just listening to each of the available clips, I'm struck by, eh, a strange thing to say on a U2 forum, but, my, the boys really have written some damn fine songs over the years.
Absolutely. Not a great song to begin with (although it’s better as an acoustic song?), this vocal doesn’t do it any favors. Could have been one of the few songs (the only song?) better than the album version with a decent vocal.
Originally posted by LikeASong:[..]
It's surprisingly good, yes. The whole arrangement seems to be among the most attractive of the bunch. There's a lot going on in the background there!
Shows that the song has good bones. I agree that it’s one of the best of the bunch.
I'm probably incredibly biased because Pop is my favorite album and any acknowledgement by the boys that it's part of their discography feels probably ten times more important than it is, but I was pleasantly surprised by the new take on IGWSHE. Sounds like it could even be dug out of the mothballs for another go live.
Overall, it seems like some of it is meh, there are some really nice recordings, and overall, they led with the worst recordings released & promoted first, for the most part. Ha.
I don’t think I’m going to dislike the album as much as I thought, but they could have ditched the parallel with Bono’s memoir, done like 20 songs instead, left the classics alone (Bad/the first 3 of JT/Beautiful Day/SBS), and it would have been overall a more successful project.