1. Originally posted by justinpushplay:Maybe.. and bear with me on this.. maybe they made this because they.. wanted to? Maybe they didn’t make it for sales or for relevance or to try to get a new audience, maybe they just enjoyed the idea and the process and they decided to share with us... frankly, I don’t wanna band that’s working for it’s fans. Of the segments of songs I heard on the audiobook, more interested me than not, so I’m curious about it. At the end of the day it’s just more of something. And I’d rather have more of a band I love than less. I happen to really like songs of innocence and songs of experience, but even those of you who only like one song or two on each album, aren’t you glad that you have that song? If the band had just stopped when a lot of you think, they should’ve, you’d be devoid of at least some thing you enjoyed, and that’s a strange mentality to crave. I’m glad I have songs like raised by wolves, and every breaking wave and red flag day and the little things that give you away...
    Well said, indeed.
    Hey, I don't expect the band to create anything that's going to resonate with me like their (original) material from the eighties and nineties. It just isn't possible - it's probably more ME than THEM. However, if only for a shorter period of time, I've loved having the opportunity to listen everything from ATYCLB to SOE. There are indeed several gems in there.
  2. Originally posted by linzer:I am sad to admit Bono became what he pretended during Zoo Tv, an aged rock star denying his age and the loss of creativity, telling very old stories instead of writing new music.
    Edge wants to reimagine everything with his acoutic guitar in a very low opa tempo, but the real shame was Desire, sounds he was kicked at the balls.
    Our best group became so irrelevant as they never ever imagined.


    Unfortunately, this is what I feel as well. Very sad.... For me it is heartbreaking, just thinking what they were for me and now, no matter how much I try to like this stuff or really justify what they've been doing these past years (the lackluster anniversary releases, Sing 2 Soundtrack, uninspired fan club gifts, etc), it just doesn't click with me and bores me to death. The worst part of the Dirty Day version on E&I was Bono speaking all over it and yet he managed to have a show fully like that? I like my rock stars to sing, and play electric guitars, and bass and drums, not to tell stories while playing stripped down versions of their songs and then released an album like this.

    Hope they knock our socks out with their new album, but it is looking very doubtful at this point. Just as I didn't make any effort to attend any Bono Surrender show, will do the same if he and Edge decide to tour on this new collection.
  3. Originally posted by Unodostres123:[..]
    It’s not about reversing it as such, I’m not suggesting they come out and say rather than love your neighbour shoot them in the head instead. I’m saying rather than go let’s just all love each other and everything will be alright why not focus on the real nitty gritty of the issue? Take us to the places love is blindness and exit take us to. Focus on how the problems they think about in the world, in their private lives, make them feel at their rawest and put that into the song not how they feel after the chance to reflect, when the emotions become more balanced. I actually like love is bigger but it’s quite a predictable message from the band. It’s good but I think it’s time to get heavier. They could really gain some appreciation from people outside of just their fans. Nothing to make them get played regularly on radio but maybe enough for some positive feedback from critics and praise where it wouldn’t normally appear.


    Thanks for that awesome response! I’d love to see where they could take your theme as well! Kind of like “OK. After nearly 50 years there are still divisions. What can we do?”


  4. Fuck. Maybe they used these sessions to get through COVID! It affected all of us.
  5. One with MJB is still one of my favorites...at any rate, yeah- I remember complaining a while back that they could have been doing something during Covid and the lockdowns. Turns out they did. I'm glad they're still being productive, and I'm still optimistic about the 40 songs. Hopefully health and Covid-willing they will get together as a unit and do a new album. And I have no doubt that it will happen. They're doing what they want to right now, and more power to them. As long as it keeps them interested
  6. Just enjoy some new takes on some old songs. You may like a few and dislike a bunch. The old ones always will exist. This isn’t some career defining moment….it’s just a release of some reworked tunes. Not that complicated. I don’t get the negativity.
  7. Good glory the fit some people are throwing. . .

    Y’all are investing far too much energy in disliking an album that doesn’t care if you exist.
  8. Originally posted by justinpushplay:Maybe.. and bear with me on this.. maybe they made this because they.. wanted to? Maybe they didn’t make it for sales or for relevance or to try to get a new audience, maybe they just enjoyed the idea and the process and they decided to share with us... frankly, I don’t wanna band that’s working for it’s fans. Of the segments of songs I heard on the audiobook, more interested me than not, so I’m curious about it. At the end of the day it’s just more of something. And I’d rather have more of a band I love than less. I happen to really like songs of innocence and songs of experience, but even those of you who only like one song or two on each album, aren’t you glad that you have that song? If the band had just stopped when a lot of you think, they should’ve, you’d be devoid of at least some thing you enjoyed, and that’s a strange mentality to crave. I’m glad I have songs like raised by wolves, and every breaking wave and red flag day and the little things that give you away...


    100% agree with you...... Some U2 haters disguised as U2 fans are making all the foul comments here. Let's U2 do whatever they like to do.... they have earned it.
  9. I hope the last questions about SOS 40 songs. What I also don't quite understand from all of this is the fact and what Bono mostly said or the media wrote that the songs were never really finished or finished. Then why was it published in the original old version ? Does anyone know if there is anything about this in the Story of Surrender book?
  10. Originally posted by kris_smith87:It is wild to me how terribly terribly negative this forum has been since for sure the release of Songs Of Experience and a little before that.


    Why? The music has been close to horrible since that point. I honestly wish they hadn't released a single song after 2014
  11. Out of interest and because I have absolutely no idea on the topic, but did Picasso or Monet or any of the classic physical medium artists ever go back and remake their masterpiece works? Not trying to prove anything but genuinely interested if the redoing of old songs is limited to musicians or if anyone else ever does this?
  12. Originally posted by dylbagz:[..]


    Why? The music has been close to horrible since that point. I honestly wish they hadn't released a single song after 2014
    For me SOE Is without a doubt the worst album they have released, I can even forigive them for October as this was a band just trying to find their feet. I reserve my judgment on SOS until I hear more of it, but I do feel this is a contractural obligation here, is it a coincidence the photo of Larry on the cover is of him looking straight at us stony faced lol