1. Originally posted by Papo:[..]
    When we were close to the E-Stage in 2018, I couldn't believe how hard Larry actually hit those drums on Elevation and Vertigo. I've never experienced a drummer hitting the skins that hart.
    Exactly that! I was at the E-stage at Berlin 1 in 2018. And not even close to the rail. And still i could hear him loud and clear above the PA
  2. Originally posted by Papo:[..]
    When we were close to the E-Stage in 2018, I couldn't believe how hard Larry actually hit those drums on Elevation and Vertigo. I've never experienced a drummer hitting the skins that hart.
    Yes. I was right next to him on the stage barrier at one of the London gigs intently watching and listening to him play 'Acrobat' - I was totally lost in the music, and for a moment I briefly looked to my right side and saw Edge looking down at me who had clocked I was mesmerised by Larry going off on the drums. Funny little moment, for me anyway. Larry is definitely not any old drummer. Very underrated indeed.
  3. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
    U2 have been working with the guy since January. They chose him because they thought he could do the job. He’s had the benefit of actually working with Larry Mullen for a large chunk of that time, something most people attempting to sound like Larry would never have. At this point I think it’s just ignorant to judge what he is going to sound like having not heard a single performance since he’s had months of practice and work on all this.

    Do we have issues with Terry Lawless trying to play things The Edge or Brian Eno have come up with in studio?

    Finally U2 themselves mix up their own sound when they do stuff live. Did Larry on “I’ll Go Crazy” sound like Larry on the album?


    --—------------------------------------------------

    Musicians play their music from memory. Because how they play it is stored in their heads. I don't think that 8 or 9 months will be enough for BVDB. How long has U2 been with Larry Mullen? Over 40 years as Larry Mullen played these from memory. And no BVDB can do that in 8 or 9 months. Here is a comparison of over 40 years versus 8 or 9 months.Allright.
  4. Originally posted by felix2:[..]


    --—------------------------------------------------

    Musicians play their music from memory. Because how they play it is stored in their heads. I don't think that 8 or 9 months will be enough for BVDB. How long has U2 been with Larry Mullen? Over 40 years as Larry Mullen played these from memory. And no BVDB can do that in 8 or 9 months. Here is a comparison of over 40 years versus 8 or 9 months.Allright.
    How did you pass your exams at school? Learned your lessons or waited 40 years to do it by memory?
  5. School sucks, no one needs it.
    Practicing 8 or 9 months is usually not enough to catch up over 40 years. When there are rehearsals of Tapern, they will agree with me how difficult it is for BVDB to imitate that or that Larry Mullen drumming. He plays it the way his memory saved it, but not Larry Mullen Junior's. And that's a very big difference. It's about the word imitate, imitate, artificial, not real etc. It won't be the real drumming of Larry Mullen. You agree that BVDB's memory is not the same as Larry Mullen's?
  6. I have every faith that come opening night, Bram will sound great. He is a professional and he will be well rehearsed by that time. Will he sound 100% like Larry? No. But he’ll sound just fine and make few mistakes, like Larry. Meanwhile Bono will be flubbing lines and forgetting verses like usual, but that’s okay also.
  7. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    School sucks, no one needs it.
    Practicing 8 or 9 months is usually not enough to catch up over 40 years. When there are rehearsals of Tapern, they will agree with me how difficult it is for BVDB to imitate that or that Larry Mullen drumming. He plays it the way his memory saved it, but not Larry Mullen Junior's. And that's a very big difference. It's about the word imitate, imitate, artificial, not real etc. It won't be the real drumming of Larry Mullen. You agree that BVDB's memory is not the same as Larry Mullen's?
    Sorry, friend. You apparently don't know the first thing about drumming. Just say it will be crap because and ONLY because Larry won't be there.. that would save everyone some time.
  8. Originally posted by bonoschild:[..]
    Sorry, friend. You apparently don't know the first thing about drumming. Just say it will be crap because and ONLY because Larry won't be there.. that would save everyone some time.
    You just have to stick to the facts in musicology. Example. Nobody living today knows how Bach played correctly, for example. We only know from the grades. BVDB will play and practice this from sheet music. Definitely not from his memory.
  9. Note: In 1984, Edge had to send a roadie out to buy U2's albums because he had forgot how the play the early albums.

    U2 are not normal* musicians.
  10. Originally posted by miryclay:Note: In 1984, Edge had to send a roadie out to buy U2's albums because he had forgot how the play the early albums.

    U2 are not normal* musicians.
    haha rly ?
    forgtot how to play sure, but to send roadie to buy their albums ? should have looked it on youtube
  11. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    You just have to stick to the facts in musicology. Example. Nobody living today knows how Bach played correctly, for example. We only know from the grades. BVDB will play and practice this from sheet music. Definitely not from his memory.
    Dude you are fixated on this being not Larry.
    Have you even heard Bram's drumming before?
    Of course he would have a different drumming style, he is a different person after all, but any professional musician would be able to learn the basic structure of 20 songs in a year.
    There won't be any discernible difference to most of the people.

    You are nitpicking and underestimating a professional musician just because he is not your preferred drummer
  12. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    You just have to stick to the facts in musicology. Example. Nobody living today knows how Bach played correctly, for example. We only know from the grades. BVDB will play and practice this from sheet music. Definitely not from his memory.
    Sheet music? Not correct.