1. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:Recently someone corrected me when I said it was U2's 50th Anniversary. The argument was made that a band couldn't celebrate their anniversary until it was the 50th anniversary of their first album release (not a single, the album).

    So thought I'd ask here. What do you consider U2's 50th anniversary?

    - The 50th anniversary of the first meeting in Larry's kitchen (September 76)
    - The 50th anniversary of Dik leaving the band and them first performing as U2 (March 4, 1978)
    - The 50th anniversary of their first release? (Three, September 79)
    - The 50th anniversary of their first album? (Boy, October 80)
    - One of the above but minus 6 months for the period working with Bram

    Personally I still look at this year as the 50th anniversary. All four of them came together to form something. I get that the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame have a different criteria when establishing eligibility which ties to release dates, but I don't think that impacts when you would say a band had formed.
    Adam in particular has said they’ll be celebrating the 50th this year,no definite plans but that champagne will be popped. But,doesn’t Bono dispute the September date and thinks it’s November?

    Either way,to me it’s 1976 so 50th the year they got together.
  2. 50th anniversary of 'U2' doesn't happen until 2028 as they didn't adopt the name 'U2' until then

    The 50th anniversary of the 4 guys meeting in Larry's kitchen is a totally different thing - that would be the 50th anniversary of them meeting and becoming a band but - pedantically - not of 'U2'

    'The Beatles' began without Ringo so do Beatles fans celebrate anniversaries when the name was given to the band or when Ringo joined and they became 'The Beatles' as we know them?
  3. What's in a name? (didn't some guy already ask that question sometime?)

    Gotta go with Larry's kitchen.
  4. The fact that all 4 members of U2 were present at Larry’s kitchen on 9/25/76 make it the anniversary.

    If it were Bono and Larry in the kitchen, and Adam and Edge joined sometime in the next year or two then it would be questionable.
  5. The band always talk about the first meeting. They acknowldged 40 years in 2016.
  6. Originally posted by RedSky:50th anniversary of 'U2' doesn't happen until 2028 as they didn't adopt the name 'U2' until then

    The 50th anniversary of the 4 guys meeting in Larry's kitchen is a totally different thing - that would be the 50th anniversary of them meeting and becoming a band but - pedantically - not of 'U2'

    'The Beatles' began without Ringo so do Beatles fans celebrate anniversaries when the name was given to the band or when Ringo joined and they became 'The Beatles' as we know them?

    The Beatles changed their name from The Silver Beetles in between gigs at a venue in my hometown on Wirral.There was a big rivalry between local bands fans and Beatles fans,in other words a lot of fighting so in the end they weren’t getting advertised as playing a venue to avoid it.

    They did a campaign in 1982 when they started to rerelease the music starting with the 1st single Love Me Do under the campaign ‘It was 20 years ago yeah yeah yeah’ They released them on picture disc,I’m sure that slogan was on one side of the disc.I gave up buying them about 5 singles in.I’ve attached a picture of a keyring I have with that slogan on it.So that’s 44 years old.So,I’m guessing Beatles fans start from 1962,so in that respect U2 would be 1979.
  7. Originally posted by gmc:[..]
    [image]
    The Beatles changed their name from The Silver Beetles in between gigs at a venue in my hometown on Wirral.There was a big rivalry between local bands fans and Beatles fans,in other words a lot of fighting so in the end they weren’t getting advertised as playing a venue to avoid it.

    They did a campaign in 1982 when they started to rerelease the music starting with the 1st single Love Me Do under the campaign ‘It was 20 years ago yeah yeah yeah’ They released them on picture disc,I’m sure that slogan was on one side of the disc.I gave up buying them about 5 singles in.I’ve attached a picture of a keyring I have with that slogan on it.So that’s 44 years old.So,I’m guessing Beatles fans start from 1962,so in that respect U2 would be 1979.


    Interesting stuff - cheers
  8. IMHO it’s the meeting in Larry’s kitchen.
  9. With the Beatles, no offense to Pete Best or Stu Sutcliffe.but its John, Paul, George and Ringo. Id say first Hamburg gig or Cavern with that line up counts.

    With U2, sure the kitchen. But there were others there I believe? Dik Evans? Also they were called The Hype and Feedback before settling ng on the name U2.
  10. so we have to wait 2 more years for the new album
  11. For me it's hard to get excited. Soon in U2 terms can be everything. Could be 2 days. Could be 2 months. Could be postponed last minute and we have to wait another year. And there's always the possibility we'll get dissapointed like when they released Ahimsa.

    I just wait and see.