1. Originally posted by BonoIsTheMessiah:Anyone else listening to the singer Rosalia in order to better appreciate the song Mirror Maker? I just listened to Lux for the first time. Wow. Incredible. Songs in 14 different languages inspired by various religious mystics. I might have to go back and forth between U2 and Rosalia over the next few days.
    Started doing that when the song was announced. My wife clued me into Rosalia a bit with the song, Berghain, about a year ago. I was impressed. Their admiration of her is completely justified.
  2. Originally posted by Fano:[..]
    Enough of this condescending attitude.
    People are entitled to not like this album, they are entitled to give their opinions on the songs, on the band etc.
    If they do not like the album that doesnt make them less of a fan than others.

    Personally I find these comparisons to Achtung Baby absolutely baffling, there isnt one bad song on Achtung Baby and there are multiple materpieces.
    There is one really great song on the new album.

    I was listening to Pop earlier, its infinitely better that the new album too.


    I fully agree. I’ll always defend U2 against the haters, but my fandom has cooled a bit over the last couple of years. As I’ve gotten older, I can take more distance and reflect. When I was younger and they released NLOTH, SOI and SOE, I initially thought those records were on par with their best work. I desperately wanted them to be that good again, so I’ve been guilty of recency bias too.

    Now we’ve lived with those records for years and heard most of the tracks live, and I almost never revisit that material. Yet I still listen to AB, JT, Pop and the like. Of course, that’s personal. But in my humble opinion, when you look at the complexity of their best records and songs, in terms of both musical craft and lyricism, it’s hard to compare them objectively with much of what’s on CdL. “Midnight Summer” and “Superficiality” are no “Ultraviolet,” “Acrobat” or “One Tree Hill,” not even a “Trying to Throw Your Arms Around the World.” “Rosalia” is no “Mysterious Ways” or “Mofo.” “Greatest Show on Earth” may reach that level, and some of the material on the EPs does too (“Tears of Things”).

    I never expected them to reach peak levels again with new material. They’ve gotten older, they have nothing left to prove, and maybe they lack some inspiration too. I applaud them for still being here and trying. I became somewhat disappointed with SOS, the Sphere shows and the HTDAAB reissue. The EPs surprised me positively, and there are tracks on CdL I can sit with for a while. But for me, it’s not a masterpiece. Still, a playlist of 11 to 13 tracks from CdL and the EPs could come close to their best output, and I never thought I’d say that in 2026.


  3. well well
  4. anyway, Go gives me Pop vibes.
  5. I never thought I’d see people defending U2 on X

  6. As of now, this truly enjoyable album lands here on my ranking. Could easily go higher or lower with time tho.
  7. interesting
  8. Damn, October is so underrated
  9. It just lacks the consistency of songs for me, still it obviously represents the band in an amazing early raw status. If only Bono didn’t lose that notebook..
  10. Musically, not much would have changed I think. I became fan after hearing their first two albums and I still like most of the songs. Question: would anyone still have that notebook? 😐
  11. Back to Carnaval.... Go is the most interesting song, but the chorus (from 1:18) ruins it for me.
  12. The chorus is the best part! My 5-year old son only needed to hear it twice and he has been singing it all weekend. He speaks neither English or Spanish, so he sings it as "Caaaaaah-nah-waaaaaah-nah-wooooz" (it's pretty cute)