Originally posted by dstankie:As far as I can tell, rock is dead (and has been for some time). I don't know what to call this style of song, but U2 have been doing it for two decades now. The weirdest thing for this old timer is that the Edge seems to do little but play electric guitar nowadays in ways that sound like lots of other people playing electric guitar. Sometimes this really works (e.g. Red Flag Day). But he used to play like no one else and in fact really go out of his way to deconstruct the electric guitar. Also strange to me: Bono can't seem to move past platitudes and tired rhymes half the time in his lyrics. Take your pick of songs from the first 20 years and try to find anything as uninspired as "I'm free/Where you are is where I'll be."
To Valentine's point, how can they not see what a diminishment this is creatively?
I hear all your objections already: at least they're still together and making music... It's not that bad... The bass part is cool... Edge's solo (though it's way too short to be called a solo) has some great energy...It's just a fun song for the Vegas residency...Don't be so negative...
Thought experiment: Would it really have been better if the Beatles had stayed together and made mediocre albums for the next thirty years?