The new Pride definitely isn't great. This SOS is even worse than I originally imagined. Not just stripped
down acoustic versions of songs, which could be really good, but reimagined for modern times with modern production. Pride was
perfect in its original form. This new version sounds like cheesy and schmaltzy yacht rock as mentioned above. I think I am going to go back to listening to 80s and 90s U2. The only good thing that may possibly come out of SOS is that they get this out of their system and record an album of new material. So at future concerts from now on are we going to get the new versions of songs or the old classic versions of songs? Leave it to U2 to ruin the best thing they had going for them - their back catalogue FFS.
This new Pride has grown on my over the course of multiple listens. Of course it is not replacing the classic version.. but liking this new take more and more.... especially the final third.. I also like the way Bono is singing on this and they way his vocals were recorded..
My guess for the next tour is that they feature a couple of these reworked versions and then stick with the classics for most of these.
Springsteen has reworked a lot of his classics ... he did a whole tour like this (Devils and Dust Tour) which was fantastic. I don't expect U2 to do that (that was a Springsteen solo tour... similar to the Bono solo shows recently). And Dylan famously reinvents much of his classic work over the years (much to the chagrin of casual fans... but I love this!).
Last days i’m thinking a lot about this album. And its hard to say; but i think i don’t like it. I mean; i don’t like the idea to make some good old songs in a new way/style. And now i listen to Pride and it’s sounds horrible to me. That’s not music; that’s a lot of tests with some other tunes and sounds. Not music with instruments, but music made by a computer. I hope the other stuff will be a lot better but i think i’m not gonna like this. For me it’s not a new album; it’s look like a commercial thing. In my opinion a new album must have new songs. I’m dissapointed in U2 with this SoS thing (i can’t called it an album).
It's a bit much to say you don't like the album after hearing one song.. but it's completely okay to not like the idea of reworking old tunes. And Pride does have instruments in it, including guitar 🤷
Originally posted by Unodostres123:[..]
You are wrong, there is 100% a green tape, even is shown on the news item on u2.com if you’re not signed in, once you sign in the pictures are different and a purple marble vinyl with a purple cover was available (still the same pictures of the band but not the sort of greyish background colours). A green vinyl with same cover as original was also available, can confirm this as I could have bought them at one point but went with the boxsets instead. I know these things can probably be faked too but here is the original link which tells you in the description what it is but when you click on it the page no longer exists on u2.com store
As I pre-emoted in my original message, it seems I was actually wrong. Does seem odd that the purple and green versions appeared and disappeared very quickly. Given the chaotic launch of the SOS shop it could be these were mistakenly made available and quickly taken down. So perhaps as per Inhaler we will see many more limited coloured editions come in the run up to 17 March and probably beyond. Very tempted to cancel my clear one and wait and see which version is most desirable. Interesting to see how things develop.
The multiple cash chasing versions are proving at least as interesting as the new / re-imagined music! 😂
Do I dislike the SOS album? I can’t say yet, it not out yet. I can’t understand anyone who is already forming an opinion of an entire album based on the sound of one song. Disliking the concept sure.
Do I dislike the new Pride? I don’t exactly care for it or really hate it. It seems dumbed down and repetitive, removing the sonicness of the original. Seems more like a pop radio production.
I agree that playing these versions on future tours instead of the classic hits would be a mistake considering the general masses probably won’t pay attention to this album. But for a one time Vegas residency, sure go ahead and get it out of your system U2.
I don’t know what the fuss is about, it’s just a Covid/book album to tide us over until the rock record is done. Im excited to hear the rest even if I only like a couple of them
This album isn’t going to cause U2 to gain or lose any fans. Pretty sure only the more diehard fans of this band will even care this album is released. This is like a collection of B-sides or the Kindergarten version of AB. It’s fun imo.
I think of this as “Graduate School” U2. Just like the Kindergarten AB versions, the SOS songs don’t replace the original tunes, but it gives me as a fan another take on songs played by my favorite band. It’s a little like getting to hear the band f around in the studio.
I’m sure I’ll think some of the SOS versions will suck, others will probably grow on me. I’d take another disc of different versions of AB from the vaults in a heartbeat no matter how crappy they might be versus the originals.
Overall, I’m looking forward to all 40 songs on SOS even if all 40 end up “worse” than the original versions. And who knows, there might be a few real gems!
I hate to say this. At first, I was kind of excited by what I heard/read about the Songs of Surrender project. It’s kind of an interesting idea to look back at a body of classic songs and think of reinterpreting them.
Then, I read that they updated some of the lyrics…. Not sure how I feel about that. Lyrics, like music, are a RECORDED document of a time and a place. That’s why they’re called “RECORDS.” Updating/changing them might work in a live setting, where they’re made to fit THAT moment, and THAT place where they song is being performed. But actually re-recording them…. I don’t think I’m on board with that.
The new version of “Pride” is okay. I listened to it once, but don’t feel compelled to listen to it that much again. I sincerely hope the rest of the album is as mediocre as this first track.
And then there’s the album cover. What a bland mess of an album cover. Pictures of Adam, Edge, and Larry from one era — POP — and then one old photo of Bono that was already on the cover of his book.Why not all of the pictures from the same era? Or different pictures from over the years, to reflect what this collection of songs is really about? It makes ZERO sense, and moreover, just looks BAD. Like a cheap greatest hits CD you’d pick up from a gas station while on a road trip. Come on, where’s the visual impact that U2 have always — ALWAYS — valued?
My expectations are somewhat LOWERED at this point. Ugh. Makes me SAD.
I’m not sure why they chose to do this, I’m happy for those that are interested in it and find joy, I’m in the mindset that a nice career spanning live anthology 4-5 CDs ala Tom Petty would have been much more exciting to buy some time until a proper new album
Ive been saying for the longest time that it is not the music that I am tired of, it is the recordings. I never want to hear anything off of Appetite for Destruction or Pearl Jam's Ten again because FM has killed those songs. The bands are exciting and I am reminded this when I see those bands live. U2 suffers this fate as well. It was so refreshing to hear RHMT in concert with a different arrangement. Bob Dylan does this all of the time.
The new album/tour is not ready so lets just welcome a new compliation for now as it has been over twenty years since Best of 90/00. The choices are solid except maybe POE/DD but arrangement is king. Lets do this. BTW, I love the 80's Bono vocal at the conclusion of Pride.