1. Why did they release this EP? Feels so random. Is it a contractual thing?
  2. Most probably. It wasn't a very generous or exciting release anyway. The whole show should have been remastered and put out.

    More crumbs from their table.
  3. I don't think the EP was contractual. U2 generally haven't been tied to getting out material since the last contract came to a close in around 2020. They are free to do what they want when they want, and have some guarantees the label will back them on promotion and release. Bono's made a few comments about how they are working with more freedom of late I'll try to dig out. "Songs of Surrender" was anything but contractual.

    I do see a lot of things being written off as 'contractual' when there's few things that likely have been.

    In 2016 they were due to go out on tour, it was scheduled, dates were populated in the system. Live Nation had people hired. And U2 decided the album wasn't done yet. The Joshua Tree tour was born out of that. They agreed to two short legs to make up for the tour they were postponing. They ended up enjoying the whole thing and the latter two legs, and the 2019 tour were all because they wanted to do more. In fact they knew the 2019 stops were likely a losing proposition when it came to money and pushed to do it regardless.

    There was Sphere, but they did sign on for that one. All four of them, and then Larry found out he was able to start having the surgeries that he had to repair his back, leg, and other bits that were "falling off". So contractual at that point to make the decision to play without him, but they had signed up for it on their own without that being the reason initially.

    As to why they put out the EP? I'm making a guess they wanted to see how it would sell / be received. They've not released much over the years in physical formats but have released a bunch of digital EPs of live material. Singles had been phased out in 2009. And although they've had a bunch of Record Store Day releases, this was the first really independent of that event. It sold well, hit the charts in a few places, and will probably inform release strategies going forward.
  4. big desire for lovetown EP
  5. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
    I don't think the EP was contractual. U2 generally haven't been tied to getting out material since the last contract came to a close in around 2020. They are free to do what they want when they want, and have some guarantees the label will back them on promotion and release. Bono's made a few comments about how they are working with more freedom of late I'll try to dig out. "Songs of Surrender" was anything but contractual.

    I do see a lot of things being written off as 'contractual' when there's few things that likely have been.

    In 2016 they were due to go out on tour, it was scheduled, dates were populated in the system. Live Nation had people hired. And U2 decided the album wasn't done yet. The Joshua Tree tour was born out of that. They agreed to two short legs to make up for the tour they were postponing. They ended up enjoying the whole thing and the latter two legs, and the 2019 tour were all because they wanted to do more. In fact they knew the 2019 stops were likely a losing proposition when it came to money and pushed to do it regardless.

    There was Sphere, but they did sign on for that one. All four of them, and then Larry found out he was able to start having the surgeries that he had to repair his back, leg, and other bits that were "falling off". So contractual at that point to make the decision to play without him, but they had signed up for it on their own without that being the reason initially.

    As to why they put out the EP? I'm making a guess they wanted to see how it would sell / be received. They've not released much over the years in physical formats but have released a bunch of digital EPs of live material. Singles had been phased out in 2009. And although they've had a bunch of Record Store Day releases, this was the first really independent of that event. It sold well, hit the charts in a few places, and will probably inform release strategies going forward.
    Nice, thanks for that. Do you know their compilation albums The Best Of's & U218 were contractual? To me, it always seemed odd that U218 came 4 years after The Best Of 1990-2000
  6. Originally posted by Flashbax:[..]
    Nice, thanks for that. Do you know their compilation albums The Best Of's & U218 were contractual? To me, it always seemed odd that U218 came 4 years after The Best Of 1990-2000
    Yes they cut a contract in 1998 for three compilation albums - one for the 80s, one for the 90s and one that was to be more general in nature, a more complete Best Of. Those are the three that we got 1980-1990, 1990-2000, and U218 Singles. 1998, 2002 and 2006, one every four years.
  7. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
    I don't think the EP was contractual. U2 generally haven't been tied to getting out material since the last contract came to a close in around 2020. They are free to do what they want when they want, and have some guarantees the label will back them on promotion and release. Bono's made a few comments about how they are working with more freedom of late I'll try to dig out. "Songs of Surrender" was anything but contractual.

