1. Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
    Oh I’m no therapist, just rational. And it’s not really a psychoanalysis if it’s clear as day that someone is just wasting their own time. If you’re not interested in anything, the band has done in the last 30 years, being here right now is the Internet equivalent of visiting your high school campus every day.. just move on
    The band are about to spend 3 months in Las Vegas playing that album released 30 years ago. Maybe they should…just move on?
  2. Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
    Oh I’m no therapist, just rational. And it’s not really a psychoanalysis if it’s clear as day that someone is just wasting their own time. If you’re not interested in anything, the band has done in the last 30 years, being here right now is the Internet equivalent of visiting your high school campus every day.. just move on


    First of all, you're reading a lot into the word "One" that I didn't say. Second, that insufferable high horse you're riding on is not doing you any favors.
  3. The first single off AB was the Fly. Do you know what that sounded like at the time? How bold and weird and provocative?

    The first single off Zooropa was Numb. Numb! And radio stations played it.

    The first single off Pop was Discotheque. Again, weird and bold and unpredictable.

    Heck, I'll throw in Beautiful Day. At the time, sounding like old U2 was the least U2 thing to do. It's a great track that set the tone for the album and tour to come.

    Desire was an interesting single from R&H.

    A non-album release like Night and Day demanded attention for its unpredictability. Same with Hold Me..., Miss Sarajevo.

    I'll even concede Vertigo was a banger and had some new energy (even if the rest of the album was nothing like it).

    So it's not like there isn't a long history of attention-grabbing singles that pushed the sound envelope for this band.

    With that context, recent singles have been tremendous let downs to some of us, and this one seems to sadly be another swing and a miss.

    And the weird thing is that they--the artists themselves--don't seem to notice the tremendous diminishment.

    An analogy: I am a New England Patriots fan. I was spoiled by twenty years of football greatness. Am I supposed to feel satisfied by what the team is now--average on a very good day? As a fan, should I just be happy that there is still a football team in New England?

    The analogy breaks down: the Patriot greatness was clearly largely about Tom Brady's greatness. He's gone, and therefore this isn't the same team. But U2 IS the same team. And given their history of greatness, plus their collective musical wisdom and experience, is it really so strange or offensive to expect more from them?
  4. Originally posted by dstankie:The first single off AB was the Fly. Do you know what that sounded like at the time? How bold and weird and provocative?

    The first single off Zooropa was Numb. Numb! And radio stations played it.

    The first single off Pop was Discotheque. Again, weird and bold and unpredictable.

    Heck, I'll throw in Beautiful Day. At the time, sounding like old U2 was the least U2 thing to do. It's a great track that set the tone for the album and tour to come.

    Desire was an interesting single from R&H.

    A non-album release like Night and Day demanded attention for its unpredictability. Same with Hold Me..., Miss Sarajevo.

    I'll even concede Vertigo was a banger and had some new energy (even if the rest of the album was nothing like it).

    So it's not like there isn't a long history of attention-grabbing singles that pushed the sound envelope for this band.

    With that context, recent singles have been tremendous let downs to some of us, and this one seems to sadly be another swing and a miss.

    And the weird thing is that they--the artists themselves--don't seem to notice the tremendous diminishment.

    An analogy: I am a New England Patriots fan. I was spoiled by twenty years of football greatness. Am I supposed to feel satisfied by what the team is now--average on a very good day? As a fan, should I just be happy that there is still a football team in New England?

    The analogy breaks down: the Patriot greatness was clearly largely about Tom Brady's greatness. He's gone, and therefore this isn't the same team. But U2 IS the same team. And given their history of greatness, plus their collective musical wisdom and experience, is it really so strange or offensive to expect more from them?


    Exactly.
  5. Originally posted by MattG:In turn, I would likewise say its harsh to suggest that their music hasn't warranted an interesting sound....but wouldn't necessarily disagree


    Hahahahah it’s sad but true
  6. Are there any examples of a band in their sixties playing music equally groundbreaking to when they were in their twenties/thirties?
  7. Atomic Shitty. Sums up the song and the discourse it has provoked..
  8. Are there any bands that sound relevant and innovative at the age U2 is? I just don’t think it’s something we should be expecting.

    If you are expecting an AB like reinvention of U2 I think you will be disappointed, they will not be cutting down the “Songs of…” tree anytime soon. I am just happy the band is together and making music that isn’t completely unlistenable. If they are happy and together then I’m happy. It’s easier this way to be a happy fan of my favorite band.

    Funny enough I’ve played U2 a ton for my girlfriend. All the best stuff. Then I’m the grocery store yesterday the Best Thing comes on and she says it’s her favorite U2 song she’s ever heard, so who the hell knows anything is my point.
  9. Originally posted by Hansav:Are there any examples of a band in their sixties playing music equally groundbreaking to when they were in their twenties/thirties?
    I don't want them to be groundbreaking necessarily, but I would like them to try and make something anthemic, something that sounds like 'U2'. I really liked Magnificent and Invisible, but it has been ten years now since they had a proper go at this kind of single (Get Out of Your Own Way does not count). There is nothing about Atomic City that strikes me as 'U2', it just sounds like a generic rock jukebox.
  10. No one is asking for "equally groundbreaking." Though:

    Bob Dylan and his touring band has released lots of great, interesting music in the last thirty years that is different from his early famous stuff.

    Nick Cave gets better and better as a writer while his band finds new sounds for his songs.

    David Byrne never disappoints.

    David Bowie's final album was a striking document.

    Same with Leonard Cohen.

    Ok, most of these are more individual artists, so maybe it's just harder to keep doing it as a band?
  11. Originally posted by Hansav:Are there any examples of a band in their sixties playing music equally groundbreaking to when they were in their twenties/thirties?
    Didn’t see this when I made my post haha, my exact point
  12. Originally posted by dstankie:No one is asking for "equally groundbreaking." Though:

    Bob Dylan and his touring band has released lots of great, interesting music in the last thirty years that is different from his early famous stuff.

    Nick Cave gets better and better as a writer while his band finds new sounds for his songs.

    David Byrne never disappoints.

    David Bowie's final album was a striking document.

    Same with Leonard Cohen.

    Ok, most of these are more individual artists, so maybe it's just harder to keep doing it as a band?
    Totally different career paths, I think you hit it on the head with solo acts compared to bands.

    U2 sells out stadiums, don’t know if Bob Dylan has played for that many people in 30 years