1. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
    I wonder if there's been some issue with the audio monitoring at the Sphere. I think Bono's voice is still very good. Just take a look at his amazing performances during the book tour, particularly the Stephen Colbert performance which was outstanding. But in the Sphere shows and even the Grammys performance he has been "out of tune" a lot. I'm not sure whether it's a voice problem or a hearing problem. So I wonder if it's an issue with the audio in that venue. Sure, his movements are less sprightly than when he was younger. But mine are too.

    Bono's singing has been my biggest disappointment with the Sphere shows for that very reason. And I have never had that issue with any previous U2 tours. So I'm wondering what's going on. The live performances of Atomic City versus the recorded versions have been particularly atrocious. But Even Better than The Real Thing has been painful and they even released an official video of that performance on their Youtube channel as if to confirm this publicly.

    The one performance that seemed really on point was the "Shut Up" performance of "Peace On Earth" where he got really worked up in the speech beforehand. On that song he hit every note perfectly. That makes me wonder if, as some commenters have remarked, he's not as "hungry" any more and can only hit the notes when he gets triggered like that. I hope that's not true but I just went back and listened to the first recordings from the April 1987 Joshua Tree tour in Arizona and, boy, is that a contrast in energy level from him. Of course I don't expect a 60 year old man to sing like a 30 year old any more but the contrast in the level of passion is noteworthy and maybe U2's music just doesn't sound as good without that level of commitment that the younger Bono was able to bring to it.
    He's sounding pretty good to my ears. He lost a decent bit of weight in the last year or two which no doubt helped overall stamina etc.
  2. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
    I wonder if there's been some issue with the audio monitoring at the Sphere. I think Bono's voice is still very good. Just take a look at his amazing performances during the book tour, particularly the Stephen Colbert performance which was outstanding. But in the Sphere shows and even the Grammys performance he has been "out of tune" a lot. I'm not sure whether it's a voice problem or a hearing problem. So I wonder if it's an issue with the audio in that venue. Sure, his movements are less sprightly than when he was younger. But mine are too.

    Bono's singing has been my biggest disappointment with the Sphere shows for that very reason. And I have never had that issue with any previous U2 tours. So I'm wondering what's going on. The live performances of Atomic City versus the recorded versions have been particularly atrocious. But Even Better than The Real Thing has been painful and they even released an official video of that performance on their Youtube channel as if to confirm this publicly.

    The one performance that seemed really on point was the "Shut Up" performance of "Peace On Earth" where he got really worked up in the speech beforehand. On that song he hit every note perfectly. That makes me wonder if, as some commenters have remarked, he's not as "hungry" any more and can only hit the notes when he gets triggered like that. I hope that's not true but I just went back and listened to the first recordings from the April 1987 Joshua Tree tour in Arizona and, boy, is that a contrast in energy level from him. Of course I don't expect a 60 year old man to sing like a 30 year old any more but the contrast in the level of passion is noteworthy and maybe U2's music just doesn't sound as good without that level of commitment that the younger Bono was able to bring to it.


    Maybe he's just bored of being in Vegas by now. Boring crowds compared to other places in the world. And the Sphere shows are not accessible to a lot of fans who are very passionate.
  3. His voice has always worked well in stadiums because he works off the big reverb and echos. At the sphere, the sound is pure and it’s missing that live element. his voice sounds very direct which isn’t always a good thing.
  4. Originally posted by Monopoly:His voice has always worked well in stadiums because he works off the big reverb and echos. At the sphere, the sound is pure and it’s missing that live element. his voice sounds very direct which isn’t always a good thing.
    That's a very good point. His voice does sound very direct, mainly because the Sphere audio system works very differently than almost every other live venue he's ever played in, with the thousands of speakers piping direct to the seats instead of blasting from the stage. That definitely could be a factor too.
  5. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
    I wonder if there's been some issue with the audio monitoring at the Sphere. I think Bono's voice is still very good. Just take a look at his amazing performances during the book tour, particularly the Stephen Colbert performance which was outstanding. But in the Sphere shows and even the Grammys performance he has been "out of tune" a lot. I'm not sure whether it's a voice problem or a hearing problem. So I wonder if it's an issue with the audio in that venue. Sure, his movements are less sprightly than when he was younger. But mine are too.

