1. Thanks for these extremely detailed answers !
  2. Haha our recording also has 11OCTT and IWF on the same track More details on the crazy IWF version here.

    So, after comparing it, I'm rather sure it's our same recording, only with minor edits. Timings are almost identical for most of the songs. There's around 10 seconds of dear air (=casette flip) on our recording that they surely edited out. And there's 1m40s of crowd noise after IWF that they also removed. 40 is cut halfway through (not even Adam had stopped playing, let alone Edge or Larry) and their "broadcast" also clocks in at 03:18 so it's definitely the same recording.


    Bootleg track length:

    1 - Gloria 4:47
    2 - I Threw A Brick/A Day Without Me 7:22
    3 - An Cat Dubh/Into The Heart 7:32
    4 - Surrender 5:09
    5 - Two Hearts Beat As One 4:51
    6 - Seconds 2:59
    7 - Sunday Bloody Sunday 5:50
    8 - The Cry/The Electric Co. 6:41
    9 - I Fall Down 4:05
    10 - October 2:11
    11 - New Year’s Day 4:34
    12 - Out Of Control 5:20
    13 - A Celebration 3:08
    14 - 11 O’Clock Tick Tock 10:07
    15 - 40 3:19


    Our recording track length:

  3. Originally posted by LikeASong:Haha our recording also has 11OCTT and IWF on the same track More details on the crazy IWF version here.

    So, after comparing it, I'm rather sure it's our same recording, only with minor edits. Timings are almost identical for most of the songs. There's around 10 seconds of dear air (=casette flip) on our recording that they surely edited out. And there's 1m40s of crowd noise after IWF that they also removed. 40 is cut halfway through (not even Adam had stopped playing, let alone Edge or Larry) and their "broadcast" also clocks in at 03:18 so it's definitely the same recording.


    Bootleg track length:

    1 - Gloria 4:47
    2 - I Threw A Brick/A Day Without Me 7:22
    3 - An Cat Dubh/Into The Heart 7:32
    4 - Surrender 5:09
    5 - Two Hearts Beat As One 4:51
    6 - Seconds 2:59
    7 - Sunday Bloody Sunday 5:50
    8 - The Cry/The Electric Co. 6:41
    9 - I Fall Down 4:05
    10 - October 2:11
    11 - New Year’s Day 4:34
    12 - Out Of Control 5:20
    13 - A Celebration 3:08
    14 - 11 O’Clock Tick Tock 10:07
    15 - 40 3:19


    Our recording track length:

    [image]
    Don’t be sure they edited anything out for quality. I compared an earlier “broadcast bootleg” to what’s been circulating in the fan community for years, and it was a pretty direct copy including a few errors which let me identify which copy they had used.

    These are popping up more and more due to copyright on broadcasts expiring after 40 years in some countries…which makes them “legal” but still not issued by the band / original broadcaster / record label. They’ve even managed to get them into streaming services in some spots…
  4. Originally posted by Monopoly:This band won’t touch Pop again. Someone brought a sign saying “20 years of Pop” to a JT17 show. Bono stared at it then flipped the guy off.


    I think that was a joke but if you want to run with that, ok.
  5. Edit.
  6. It wasn’t. He gave the middle finger. Stood next to the sign haha.

    (Could still be a Bono joke if that’s what you mean)
  7. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
    Don’t be sure they edited anything out for quality. I compared an earlier “broadcast bootleg” to what’s been circulating in the fan community for years, and it was a pretty direct copy including a few errors which let me identify which copy they had used.

    These are popping up more and more due to copyright on broadcasts expiring after 40 years in some countries…which makes them “legal” but still not issued by the band / original broadcaster / record label. They’ve even managed to get them into streaming services in some spots…
    In this case I'm rather sure they edited out these fragments because it's pretty obvious. The differences in track length amount to almost exactly the dead air after I Fall Down and the crowd noise after I Will Follow. If they want to make this recording pass as a soundboard (not easy) they must have done some heavy editing

  8. Originally posted by Remy:[..]
    It wasn’t. He gave the middle finger. Stood next to the sign haha.

    (Could still be a Bono joke if that’s what you mean)
    Especially since he spoke fondly of Pop during the Surrender press tour.
  9. Adam designs a new AMP for Fender -

  10. Originally posted by Remy:[..]
    It wasn’t. He gave the middle finger. Stood next to the sign haha.

    (Could still be a Bono joke if that’s what you mean)
    When Bono gives you the finger it's not really like when someone else does. Its light hearted. Really.
  11. My best friends and I flip each other off all the time. Bono was probably just joking.