1. Fez's are cool.
  2. Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
    We all do that. We say Fez and we mean the whole 5.20 minute thing.

    It's a gem. Very few U2 songs are as strongly evocative as that one for me. It's completely tied to the trip to Barcelona to see the kick-off gig of the 360 tour. I remember it like it was yesterday.


    Haha for sure.

    And yeah I would agree. It's super underrated in their catalogue (at least by people who aren't super nerds like the people here πŸ˜›), and a perfect marriage of music and lyricism.

    And the music is such a departure for U2 - and just in general, for that matter. Like the phrases and melodies they ended up with on that song...it's so un-U2 sounding. It sounds mysterious and otherworldly, but at the same time uplifting and cathartic. It's almost like a perfect intersection of super early U2, Zooropa, and modern U2. It's also both very melodic and "soft", while also being loud and powerful. THIS is the kind of "rock" that I wish U2 would make a full album of. Not necessarily super distorted and macho, but something that can still get very loud while still retaining that U2 sound.

    I said it at the time and still think to this day that it should've opened the 360 shows. Have "Fez" come on over the PA, the band slowly take their positions, and then kick into "Being Born". What an explosive opener that would've been.
  3. Fez/Being Born is a marriage. It's definitely two songs wed into one. The first part is probably mostly Eno. Let's not forget that though No Line is a "U2" album, all songs were written by the band in collaboration with Eno and Lanois (which was undoubtedly also true of UF, JT, AB, and ALTYCLB).

    Agree completely that it's a standout track from No Line--and a vision of what they're capable of when not trying to be U2.

    I also wish all of that album went in that direction. Crazy, Boots, and Standup would have been fun b-sides, but they still pretty much ruin the flow of the album for me.
  4. Originally posted by dstankie:Fez/Being Born is a marriage. It's definitely two songs wed into one. The first part is probably mostly Eno. Let's not forget that though No Line is a "U2" album, all songs were written by the band in collaboration with Eno and Lanois (which was undoubtedly also true of UF, JT, AB, and ALTYCLB).

    Agree completely that it's a standout track from No Line--and a vision of what they're capable of when not trying to be U2.

    I also wish all of that album went in that direction. Crazy, Boots, and Standup would have been fun b-sides, but they still pretty much ruin the flow of the album for me.

    Yeah. After years of being a bit upset at the lost opportunity with the original album that NLOTH was supposed to be... I decided I'd just go and fix it myself using info from Wiki about its original title and based on the Linear movie. And I've never listened to the origina lalbum ever again... While this version is now probably their album I listen to the most πŸ™‚

    BTW this uses a modified version of Winter. I love this song to death but I never could like the weird chorus that departs so much from it, feels just unfinished. So in the end I've managed to remove the choruses and re-arrange things a bit to keep things nice. If anyone is interested just ask, I'm pretty proud of the edit, the cuts are not distinguishible πŸ™‚
  5. Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]


    Haha for sure.

    And yeah I would agree. It's super underrated in their catalogue (at least by people who aren't super nerds like the people here πŸ˜›), and a perfect marriage of music and lyricism.

    And the music is such a departure for U2 - and just in general, for that matter. Like the phrases and melodies they ended up with on that song...it's so un-U2 sounding. It sounds mysterious and otherworldly, but at the same time uplifting and cathartic. It's almost like a perfect intersection of super early U2, Zooropa, and modern U2. It's also both very melodic and "soft", while also being loud and powerful. THIS is the kind of "rock" that I wish U2 would make a full album of. Not necessarily super distorted and macho, but something that can still get very loud while still retaining that U2 sound.

