1. I'm predicting STUCK on Edge piano. According to U2W1 it has never been released but played live of course.
  2. The audiobook already has a snippet, its acoustic guitar. Sounds like a different version from the previous acoustic version anyway, although Bono and edge are singing the same parts as they do in the original and acoustic versions but with the longer ‘it’s just a moment’ rather than going straight into ‘this time will pass’ , maybe edge is doing lead during verse and choruses and then it finishes as normal.
  3. Originally posted by felix2:Only two simple questions. Does anyone know why there is a 16 and 20 title of SOS 40 songs? What I don't understand at all is why have the titles of beautiful day, red mining town, UNTIL THE END OF THE WORLD and WITH OR WITHOUT YOU disappeared?


    Cause they don't doing for fans but for money. You have to but 4lp, 2lp colour crystal and another ultra limited edition purple and green ๐Ÿ˜‰
    All is only for money, it's sad I know but it's true.
  4. And when fans will buy different editions, they will be No. 1 in the charts again.
    Is this Rock'N'Roll?
  5. Originally posted by MartinPhisto:[..]


    Cause they don't doing for fans but for money. You have to but 4lp, 2lp colour crystal and another ultra limited edition purple and green ๐Ÿ˜‰
    All is only for money, it's sad I know but it's true.
    Then Marketing, Universal or Bono must have gotten bogged down and miscalculated at the same time. 40 chapters in the book total. 16 and 20 songs of the editions, 20 and 24 songs are missing based on the songs but not in the book, there are 40 chapters. Either I'm too stupid to break down or the chapters in the book to pull together. The book SOS with 16 or 20 chapters according to the CDs is there, but where is the rest? Someone has built incomprehensible crap here, which nobody understands.
  6. it leaves space for the part II release on splattered vinyl
  7. People this is art. They can do what they want, when they want. That's the way it works. Projects have existed where different songs have been on vinyl, CD or whatever from many different artists. The format dictates the product. This project is a bit scatterbrain but that is what they have decided. Get over it.

    Further, the revenues, even to cover promotion and recording costs have all but dried up in the 21C for all artists. Because of the population stealing music online. Bands have to re-coup costs by releasing multiple limited editions. Did I buy the X number of Inhaler editions? Hell no! Those strategies are just a response to a market that simply doesn't pay for music anymore.
  8. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    Then Marketing, Universal or Bono must have gotten bogged down and miscalculated at the same time. 40 chapters in the book total. 16 and 20 songs of the editions, 20 and 24 songs are missing based on the songs but not in the book, there are 40 chapters. Either I'm too stupid to break down or the chapters in the book to pull together. The book SOS with 16 or 20 chapters according to the CDs is there, but where is the rest? Someone has built incomprehensible crap here, which nobody understands.
    It’s just extra ways to buy it. If the main interest is getting all 40 songs there’s the digital download at £20, 4 cd version at £30 or 4 lp set at £100ish. It’s quite normal to offer cd and vinyl with different amounts of tracks on them and price them accordingly.
  9. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    Then Marketing, Universal or Bono must have gotten bogged down and miscalculated at the same time. 40 chapters in the book total. 16 and 20 songs of the editions, 20 and 24 songs are missing based on the songs but not in the book, there are 40 chapters. Either I'm too stupid to break down or the chapters in the book to pull together. The book SOS with 16 or 20 chapters according to the CDs is there, but where is the rest? Someone has built incomprehensible crap here, which nobody understands.
    Maybe now will be a half of the book ๐Ÿ˜ƒ who knows? Second half you have to glued it on your own ๐Ÿ˜ƒ
    But also they will be new resong Sometimes you can't glued it on your own ofcourse ultra limited edition ๐Ÿ˜‰
  10. N 1 in the charts? With this album for sure not.
  11. Originally posted by MartinPhisto:[..]
    Maybe now will be a half of the book ๐Ÿ˜ƒ who knows? Second half you have to glued it on your own ๐Ÿ˜ƒ
    But also they will be new resong Sometimes you can't glued it on your own ofcourse ultra limited edition ๐Ÿ˜‰
    Or even several steps have to be taken backwards. Yes Universal is a very poor music label, if not the poorest that steals most of the money from the artists, that's what the artists signed for. I understand that with the different editions. But who the hell buys the 16 or 20 version? These are slow sellers that nobody buys. Or the book has to be shortened by 20 or 24 chapters in order for it to make sense, because it still doesn't make sense to me.
  12. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    Or even several steps have to be taken backwards. Yes Universal is a very poor music label, if not the poorest that steals most of the money from the artists, that's what the artists signed for. I understand that with the different editions. But who the hell buys the 16 or 20 version? These are slow sellers that nobody buys. Or the book has to be shortened by 20 or 24 chapters in order for it to make sense, because it still doesn't make sense to me.
    Maybe you can start to realise the book and the album are somehow linked together but are different projects. They don't even have the same songs/chapters