I think the falsetto sounds better than it did on SLABT on SOI
Originally posted by podiumboy:I like it. It's not going to save my life or anything, but I enjoy it. I wasn't expecting "Stay" or "One" anyway. I simply accept this song for what it is. I always enjoy hearing Bono singing.
The only part I'm not wild about is the falsetto singing.
Very true, edge taking the lead for the high vocals helps though, Bono’s falsetto has pretty much gone, it’s turned into a whisper type thing, Edge gives it a bit more depth.
Originally posted by Alvin:I like the crispy falsetto on SLABT. It fits the theme and mood of the song and SLABT is leagues better than this.
I would say he gets away with it on SLABT rather than it actually fitting, just because it’s a bit of an obscure sounding song. Not better either imo although not much in it, songs at complete opposite ends style wise anyway.
On listening to it again, the intro and verses are actually nice and interesting. It then suffers from then on in because it’s for a kids film and in the end credits. I imagine when we see the film it’ll make sense.
If this wasn’t for a film it could have gone a very different direction, less pop and more soul perhaps. It’s a pity their only new stuff released has been for events. Hopefully they’ll park the SOE/Coldplay type music for the next album and get back to basics.
Don’t over analyse this. They perhaps should not have released it before the film came out.
Originally posted by mattfromcanada:Man U2 fans have really become Goldilocks......this song is to cheesy....this song is to produced.....the lyrics are to predictable.....can we just love that we got a FREAKING NEW U2 SONG TODAY!??!?!?
No, we can't. I'd rather have no new U2 song than have this.
Originally posted by deanallison:[..]
I would say he gets away with it on SLABT rather than it actually fitting, just because it’s a bit of an obscure sounding song. Not better either imo although not much in it, songs at complete opposite ends style wise anyway.
There is difference in style yes, but definitely big difference in quality.
I don’t get people calling it cheesy, I’ve already seen the inevitable Coldplay comparisons as well. Are people actually listening to the lyrics? Can’t think of many well known songs lately with such heavy lyrics as ‘the man you carry in your heart is only comfortable when he’s in pain’.