very much the record the world needs from U2 right now.

    I think it's a smashing success. I can't listen to it without laughter, smiles, and tears.
    Agreed 👍 I feel the same about this new album and it made me hopeful about the future, whatever it might bring.
  10. I’ve listened to this record many times already in different contexts - alone and with other people, with headphones and on speakers, sober and a few beers in, I’ve also heard songs played on the radio and it just keeps working for me in each of these contexts and keeps revealing new layers. I haven’t made up my mind yet where it sits compared to other albums, but I’m just very happy with it and very grateful that we have a new album of U2 music to keep going back to.


  11. It was not intended. They were going to scrap those songs on the two eps then Bono being Bono saw the whole religious calendar dates ‘thingy’ ( I don’t have a religious bone i my body lol but you all know what I mean ) and they suddenly had a little bit of a plan as they were songs they said months ago did not fit in theme or style to CDL. So no we weren’t meant to buy a 3 part Album.

    Edit : For the record I can’t stand ‘Days of Ash’ but I absolutely LOVE ‘Easter Lily’
  12. I just feel lucky
    50 years on and still great Music from the Boys
    Love the album and EP’s
    The day of ash a bit ordinary
    Some songs better than others
    Production poor sometimes
    Bring on the live shows
    And give all the bonus track please
    Go on u2
    The future is light