1. Originally posted by Prior86:Its fucking poison at times on here. Unbelievable how people actually get pissed off at times on this. Its a band at the end of the day fuck me. But as stated earlier. Its some laugh to read tho i find it funny


    AGREE! Like I said the band are damned if they do damned if they don't!
    However I will say that if this news is aside and seperate info from what Adam had been talking about 6 months ago I'm actually shocked. The band really has lost its creative spark and rehashing old songs is something that heritage rock acts do to sell albums that newer material won't.

    I have never thought of the band as an heritage act until now.

    Question. I wonder who the pusher of this recent narrative ( soppy love songs for movies / Indian themed collab to sell tickets and boast sales numbers / Netflix BIO / JT 16/19 / rehashed album of back catalogue etc .... ) has been. BONO ? THE EDGE ? GUY? UNIVERSAL RECORDS ? LIVE NATION?

    Curious as to what you guys think ?
  2. Originally posted by marik:[..]
    thanks for what you do.
    I can only imagine how bad it gets, but I hope you can remember- like much in this world at large- for every one voice complaining, there's 100 that enjoy it but it just doesn't get vocalized.



    Thank you for posting this!
  3. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:[..]


    AGREE! Like I said the band are damned if they do damned if they don't!
    However I will say that if this news is aside and seperate info from what Adam had been talking about 6 months ago I'm actually shocked. The band really has lost its creative spark and rehashing old songs is something that heritage rock acts do to sell albums that newer material won't.

    I have never thought of the band as an heritage act until now.

    Question. I wonder who the pusher of this recent narrative ( soppy love songs for movies / Indian themed collab to sell tickets and boast sales numbers / Netflix BIO / JT 16/19 / rehashed album of back catalogue etc .... ) has been. BONO ? THE EDGE ? GUY? UNIVERSAL RECORDS ? LIVE NATION?

    Curious as to what you guys think ?
    Guy Oseary.
  4. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:[..]


    AGREE! Like I said the band are damned if they do damned if they don't!
    However I will say that if this news is aside and seperate info from what Adam had been talking about 6 months ago I'm actually shocked. The band really has lost its creative spark and rehashing old songs is something that heritage rock acts do to sell albums that newer material won't.

    I have never thought of the band as an heritage act until now.

    Question. I wonder who the pusher of this recent narrative ( soppy love songs for movies / Indian themed collab to sell tickets and boast sales numbers / Netflix BIO / JT 16/19 / rehashed album of back catalogue etc .... ) has been. BONO ? THE EDGE ? GUY? UNIVERSAL RECORDS ? LIVE NATION?

    Curious as to what you guys think ?
    If I have to guess I say Guy Oseary and Live Nation. Trying to reinvent old U2 and market to younger audiences.
    Personally, I don't care what cover album U2 release as long as their next album of new material, supposedly a rock album, is released in Spring of '23 and is decent.
  5. Originally posted by LostSailor:[..]
    If I have to guess I say Guy Oseary and Live Nation. Trying to reinvent old U2 and market to younger audiences.
    Personally, I don't care what cover album U2 release as long as their next album of new material, supposedly a rock album, is released in Spring of '23 and is decent.
    Wouldn't be surprised. Guy Oseary has not been good for U2 IMO. Maybe made them lots of $$ but that's about it.
  6. we are very lucky that they keep putting out albums, they are going to do this kind of thing (netflix, album of old songs) when U2 retires
  7. when they are in their 80s this will continue to happen, I saw it coming, but not so soon all this
  8. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:[..]


    AGREE! Like I said the band are damned if they do damned if they don't!
    However I will say that if this news is aside and seperate info from what Adam had been talking about 6 months ago I'm actually shocked. The band really has lost its creative spark and rehashing old songs is something that heritage rock acts do to sell albums that newer material won't.

    I have never thought of the band as an heritage act until now.

    Question. I wonder who the pusher of this recent narrative ( soppy love songs for movies / Indian themed collab to sell tickets and boast sales numbers / Netflix BIO / JT 16/19 / rehashed album of back catalogue etc .... ) has been. BONO ? THE EDGE ? GUY? UNIVERSAL RECORDS ? LIVE NATION?

    Curious as to what you guys think ?
    Just out of interest how would you define a heritage act? I realise I’m probably making the same point here as I have a million times but I still don’t know how a band that continues to release and tour new material playing several songs from the new album can be called a heritage act. They have never stopped working on new material. They release it at a rate comparable to most established artists and they play more songs live from new albums than most established artists and even plenty of younger artists even half their age. I do find it difficult to understand that fans allow the other stuff to outweigh all that in how they define them as a band.
  9. Originally posted by deanallison:[..]
    Just out of interest how would you define a heritage act? I realise I’m probably making the same point here as I have a million times but I still don’t know how a band that continues to release and tour new material playing several songs from the new album can be called a heritage act. They have never stopped working on new material. They release it at a rate comparable to most established artists and they play more songs live from new albums than most established artists and even plenty of younger artists even half their age. I do find it difficult to understand that fans allow the other stuff to outweigh all that in how they define them as a band.
    If you go by the 'defined' meaning of 'musical heritage' - as per Collins English Dictionary:

    To preserve their country's musical heritage.
    Times, Sunday Times

    No more dipping into an important, but little-known, strand of our national musical heritage.
    Times, Sunday Times

    This might not be *exactly* what the question relates to. From that first one - maybe country/genre. The blues - North America, R&B, South America, folk, Ireland, pub rock, Australia/England ..., or:


    Heritage is the full range of our inherited traditions, monuments, objects, and culture. Most important, it is the range of contemporary activities, meanings, and behaviors that we draw from them. Heritage includes, but is much more than preserving, excavating, displaying, or restoring a collection of old things.

    ... so re-recording old musical pieces, restoring old film, preserving achievements ... and so on? In that case, SoS (is this apt?), might be of heritage. A band continuing to record and play new music I can't see as being called heritage then - because it isn't restoring old things or excavating/preserving old things.
  10. Originally posted by drewhiggins:[..]
    If you go by the 'defined' meaning of 'musical heritage' - as per Collins English Dictionary:

    To preserve their country's musical heritage.
    Times, Sunday Times

    No more dipping into an important, but little-known, strand of our national musical heritage.
    Times, Sunday Times

    This might not be *exactly* what the question relates to. From that first one - maybe country/genre. The blues - North America, R&B, South America, folk, Ireland, pub rock, Australia/England ..., or:


    Heritage is the full range of our inherited traditions, monuments, objects, and culture. Most important, it is the range of contemporary activities, meanings, and behaviors that we draw from them. Heritage includes, but is much more than preserving, excavating, displaying, or restoring a collection of old things.

    ... so re-recording old musical pieces, restoring old film, preserving achievements ... and so on? In that case, SoS (is this apt?), might be of heritage. A band continuing to record and play new music I can't see as being called heritage then - because it isn't restoring old things or excavating/preserving old things.
    Thank you Drew, I’ve been saying this for years that by definition the band aren’t a heritage act. I don’t even think it’s a matter of opinion but factual that they aren’t a heritage act although I’ll likely get criticised for saying that but when something doesn’t fall in line with the definition of what they are saying surely that isn’t an opinion they’re just wrong with what they’re saying?