    Bono's singing has been my biggest disappointment with the Sphere shows for that very reason. And I have never had that issue with any previous U2 tours. So I'm wondering what's going on. The live performances of Atomic City versus the recorded versions have been particularly atrocious. But Even Better than The Real Thing has been painful and they even released an official video of that performance on their Youtube channel as if to confirm this publicly.

    The one performance that seemed really on point was the "Shut Up" performance of "Peace On Earth" where he got really worked up in the speech beforehand. On that song he hit every note perfectly. That makes me wonder if, as some commenters have remarked, he's not as "hungry" any more and can only hit the notes when he gets triggered like that. I hope that's not true but I just went back and listened to the first recordings from the April 1987 Joshua Tree tour in Arizona and, boy, is that a contrast in energy level from him. Of course I don't expect a 60 year old man to sing like a 30 year old any more but the contrast in the level of passion is noteworthy and maybe U2's music just doesn't sound as good without that level of commitment that the younger Bono was able to bring to it.


    I honestly feel like we’re living in opposite worlds. Bono’s falsetto at the sphere has been unbelievably good, and his control while using it is the best it’s been since pre popmart. I think he’s sounded great and he’s having a lot of fun on stage. So I genuinely can not speak to what you’re witnessing
  6. Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]


    I honestly feel like we’re living in opposite worlds. Bono’s falsetto at the sphere has been unbelievably good, and his control while using it is the best it’s been since pre popmart. I think he’s sounded great and he’s having a lot of fun on stage. So I genuinely can not speak to what you’re witnessing
    Really! You don't find his singing cringeworthy in this clip, for example?

    It's completely out of tune most of the time, especially in the verses.

    I was actually physically uncomfortable the first time I heard this, like the kind of second-hand embarrassment you feel when you hear someone at a karaoke who thinks they're doing an amazing job but everyone is quietly waiting for them to finish.



    Please tell me I'm not the only one who finds this dreadful.
  7. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
    Really! You don't find his singing cringeworthy in this clip, for example?

    It's completely out of tune most of the time, especially in the verses.

    I was actually physically uncomfortable the first time I heard this, like the kind of second-hand embarrassment you feel when you hear someone at a karaoke who thinks they're doing an amazing job but everyone is quietly waiting for them to finish.

    [YouTube Video]

    Please tell me I'm not the only one who finds this dreadful.
    Sounds like talk singing to me, which is kinda what he does in the studio version during the verses. It’s just less controlled here because there’s a performance happening as well. I think if you look up One and So Cruel on that same page you’ll see otherwise quickly
  8. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
    Really! You don't find his singing cringeworthy in this clip, for example?

    It's completely out of tune most of the time, especially in the verses.

    I was actually physically uncomfortable the first time I heard this, like the kind of second-hand embarrassment you feel when you hear someone at a karaoke who thinks they're doing an amazing job but everyone is quietly waiting for them to finish.

    [YouTube Video]

    Please tell me I'm not the only one who finds this dreadful.
  9. Yeah that version of One is fine.

    But to your point about Atomic City being a talk-singing kind of song, he did a more in-tune rendition on the flat-bed truck a few months ago:



    Why can't he sing it that well in the Sphere?
  10. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
    Yeah that version of One is fine.

    But to your point about Atomic City being a talk-singing kind of song, he did a more in-tune rendition on the flat-bed truck a few months ago:

    [YouTube Video]

    Why can't he sing it that well in the Sphere?
    I’m sure he can but that was also him singing with the track.. they were filming the video. The only completely live performance that night was “i still haven’t found”
  11. Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]


    I honestly feel like we’re living in opposite worlds. Bono’s falsetto at the sphere has been unbelievably good, and his control while using it is the best it’s been since pre popmart. I think he’s sounded great and he’s having a lot of fun on stage. So I genuinely can not speak to what you’re witnessing
    His deep falsetto on 360 Tour was stronger than on the Sphere shows, there where are few "Child" in MW on 360 that was almost identical to the sound he got on ZooTV.