    I do see a lot of things being written off as 'contractual' when there's few things that likely have been.

    In 2016 they were due to go out on tour, it was scheduled, dates were populated in the system. Live Nation had people hired. And U2 decided the album wasn't done yet. The Joshua Tree tour was born out of that. They agreed to two short legs to make up for the tour they were postponing. They ended up enjoying the whole thing and the latter two legs, and the 2019 tour were all because they wanted to do more. In fact they knew the 2019 stops were likely a losing proposition when it came to money and pushed to do it regardless.

    There was Sphere, but they did sign on for that one. All four of them, and then Larry found out he was able to start having the surgeries that he had to repair his back, leg, and other bits that were "falling off". So contractual at that point to make the decision to play without him, but they had signed up for it on their own without that being the reason initially.

    As to why they put out the EP? I'm making a guess they wanted to see how it would sell / be received. They've not released much over the years in physical formats but have released a bunch of digital EPs of live material. Singles had been phased out in 2009. And although they've had a bunch of Record Store Day releases, this was the first really independent of that event. It sold well, hit the charts in a few places, and will probably inform release strategies going forward.
    Songs of surrender, How to Re-assemble an Atomic bomb ,Zoo TV EP may not have been "contractual " but it sounds like(hopefully)they were put put out to keep the record company appeased and give the band more time to release new material IMO, why go to the bother of doing SOS and Re-assemble they add nothing to their musucal legacy surely there were a lot within the band and management who would have been strongly opposed to such an idea .
  8. Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
    Songs of surrender, How to Re-assemble an Atomic bomb ,Zoo TV EP may not have been "contractual " but it sounds like(hopefully)they were put put out to keep the record company appeased and give the band more time to release new material IMO, why go to the bother of doing SOS and Re-assemble they add nothing to their musucal legacy surely there were a lot within the band and management who would have been strongly opposed to such an idea .


    The label had little interest in Songs of Surrender. That sort of thing in the music industry tends to be a low selling proposition. The label would have preferred another greatest hits compilation - of the original versions. The band were talking about some sort of compilation project along those lines as far back as 2018, which was right after SOE came out. All of the stuff you mention originated with the band and not because they had any contract they had to meet. The 20th anniversary of Atomic Bomb could have come out with a bunch of previously released remixes and the live tracks, and everyone at the label would have been perfectly happy, and that's what we almost got. It was Edge that pushed to get an album of demos pulled together for release as an added component.
  9. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]


    The label had little interest in Songs of Surrender. That sort of thing in the music industry tends to be a low selling proposition. The label would have preferred another greatest hits compilation - of the original versions. The band were talking about some sort of compilation project along those lines as far back as 2018, which was right after SOE came out. All of the stuff you mention originated with the band and not because they had any contract they had to meet. The 20th anniversary of Atomic Bomb could have come out with a bunch of previously released remixes and the live tracks, and everyone at the label would have been perfectly happy, and that's what we almost got. It was Edge that pushed to get an album of demos pulled together for release as an added component.
    I'm not buying all that sorry ,SOS is a pile of cow dung that adds nothing to the songs it should never have had a stand alone release IMO and should have been a U2.com gift or Streaming exclusive during lockdown, It was a way of keeping the record label happy because they hadn't a new album ready to go when they were supposed to have.
  10. Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
    I'm not buying all that sorry ,SOS is a pile of cow dung that adds nothing to the songs it should never have had a stand alone release IMO and should have been a U2.com gift or Streaming exclusive during lockdown, It was a way of keeping the record label happy because they hadn't a new album ready to go when they were supposed to have.
    A. U2's contract ended in 2020 just as Covid started. The band had no obligations to do an new album going into Covid. The contract they are working with now was negotiated during that time, and leaves them with quite a bit of freedom and doesn't impose a timeline on getting a new album done. Things were kept very open because no one knew what was going on with Covid. Bono has spoken on a couple of occasions about having the freedom to work at their own pace and not be working to a deadline. (One of those interviews was with Jenna Bush in the leadup to Sphere.)