    I said it at the time and still think to this day that it should've opened the 360 shows. Have "Fez" come on over the PA, the band slowly take their positions, and then kick into "Being Born". What an explosive opener that would've been.
    And this is why I'm still hoping so much for Songs of Ascent. Somehow this idea always sounded to me like it would be the best parts of NLOTH and stuff like Disappearing Act, which is one of their best songs IMHO
  6. Originally posted by Sev00:[..]
    [image]
    Yeah. After years of being a bit upset at the lost opportunity with the original album that NLOTH was supposed to be... I decided I'd just go and fix it myself using info from Wiki about its original title and based on the Linear movie. And I've never listened to the origina lalbum ever again... While this version is now probably their album I listen to the most πŸ™‚

    BTW this uses a modified version of Winter. I love this song to death but I never could like the weird chorus that departs so much from it, feels just unfinished. So in the end I've managed to remove the choruses and re-arrange things a bit to keep things nice. If anyone is interested just ask, I'm pretty proud of the edit, the cuts are not distinguishible πŸ™‚
    Definitely interested in hearing your mix. There was a resequencing of NLOTH I had bookmarked on Reddit but lost it and couldn't find the thread it was on. This one comes close but doesn't include Breathe (which I could understand why.)
  7. Originally posted by ThomDorke:[..]
    Definitely interested in hearing your mix. There was a resequencing of NLOTH I had bookmarked on Reddit but lost it and couldn't find the thread it was on. This one comes close but doesn't include Breathe (which I could understand why.)
    Sent you a DM ! Probably can't share that in here

    I happen to really like Breathe btw and tried to make it fit in there... But it just doesn't in my opinion. Also I really wanted to keep the album structure as 4 songs / Soon / 4 songs, in line with the Daylight and Darkness theme !
  8. Originally posted by Sev00:[..]
    And this is why I'm still hoping so much for Songs of Ascent. Somehow this idea always sounded to me like it would be the best parts of NLOTH and stuff like Disappearing Act, which is one of their best songs IMHO
    I hope so too, yeah.

    But the mere fact that Songs of Ascent is still actually kicking around tells me that U2 haven’t stopped fiddling with it since 2009, so it probably doesn’t sound anything like what it might’ve once upon a time anymore ☹️
  9. Originally posted by RattleandHum1988:[..]
    I hope so too, yeah.

    But the mere fact that Songs of Ascent is still actually kicking around tells me that U2 haven’t stopped fiddling with it since 2009, so it probably doesn’t sound anything like what it might’ve once upon a time anymore ☹️
    If you purchased SOS audiobook, there’s a clip of Soon and it sounds exactly same as what’s online.
  10. Originally posted by Sev00:[..]
    Sent you a DM ! Probably can't share that in here

    I happen to really like Breathe btw and tried to make it fit in there... But it just doesn't in my opinion. Also I really wanted to keep the album structure as 4 songs / Soon / 4 songs, in line with the Daylight and Darkness theme !
    Thanks! Which version of Soon did you use? I've heard there are two that exist.
  11. I'm struggling to finish the audiobook but recently was listening to the chapter containing Soon. I'm pretty sure it is a different mix, the vocals are more in the front and especially Bono seems to stand out in a distinct way that I can't her him in the version that was released on 7".

    Same for The Wanderer clip in the audiobook. This time it was the guitar that seemed much louder and distinct so I suspect it's a different mix from the album as well as the soundtrack version.

    Did anyone else notice this?
  12. Originally posted by Sev00:[..]
    [image]
    Yeah. After years of being a bit upset at the lost opportunity with the original album that NLOTH was supposed to be... I decided I'd just go and fix it myself using info from Wiki about its original title and based on the Linear movie. And I've never listened to the origina lalbum ever again... While this version is now probably their album I listen to the most πŸ™‚

    BTW this uses a modified version of Winter. I love this song to death but I never could like the weird chorus that departs so much from it, feels just unfinished. So in the end I've managed to remove the choruses and re-arrange things a bit to keep things nice. If anyone is interested just ask, I'm pretty proud of the edit, the cuts are not distinguishible πŸ™‚
    My version would be

    Soon
    Breathe
    No line on the horizon
    Magnificent
    Unknown Caller
    Fez-Being Born
    White As Snow
    Winter
    Moment Of Surrender
    Cedars Of Lebanon

    Quite close in parts to yours, I think the 360 opening heavily inspired this order for me at the beginning and with moment of surrender near the end.