1. Originally posted by eddiecanb:You should all listen to the atmos mix it’s insane. I’m hearing more and more things I never picked up on before particularly on GSOE. For example when Bono first does his “ohhhhhh” when the piano comes in you can hear eno and edge harmonising underneath I never noticed it before. Beautiful.
    yeah dolby atmos it’s mindblowing
  2. I listened to *CdL* again, from start to finish. For me—based on my own taste—it begins as a 10/10 with the first two tracks, and then, to my ears, it only really starts to make sense again from "Silencio" through to the end. "GSOE"—and again, this is just my personal take—resonates, both in its music and especially its lyrics, in the same vein as "One," "Bad," "WOW," and "WTSHNN."
  3. Originally posted by BonoIsTheMessiah:As a lifelong U2 fan, I think there are two kinds of U2 albums: (1) those that are masterpieces, and (2) those that are just very good.

    If you think this album sucks, or only like a few of the songs, I don't think you are much of a fan of the band. This is the best thing they have done since the All That/Atomic Bomb era and perhaps since Achtung Baby. Every song is fantastic. At the very least it is just a very good album like most of the last 15.
    Enough of this condescending attitude.
    People are entitled to not like this album, they are entitled to give their opinions on the songs, on the band etc.
    If they do not like the album that doesnt make them less of a fan than others.

    Personally I find these comparisons to Achtung Baby absolutely baffling, there isnt one bad song on Achtung Baby and there are multiple materpieces.
    There is one really great song on the new album.

    I was listening to Pop earlier, its infinitely better that the new album too.
  4. I don’t find there to be a weak song on this album it’s greater than the sum of its parts too.
  5. There's enough fundamentalism in the political world. Maybe we could remember that taste in music is relative at the end of the day and what you bring to a listening experience is going to be different from someone else or even from yourself at different times of your life. It would be comforting to think that there's an objective truth about what this album is but it's all ultimately in the ear of the beholder.
  6. I don’t know if I’d go as far as saying there isn’t a weak song but I’d say there isn’t any terrible songs and it’s mostly good or better songs. I really think they’ve done very well with this album.
  7. ​So, I’ve listened to it at least 15 times now, and I really like it.
    ​In La Rena definitely needs an Edge solo.
    ​The Bonus Track is a beautifully crafted song up until the outro, but the chorus at the end is just too much—it completely overpowers everything else.
    ​Otherwise, Go is a great opener.
    ​Street of Dreams is arranged wonderfully, Rosalina is also okay, Superficiality is top-notch.
    ​I also really like World at War.
    ​Silencio is amazing, it has real Atomic Bomb vibes.
    ​Greatest Show is phenomenal—for me, it’s on the same level as their best songs like Streets, Pride, Bad, One, Beautiful Day, City of Blinding Lights, Little Things.
    ​Glorify is a super song, Bono’s vocals are world-class.
    ​Midnight Sunshine is really nice, Can’t Stop Us Now is also very great.
    ​Torn is one of the best duets I’ve ever heard—world-class, especially the transition into American Opportunity...
    ​Listening to all three records back-to-back... The Deluxe Edition ranks among their masterpieces, it's top tier.
    ​One final thought: It’s such a shame that North Star (Transformers movie version) isn't included on it. I really hope it makes it onto a vinyl/record someday—Bono, Edge, Larry, Adam, please don't forget about this song!
  8. American Obituary.


  9. i like this idea of Silencio being macphisto’s song
  10. Carnaval De Luz can hold its own…even more so than SOE…but the deluxe version is an indisputable top 3 for U2 albums.