Originally posted by JoeHar:I like Pride. I like the other songs I heard so far and I can’t wait to hear the other songs.
For me, NLOTH, SOI and SOE are the same “sound”. And finally they are trying a different direction once more. In the 90’s the experiment was more and more and more. Now the experiment is less. We shall see over time where that experiment will bring them.
Last wednesday when they released Pride I was walking in a mall. While listening it gave me goosebumps. The respect for the past by integrating Bono’s original recording, but still make a complete new song.
The next chapter for me is how these songs will survive on the stage. Based on the performance in The Ambassador they will. Although that setting was really different than arenas or stadiums. We will see…
NLOTH sounds nothing at all like SOI or SOE. And NLOTH is a far superior record to SOI and SOE.
Originally posted by MartinPhisto:[..]
IMHO they made it for teenage generation fans. I spoke with older fans 40+ and all said the same ,,U2's ,,new direction,, is a total crap,,. I hope new album will be more AB-HTDAAB era.
But will teenagers even care about this? If they want to grasp a younger generation, they’d be likely be better off releasing an updated greatest hits package - kind of like what bands like The Stones and Led Zeppelin did to help me get into them.
Originally posted by Unodostres123:I feel like at this point the type of album that would gain the band most praise is probably the type of album that they’d least like to make. Some sort of heavy, dark album that seems a million miles away from the bands claim that love is bigger than anything. I just don’t think the band are in the right place to make the album they need to make to get the praise probably all of us on here want them to get. That doesn’t mean I personally don’t love the bands more recent work, I do, and I’m confident I’ll enjoy the next album and enjoy listening to songs of surrender at least to some extent but for the band to really get even the slightest bit of praise from a non fan it’s going to need to take something bold but not too clever, too experimental I don’t think will go down well, it needs to be just purely heavy, try and appeal to proper rock lovers and get far away as possible from the chart sound who’s listeners are never going to come round to u2.
I want them to ride off into the sunset with their tried and true message of love being bigger than anything in its way. I think turning around this whole message for an album would really be terrible.
Originally posted by RUMMY:[..]
But will teenagers even care about this? If they want to grasp a younger generation, they’d be likely be better off releasing an updated greatest hits package - kind of like what bands like The Stones and Led Zeppelin did to help me get into them.
I think what they should be exploring is something along the lines of what Elton John had been doing. Creating a composition from old songs and collaborating with new artists.
I think anyone who believes that a band as old as U2 could still be part of the zeitgeist is deluding themselves. When bands get old they can do a few things. Continue to try and break new ground (for themselves), retire and leave their legacy intact, or do stuff like this album/the JT30 tour and start eroding their reputation.
I have to imagine that most U2 fans through the 80s and 90s (and even 2000s) never would’ve thought U2 would be a band who chose the third option.
More power to anyone who enjoys this recording, truly. It’s just not for me, and I don’t think it’s going to be for anyone other than those diehard U2 fans who are happy to see them cash in on their catalogue by doing stuff like this. I can safely say I never want to hear that version of Pride again. I’ll always want to hear the version that the band made in their 20s when it was revolutionary, and they were at the top of their game.
Originally posted by kris_smith87:[..]
I think what they should be exploring is something along the lines of what Elton John had been doing. Creating a composition from old songs and collaborating with new artists.
They did something with Mary J Blidge and that was horrible
Originally posted by LostSailor:The only way SOS will be worth it for me is if they get this SOS out of their system and make a good album of new material. If not, it's time wasted.
Side note: I for one am tired of album titles with the word "songs" in them. Can we move on already FFS?
I feel exact the same. Songs of this / songs of that. Translation-boring
Originally posted by LostSailor:
Side note: I for one am tired of album titles with the word "songs" in them. Can we move on already FFS?
Yeah I was ready for the "songs of" era to be over after 2018 but it seems like we got a long way to go yet. Songs of Surrender and Songs of Ascent still to come.