1. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:[..]


    It was not intended. They were going to scrap those songs on the two eps then Bono being Bono saw the whole religious calendar dates ‘thingy’ ( I don’t have a religious bone i my body lol but you all know what I mean ) and they suddenly had a little bit of a plan as they were songs they said months ago did not fit in theme or style to CDL. So no we weren’t meant to buy a 3 part Album.

    Edit : For the record I can’t stand ‘Days of Ash’ but I absolutely LOVE ‘Easter Lily’
    We can of course argue from what specific moment in time it became “intended” and what were the reasons for that but the fact is that at some point three separate elements got tweaked to be listened to back to back. It is of course the ringing tone ending COEXIST and starting Go but it is also the way how Torn and American Obituary thematically fit together like a glove and how the album flows together in the vein of White Album when heard as a whole. Even CSUN makes so much more sense as a prelude to even more music, not (almost) closing piece.

    You don’t actually have to “buy a 3 part Album” to hear that as it’s most apparent when you listen to Carnaval de Luz (Deluxe Edition) available on streaming platforms. It’s magnificent and so much better than the sum of its parts! You don’t have to love all of the individual songs to love the whole shebang if you know what I mean. Exactly like The Beatles “White Album”.
  2. I've been listening non-stop in the last 2 days and I almost can't believe I'm saying this but think this might be their best album since Achtung Baby.

    The Mirror Maker (Rosalia) and especially Can't Stop Us Now are KILLER tracks. They're all good though. I love La Reina, Greatest Show, Torn - all the Brian Eno collabs on it are masterful. The ones that don't immediately pop out are sneaky growers that take a few listens to fully appreciate.

    As ever, U2 are ahead of their listeners. That is the mark of great art.

    And this is an aggressively and innovatively produced guitar rock album, it's a cultural moment, great to see U2 somehow regain the peak of their powers.

    One thing worth noting is it's clear that the album is designed to be heard on Dolby Atmos. The stereo hi-res and 16bit feel very crowded compared to the Atmos mix. Definitely recommend everyone to get listening to the Atmos version - Edge's guitars, the delay, the reverb, generally the separation is magnificent. The reduced compression let's everything breathe and Bono's vocal has the full space it needs.
  3. Originally posted by ZooropaMan:I've been listening non-stop in the last 2 days and I almost can't believe I'm saying this but think this might be their best album since Achtung Baby.

    The Mirror Maker (Rosalia) and especially Can't Stop Us Now are KILLER tracks. They're all good though. I love La Reina, Greatest Show, Torn - all the Brian Eno collabs on it are masterful. The ones that don't immediately pop out are sneaky growers that take a few listens to fully appreciate.

    As ever, U2 are ahead of their listeners. That is the mark of great art.

    And this is an aggressively and innovatively produced guitar rock album, it's a cultural moment, great to see U2 somehow regain the peak of their powers.

    One thing worth noting is it's clear that the album is designed to be heard on Dolby Atmos. The stereo hi-res and 16bit feel very crowded compared to the Atmos mix. Definitely recommend everyone to get listening to the Atmos version - Edge's guitars, the delay, the reverb, generally the separation is magnificent. The reduced compression let's everything breathe and Bono's vocal has the full space it needs.
    +1, the atmos. mix across the 24 tracks is awesome.
  4. the deluxe version of CdL is indeed a masterpiece.
  5. Originally posted by dstankie:Hard to believe the differences of opinions on this one.

    I'm gonna play the "fan since 1984" card. Sorry!

    I think this is a fantastic record, start to finish.

    What I most love is how surprising and different the sound is. Back in the glory days, each new U2 release was a surprise, sounding nothing like the U2 we thought we knew, while still sounding like U2/expanding our sense of what U2 music sounded like. This record is the first time since ATYCLB that I have had that old, wonderful experience.

    I'm gonna get killed for this opinion, but I don't think GSOE is the best song on the album. It's the best "U2" song in that it revisits and reconfigures classic U2 sounds and gestures in a masterful way. It's a good song, for sure. But it remains grounded (stuck?) in the past (which, I hasten to add, is appropriate given its theme).

    This is the first U2 record since Pop or ATYCLB for me that feels like the future. It's light yet deep, playful and masterful, diverse yet unified. Amazing that men in their 60s could sound so fresh and artful. It also perfectly nails the post blue-wave (in the states) hopefulness and "defiant joy." It is very much the record the world needs from U2 right now.

    I think it's a smashing success. I can't listen to it without laughter, smiles, and tears.



    this
  6. I should acknowledge a post from a few days ago prior to the live performances of the greatest show on earth where TRISTAN had stated it was a top 10 song and I stated it wasn’t near the top 10. While I’m still of the opinion it isn’t quite a top 10 I think it’s a top 20, that Tate modern performance was something special.
  7. Does anyone know if the new in issue of Propaganda will be available in print and not just on line?
  8. Third listen. Thank God for this.
  9. Just listened to the double album that they wanted to release but thought it not ‘punk rock’ and too ‘prog’ and it’s one hell of a ride. I even found myself really liking some of the tracks from the EPs I’d written off… American Obituary for example which sounds huge after Torn.
  10. Listened multiple times now and normally I would send songs to friends (none U2 fans) to gauge their reaction and show off the quality of the songs. There's really nothing here to pass onto people. Maybe the album is to light for my tastes. Edge really is and has been missing for sometime now