1. Originally posted by nicko:[..]
    haha rly ?
    forgtot how to play sure, but to send roadie to buy their albums ? should have looked it on youtube
    This is a joke right??? YouRube in ‘84? Sadly they didn’t have a NES to play Rock Hand on. Haha

    But I love that they aren’t “normal” musicians. It adds to their legend.
  2. Originally posted by DerBFreund:[..]
    Dude you are fixated on this being not Larry.
    Have you even heard Bram's drumming before?
    Of course he would have a different drumming style, he is a different person after all, but any professional musician would be able to learn the basic structure of 20 songs in a year.
    There won't be any discernible difference to most of the people.

    You are nitpicking and underestimating a professional musician just because he is not your preferred drummer

    you just catching up on this?

    we all are - it ain't Larry and we don't like it

    get with the program
  3. Plenty of great tribute band Larrys. Bram will absolutely do fine although it will look weird with him there and I’d rather he not.. but old news.
  4. Originally posted by DerBFreund:[..]
    Dude you are fixated on this being not Larry.
    Have you even heard Bram's drumming before?
    Of course he would have a different drumming style, he is a different person after all, but any professional musician would be able to learn the basic structure of 20 songs in a year.
    There won't be any discernible difference to most of the people.

    You are nitpicking and underestimating a professional musician just because he is not your preferred drummer


    Question. Can BVDB then play U2's songs that he hasn't practiced before? Mhhh, I don't think so. What if the audience wanted to hear a specific song? Can BVDB drum the song? Can BVDB play a U2 song that U2 has not yet played live? Will BVDB even be able to play all U2 songs? And those are just the minor issues. What if his memory, which he practices and imitates countless times with the pieces, plays a trick on him? Does he then play the piece correctly or not?
  5. Originally posted by felix2:[..]


    Question. Can BVDB then play U2's songs that he hasn't practiced before? Mhhh, I don't think so. What if the audience wanted to hear a specific song? Can BVDB drum the song? Can BVDB play a U2 song that U2 has not yet played live? Will BVDB even be able to play all U2 songs? And those are just the minor issues.
    Can BVDB then play U2's songs that he hasn't practiced before?
    Probably, since he will have rehearsed for months and is a professional.

    What if the audience wanted to hear a specific song? Can BVDB drum the song?
    This is U2, not Bruce Springsteen.

    Can BVDB play a U2 song that U2 has not yet played live?

    Why would he need to? They will have a list of 25-30 songs, some probably won’t even require BVDB to play.

    Will BVDB even be able to play all U2 songs?
    Again, they’ll have a list of 25-30 songs. They’re not going to sit him down and start going through Red Light are they?
  6. Originally posted by iTim:[..]
    Can BVDB then play U2's songs that he hasn't practiced before?
    Probably, since he will have rehearsed for months and is a professional.

    What if the audience wanted to hear a specific song? Can BVDB drum the song?
    This is U2, not Bruce Springsteen.

    Can BVDB play a U2 song that U2 has not yet played live?

    Why would he need to? They will have a list of 25-30 songs, some probably won’t even require BVDB to play.

    Will BVDB even be able to play all U2 songs?
    Again, they’ll have a list of 25-30 songs. They’re not going to sit him down and start going through Red Light are they?
    And with the last question, everyone will be surprised and think no. If BVDB can only do 25-30 tracks, what about the rest? Probably then the audience would have to play the rest of the pieces. Imagine in the Sphere the whole audience wants to hear song xy by shouting, which BVDB has neither practiced nor played? Will u2 play the song?
  7. Originally posted by felix2:[..]


    Question. Can BVDB then play U2's songs that he hasn't practiced before? Mhhh, I don't think so. What if the audience wanted to hear a specific song? Can BVDB drum the song? Can BVDB play a U2 song that U2 has not yet played live? Will BVDB even be able to play all U2 songs? And those are just the minor issues. What if his memory, which he practices and imitates countless times with the pieces, plays a trick on him? Does he then play the piece correctly or not?
    Ever heard of drum tabs? Keith in Vancouver 2015 did fine.
  8. Originally posted by felix2:[..]
    And with the last question, everyone will be surprised and think no. If BVDB can only do 25-30 tracks, what about the rest? Probably then the audience would have to play the rest of the pieces. Imagine in the Sphere the whole audience wants to hear song xy by shouting, which BVDB has neither practiced nor played? Will u2 play the song?
    U2 and requests don’t go hand in hand. The setlist is the setlist, they’re too rigid. You’ve got just as much chance of Bram being able to play the song as you have Edge being able to play it or Bono remembering the lyrics.
  9. Originally posted by felix2:[..]


    Question. Can BVDB then play U2's songs that he hasn't practiced before? Mhhh, I don't think so. What if the audience wanted to hear a specific song? Can BVDB drum the song? Can BVDB play a U2 song that U2 has not yet played live? Will BVDB even be able to play all U2 songs? And those are just the minor issues. What if his memory, which he practices and imitates countless times with the pieces, plays a trick on him? Does he then play the piece correctly or not?
    Question. Can BVDB then play U2's songs that he hasn't practiced before? Mhhh, I don't think so.

    They are preparing huge video presentations to accompany every song. The Edge has already warned us there will be little change in the set list.

    What if the audience wanted to hear a specific song?

    How many times have U2 taken requests? Almost never. And when they have, it’s usually been something they’ve had time to rehearse. People asked for “Landlady” for weeks before it finally showed up.

    Can BVDB play a U2 song that U2 has not yet played live?

    If they plan on playing it live he will know how to play it. And yes, I expect he will have to learn songs that U2 have not yet played live.

    Will BVDB even be able to play all U2 songs?

    He’s not expected to be a human jukebox where you feed him $0.25 and he plays whatever you want. He will be pretty much sticking to a scripted number of songs that will be matched up to the video presentations. Three shows a week means they’ll likely have three different shows put together, with probably 22 songs each night, and 2-3 that will rotate. 28 songs max that he will have to worry about.

    What if his memory, which he practices and imitates countless times with the pieces, plays a trick on him?

    Haha I’m reminded of a recent show I was listening to when Larry started “Out of Control” when it wasn’t on the set lists that night. The guy is human. Mistakes will happen. Larry’s had a number over the years. What if Bram is perfect and doesn’t make any mistakes? Does that make him less like Larry? Oh man…now I’m doing it.
  10. Exactly. It's like people playing mozart or beethovens music. If there's a chart, it's playable. More likely he's going to sound like a human jukebox and that's fine. The drumming will probably closer to the album versions.
  11. Playing u2 on drums is extremely easy. The uniqueness Larry brings is the parts he comes up with. His approach is like no one else and that’s what makes him special. Any drummer can replicate any song in their catalogue. It’s not hard.

    And I’m firmly in the camp of Larry or no u2. But let’s not be silly. His parts aren’t difficult to replicate.