Originally posted by felix2:[..]
And with the last question, everyone will be surprised and think no. If BVDB can only do 25-30 tracks, what about the rest? Probably then the audience would have to play the rest of the pieces. Imagine in the Sphere the whole audience wants to hear song xy by shouting, which BVDB has neither practiced nor played? Will u2 play the song?
This might be disappointing, but Larry doesn't know all of U2's songs. When the band chooses a lesser-played or never-played track to throw into a setlist, they actually practice and learn/relearn the song. We've all seen/heard what can happen when any band tries out a song that they don't remember, and U2 is no exception.. there probably won't be more than 20-25 songs played through the run of Sphere shows. Without looking at tour and song stats, I would wager that U2 could probably spontaneously play less than half of their catalog right now.. and it's not knocking them at all- it's a question of memory and how often songs have or haven't been played. The band's memories have played several tricks on them while playing over the years. You're imagining the audience at the Sphere yelling and requesting songs- honestly... seriously... you think that will happen there?
Originally posted by felix2:[..]
You just have to stick to the facts in musicology. Example. Nobody living today knows how Bach played correctly, for example. We only know from the grades. BVDB will play and practice this from sheet music. Definitely not from his memory.
Bach had pro musicians of the time.
Dvdb will start off by sheet music, if he can read music. He can watch dvds, videos, Larrys drum tech can help...he will.be fine. This is 25 dates on a rigid setlist, not a 100+date world tour.
Bach had pro musicians of the time.
Dvdb will start off by sheet music, if he can read music. He can watch dvds, videos, Larrys drum tech can help...he will.be fine. This is 25 dates on a rigid setlist, not a 100+date world tour.
Sheet music? Not very likely...he will use his trained ears as a drummer to figure out the parts and patterns and as U2Wanderer1 stated, Larry is or has been working with him as well.
With all due respect, this guy has been trolling the Las Vegas thread for so long now, what’s even the point of engaging in these absurd discussions. U2 and audience requests?
However, on the topic of BVDB’s drumming, I actually wouldn’t mind it being a little different from Larry’s style. I don’t need to hear an exact copy, as long as it suits the song and sounds good. Even Larry’s drumming in certain songs has changed over the years, I’ve always enjoyed listening for the changes from one tour to the other. The new guy is not a drum machine or a backing track, let him play in the way that suits him the best and that the rest of the band agrees works with the song.
Originally posted by Hansav:With all due respect, this guy has been trolling the Las Vegas thread for so long now, what’s even the point of engaging in these absurd discussions. U2 and audience requests?
However, on the topic of BVDB’s drumming, I actually wouldn’t mind it being a little different from Larry’s style. I don’t need to hear an exact copy, as long as it suits the song and sounds good. Even Larry’s drumming in certain songs has changed over the years, I’ve always enjoyed listening for the changes from one tour to the other. The new guy is not a drum machine or a backing track, let him play in the way that suits him the best and that the rest of the band agrees works with the song.
I agree! Josh Freese brings something new to the Foo Fighters and I love it
Originally posted by Hansav:With all due respect, this guy has been trolling the Las Vegas thread for so long now, what’s even the point of engaging in these absurd discussions. U2 and audience requests?
However, on the topic of BVDB’s drumming, I actually wouldn’t mind it being a little different from Larry’s style. I don’t need to hear an exact copy, as long as it suits the song and sounds good. Even Larry’s drumming in certain songs has changed over the years, I’ve always enjoyed listening for the changes from one tour to the other. The new guy is not a drum machine or a backing track, let him play in the way that suits him the best and that the rest of the band agrees works with the song.
Larry should walk onto the stage during the first show with a cane, appearing very feeble. Then throw down the cane as if to say "GOTCHA", and then announce the next song, "Trying to throw your arms around the world", like he did during Zoo TV.