1. Someone posted on here a while ago ( can't remember which thread ) links to the original message boards where fans were commenting on the AB release. Like a time capsule.
  2. We need to listen to this album several hundred times before we can really assess its place in U2's catalogue. But I think when you listen to the whole three discs as a unity it is up there with their 5 or 6 finest works. It's like if you took the best sounds of Pop, Atomic Bomb, and No Line on the Horizon and organized them around the liturgical calendar and the themes of celebration, protest, and transcendence. The whole thing as a whole just feels big and majestic and perfect for the moment. Not quite at the level of JT or AB, but pretty damn good.


  3. When I first heard Achtung Baby, I was not impressed. A bunch of us thought u2 had abandoned being a political band and were just writing stuff that people could dance to. It took a while to grow on me. I remember hearing The Fly on the radio and thinking WFT is this?
  4. Originally posted by mat76:Having listened to the album a few times now I think I preferred the direction and production of the Easter Lily EP. Having said that TGSOE is the best thing they've done in a long time in my opinion. Adam shines on CDL, Bono's lyrics not so much. CDL is a mixed bag for me. I wouldn't be surprised if the tour has become a greatest hits (and possibly farewell) tour by the time it gets to Dublin for the last shows.
    Farewell tour should not cross anyone’s brains. Idk what people are talking about
  5. After a couple of listens to the new record - this record like the EP's doesn't sound forced or trying for pop relevance like at least SOE. CDL is colorful, bright and all over the place in a good way, it does not feel like a retread so much.. The first two songs are currently my favorites but songs like Superficiality and Midnight Sunshine are really growing on me.. This record is of the high quality of the EP's IMO.. back to listening..


  6. I realized every album the band released after ATYCLB divided the fans, so I'm finding this pretty normal.
  7. I would say the fanbase is pretty much 80/20 in favour of the new album.
    For SOE and SOI pretty much 50/50. For NLOH maybe 60/40 for the album. I remember for Bomb and Leave Behind there being more of less universal acclaim in the fanbase
  8. I was wondering where you've been the last couple of days [work] ? So, what are your thoughts on the record ?
  9. Originally posted by dstankie:Hard to believe the differences of opinions on this one.

    I'm gonna play the "fan since 1984" card. Sorry!

    I think this is a fantastic record, start to finish.

    What I most love is how surprising and different the sound is. Back in the glory days, each new U2 release was a surprise, sounding nothing like the U2 we thought we knew, while still sounding like U2/expanding our sense of what U2 music sounded like. This record is the first time since ATYCLB that I have had that old, wonderful experience.

    I'm gonna get killed for this opinion, but I don't think GSOE is the best song on the album. It's the best "U2" song in that it revisits and reconfigures classic U2 sounds and gestures in a masterful way. It's a good song, for sure. But it remains grounded (stuck?) in the past (which, I hasten to add, is appropriate given its theme).

    This is the first U2 record since Pop or ATYCLB for me that feels like the future. It's light yet deep, playful and masterful, diverse yet unified. Amazing that men in their 60s could sound so fresh and artful. It also perfectly nails the post blue-wave (in the states) hopefulness and "defiant joy." It is very much the record the world needs from U2 right now.

    I think it's a smashing success. I can't listen to it without laughter, smiles, and tears.


    THANK YOU! Let’s go! Sound of the Future!
    Happy to hear you’re liking it!!
  10. I personally think it is a fantastic record and was actually surprised how good it sounds. The only song that I am not sure about is SOD. Overall fantastic!
  11. I think this album will take some time for some people to digest. for me, it took long time to like Midnight Sunshine