    B. The band were already working on the idea of Songs of Surrender in 2018. The plan was all in place, new recordings of all of the songs on the album, which would be made up of hits of earlier albums. The project at the time was planned to coincide for launch with the U2-X Exhibition in Dublin. I reported it in January 2019 for the first time as a possible upcoming compilation, at that time also called U2-X. I know who told me about it and how they would know that information, and more, the project actually happened so I guess they did know what they are talking about. Less than a year after SOE was released, they were talking to people about the idea that became the SOS project. No one at the label was expecting a new album from U2 or pushing for a new album from U2 less than a year after the last, especially when they had spent most of that year on the road.

    C. Edge in May 2020 confirmed he was working on new recordings of older U2 songs. At that point he wasn't sure what they would be used for, and if it might be a solo project, something for a film, or something else. That was about 2 and a half years after the last album, so yes, maybe there was some push towards a new album by that point, but Covid was on, and I doubt anyone was being pushed too much until we figured out what was going on.

    D. In late 2020 / early 2021 Adam did a number of appearances talking about what the band was up to. He told U2 X-Radio "Well, you know we are playing around with rearranging some of the songs that we have and setting them in a more acoustic environment. Edge got a bit of a bee in his bonnet and said you know, no pun intended, said lets look at these songs and imagine them in a different context. So we are playing around with that. He’s putting a lot of work into changing the keys, and moving them onto piano and that sort of thing." At that point they were well underway on the project. Three years on from the release of Songs of Experience. Probably getting some questions on when a new album would be out from the label, but probably not an unexpected time frame for U2 to be working on something.

    E. And Songs of Surrender was delayed twice. It was originally planned for a late 2021 release, but the release of Bono's book was shifted back a year and an additional rewrite was done in that time. The album was then planned for November 2022, to coincide with the book, but was pushed back into 2023 when a book tour was decided upon. It was delivered to the label in June of 2022.

    They weren't being pushed to develop Songs of Surrender because a new album was late. They were talking about doing just that as early as the year following the release of that album. It was in development for a long time, and was probably meant to be developed alongside a new album, and came to the forefront when Covid came along. Early on Edge was approaching it as solo material, somewhere along the way it went from being tied to the exhibition, to being tied to Bono's book.

    It wasn't something knocked together in a couple of months to fill a gap by not having an album of new material to go. There's more than enough evidence along the way that they had the idea for a number of years and that's what they got to first, perhaps all being in separate countries and unable to work in a room together, it was the easiest thing to tackle.

    Believe what you want though. And I'll believe the above. Will circle back if i can find those Bono quotes.

    EDIT:
    Bono: "“It’s nice to work without a purpose. Which is to say, it’s not like somebody is coming up and saying we have to have a U2 album or we have to have a U2 tour. We’ve been talking, and are excited to work together again. In the next few weeks there will be some recording.” (November 2021)

    The Edge mentioned the band is “locked in the tower of song and working away on a bunch of new things. I’m just having so much fun writing and not necessarily having to think about where it’s going to go.” (November 2021)

    Adam: "We’re looking at going back into the studio and recording. We haven’t fixed anything. It feels like the right time now. It feels like we need to do another record." (October 2021)

    Doesn't sound like they were really being pushed all that hard. At least not at that point.
  11. Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
    I'm not buying all that sorry ,SOS is a pile of cow dung that adds nothing to the songs it should never have had a stand alone release IMO and should have been a U2.com gift or Streaming exclusive during lockdown, It was a way of keeping the record label happy because they hadn't a new album ready to go when they were supposed to have.
    I agree with you on this one and believe this was the same case for the HTDAAB box set and reassemble. It was quoted (by our mate U2W) that there were no plans for a big box set reissue for the 20th Anniversary. This was also around the time that rumours were swirling that the band were working on new material ("bad ass guitar album" anybody?). Surprise surprise the new material didnt eventuate and then all of a sudden the rumours swirl and U2W is posting about the upcoming 20th Anniversary release for HTDAAB... 100000% this was to appease the record label due to new material not being ready or been thrown out.
  12. Does it really make sense to argue with the one person on here who has access to some factual inside information?

    Does a band of U2's stature have to appease any record company? We were just told that the terms of their current contract stipulate no due dates.