Originally posted by siblis55:It’s 10 times better than “Pop” in my opinion, “Pop” was rushed out the doors by the record industry and released too close to the starting of their tour, this album is an extension to the two EPS which I think are brilliant
Originally posted by ap5:I absolutely agree with the comparisons to Pop. To me the biggest difference is that Pop was ironic as a title and it was actually a very dark album lyrically and thematically. CDL is actually quite upbeat lyrically and thematically.
Pop is a top 3 U2 album for me. I like a lot of CDL, but admit I generally prefer that darker side of U2.
Originally posted by BonoIsTheMessiah:I still can't figure out if I should view Carnaval de Luz as a single album or as a three-disc album that includes the two EPs. Someone ask Bono for me.
Carnaval de Luz by itself strikes me in quality to be on par with Pop, All That You Can't Leave Behind, and Atomic Bomb (and I think it is their best material since that 1997-2004 period). But with the EPs added there is just something epic about the whole project - defiant joy and hope in the power and practice of resurrection in a cruciform world -- that excites me and captures my imagination a little more than those albums. In the dark we discover midnight sunshine.
The other thing is that the sequence of songs from Silencio to Torn is U2 at their very best -- comparable with the first side of ATYCLB, the first side of War, and maybe even parts of JT and AB. My only complaint is that they might have done a more robust version of Glorify
But I need to listen to this album several hundred times and go see them on tour next year before I know where I place it in the U2 pantheon of albums.
I'm also still waiting to get my physical copy of the CDs -- arriving Friday -- so I don't have my listening of the album interrupted by commercials on Spotify. I need to hear the whole thing as a flow.
My other question is which of these songs should I learn on guitar? I want to quit my job and form a U2 tribute band.