1. I think there are about 5 tracks I like… many skip songs unfortunately for me. Let’s see how the record will grow.
  2. Originally posted by blink:I think there are about 5 tracks I like… many skip songs unfortunately for me. Let’s see how the record will grow.
    I loved *Easter Lily* and keep listening to it; if the new album had 2 tracks from *Ash* and 3 or 4 from *CDL*, it would be a top 5 album for me.
    I would have put the tracks from these three—*Carnival*, *Ash*, and *Lily*—together as a trilogy on a single LP, but I’m happy with what they’re giving us.
  3. As a lifelong U2 fan, I think there are two kinds of U2 albums: (1) those that are masterpieces, and (2) those that are just very good.

    If you think this album sucks, or only like a few of the songs, I don't think you are much of a fan of the band. This is the best thing they have done since the All That/Atomic Bomb era and perhaps since Achtung Baby. Every song is fantastic. At the very least it is just a very good album like most of the last 15.
  4. Now that I have heard it a few times I feel like I get this album now and like it a lot. I had mental resistance initially because the songwriting follows a different pattern than I am used to from them. It's quite sophisticated so it doesn't trigger the normal patterns of recognition for me.
  5. Originally posted by JDLM:[..]
    I loved *Easter Lily* and keep listening to it; if the new album had 2 tracks from *Ash* and 3 or 4 from *CDL*, it would be a top 5 album for me.
    I would have put the tracks from these three—*Carnival*, *Ash*, and *Lily*—together as a trilogy on a single LP, but I’m happy with what they’re giving us.


    This 💯
  6. I am loving this album and so are my wife and children. It’s varied, inspired, alive.

    Thematically and also musically it’s different to the two EPs. Overall, it is somewhat brighter and lighter. But I think it was meant to be.

    The three together rank for me - at the moment - as the freshest and most inspired material since AB/Zooropa. And I am a big fan of all the other albums in between, including No Line and SOI.
  7. It is fair to ask whether the album would be stronger by taking all three discs and putting them on a single CD and eliminating a few songs that feel like filler. It would have to be a longer CD of, say, 16 tracks. Here is an alternative album that I think would have been really excellent, as a single CD and vinyl double album.

    Go
    La Reina
    Mirror Maker
    Silencio
    Greatest Show on Earth
    Glorify
    Can't Stop Us Now
    Torn
    Song of the Future
    Tears of Things
    Song for Hal
    In a Life
    Scars
    Resurrection Song
    Easter Parade
    COEXIST


    But, you know, if you would prefer an album of this sort, you can just make your own playlist and/or burn it to your own disc for your 90s boombox.
  8. Originally posted by BonoIsTheMessiah:As a lifelong U2 fan, I think there are two kinds of U2 albums: (1) those that are masterpieces, and (2) those that are just very good.

    If you think this album sucks, or only like a few of the songs, I don't think you are much of a fan of the band. This is the best thing they have done since the All That/Atomic Bomb era and perhaps since Achtung Baby. Every song is fantastic. At the very least it is just a very good album like most of the last 15.
    I have been a fan since 1982, after borrowing the first two LPs from a cousin.
    From ATYCLB onwards, there are at least 4 songs on every album that I don’t enjoy listening to, including tracks like Stuck in a Moment, Sometimes You Can't Make It, The Miracle, You're the Best Thing. Moment of Surrender, Glorify. Songs that other fans like very much.
    I have tickets for 6 European shows and maybe I will visit the US next year too. Their concerts are magical and take me back to my youth and bring back memories.
    For me there are three kinds of U2 albums: those that are masterpieces, those that are just good and those that are average.
    I consider myself a fan, but does that mean I’m not allowed to be critical?
  9. Originally posted by TheUglyOne:[..]
    I have been a fan since 1982, after borrowing the first two LPs from a cousin.
    From ATYCLB onwards, there are at least 4 songs on every album that I don’t enjoy listening to, including tracks like Stuck in a Moment, Sometimes You Can't Make It, The Miracle, You're the Best Thing. Moment of Surrender, Glorify. Songs that other fans like very much.
    I have tickets for 6 European shows and maybe I will visit the US next year too. Their concerts are magical and take me back to my youth and bring back memories.
    For me there are three kinds of U2 albums: those that are masterpieces, those that are just good and those that are average.
    I consider myself a fan, but does that mean I’m not allowed to be critical?
    Of course you're allowed to be critical and have an opinion, it doesn't mean you're not a fan. Some people just seem to want an echo chamber.

    We can all agree to disagree, doesn't mean that anyone is less worthy. There's some U2 stuff I like more, there's something like Mercy which I don't get all the fuss about or hold it in high regard as some fans do, but that doesn't make them or me wrong. If we all agreed on everything that would be worrying.
  10. You should all listen to the atmos mix it’s insane. I’m hearing more and more things I never picked up on before particularly on GSOE. For example when Bono first does his “ohhhhhh” when the piano comes in you can hear eno and edge harmonising underneath I never noticed it before. Beautiful.