Originally posted by Flashbax:Why did they release this EP? Feels so random. Is it a contractual thing?
Originally posted by Flashbax:Why did they release this EP? Feels so random. Is it a contractual thing?
Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
I don't think the EP was contractual. U2 generally haven't been tied to getting out material since the last contract came to a close in around 2020. They are free to do what they want when they want, and have some guarantees the label will back them on promotion and release. Bono's made a few comments about how they are working with more freedom of late I'll try to dig out. "Songs of Surrender" was anything but contractual.
I do see a lot of things being written off as 'contractual' when there's few things that likely have been.
In 2016 they were due to go out on tour, it was scheduled, dates were populated in the system. Live Nation had people hired. And U2 decided the album wasn't done yet. The Joshua Tree tour was born out of that. They agreed to two short legs to make up for the tour they were postponing. They ended up enjoying the whole thing and the latter two legs, and the 2019 tour were all because they wanted to do more. In fact they knew the 2019 stops were likely a losing proposition when it came to money and pushed to do it regardless.
There was Sphere, but they did sign on for that one. All four of them, and then Larry found out he was able to start having the surgeries that he had to repair his back, leg, and other bits that were "falling off". So contractual at that point to make the decision to play without him, but they had signed up for it on their own without that being the reason initially.
As to why they put out the EP? I'm making a guess they wanted to see how it would sell / be received. They've not released much over the years in physical formats but have released a bunch of digital EPs of live material. Singles had been phased out in 2009. And although they've had a bunch of Record Store Day releases, this was the first really independent of that event. It sold well, hit the charts in a few places, and will probably inform release strategies going forward.
Originally posted by Flashbax:[..]
Nice, thanks for that. Do you know their compilation albums The Best Of's & U218 were contractual? To me, it always seemed odd that U218 came 4 years after The Best Of 1990-2000
Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
I don't think the EP was contractual. U2 generally haven't been tied to getting out material since the last contract came to a close in around 2020. They are free to do what they want when they want, and have some guarantees the label will back them on promotion and release. Bono's made a few comments about how they are working with more freedom of late I'll try to dig out. "Songs of Surrender" was anything but contractual.
I do see a lot of things being written off as 'contractual' when there's few things that likely have been.
In 2016 they were due to go out on tour, it was scheduled, dates were populated in the system. Live Nation had people hired. And U2 decided the album wasn't done yet. The Joshua Tree tour was born out of that. They agreed to two short legs to make up for the tour they were postponing. They ended up enjoying the whole thing and the latter two legs, and the 2019 tour were all because they wanted to do more. In fact they knew the 2019 stops were likely a losing proposition when it came to money and pushed to do it regardless.
There was Sphere, but they did sign on for that one. All four of them, and then Larry found out he was able to start having the surgeries that he had to repair his back, leg, and other bits that were "falling off". So contractual at that point to make the decision to play without him, but they had signed up for it on their own without that being the reason initially.
As to why they put out the EP? I'm making a guess they wanted to see how it would sell / be received. They've not released much over the years in physical formats but have released a bunch of digital EPs of live material. Singles had been phased out in 2009. And although they've had a bunch of Record Store Day releases, this was the first really independent of that event. It sold well, hit the charts in a few places, and will probably inform release strategies going forward.
Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
Songs of surrender, How to Re-assemble an Atomic bomb ,Zoo TV EP may not have been "contractual " but it sounds like(hopefully)they were put put out to keep the record company appeased and give the band more time to release new material IMO, why go to the bother of doing SOS and Re-assemble they add nothing to their musucal legacy surely there were a lot within the band and management who would have been strongly opposed to such an idea .
Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
The label had little interest in Songs of Surrender. That sort of thing in the music industry tends to be a low selling proposition. The label would have preferred another greatest hits compilation - of the original versions. The band were talking about some sort of compilation project along those lines as far back as 2018, which was right after SOE came out. All of the stuff you mention originated with the band and not because they had any contract they had to meet. The 20th anniversary of Atomic Bomb could have come out with a bunch of previously released remixes and the live tracks, and everyone at the label would have been perfectly happy, and that's what we almost got. It was Edge that pushed to get an album of demos pulled together for release as an added component.
Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
I'm not buying all that sorry ,SOS is a pile of cow dung that adds nothing to the songs it should never have had a stand alone release IMO and should have been a U2.com gift or Streaming exclusive during lockdown, It was a way of keeping the record label happy because they hadn't a new album ready to go when they were supposed to have.
Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
I'm not buying all that sorry ,SOS is a pile of cow dung that adds nothing to the songs it should never have had a stand alone release IMO and should have been a U2.com gift or Streaming exclusive during lockdown, It was a way of keeping the record label happy because they hadn't a new album ready to go when they were supposed to have.