1. Topic for track 1 of Days of Ash EP


    You have the right to remain silent
    or not…

    God above a mother's love
    A guiding hand to pick you up
    To crush her like a coffee cup
    Why?
    Crossing guard or yellow bus
    Our children teach us who to trust
    The worst can't kill what's best in us
    But they can try
    America will rise
    Against the people of the lie

    I love you more
    Than hate loves war
    I love you more
    Than hate loves war
    (War, war)

    We love you more than hate loves war

    Renee Good born to die free
    American mother of three
    Seventh day January
    A bullet for each child, you see
    The color of her eye
    930 Minneapolis
    To desecrate domestic bliss
    Three bullets blast, three babies kissed
    Renee the domestic terrorist???
    What you can't kill can't die
    America will rise
    Against the people of the lie
    I love you more
    Than hate loves war
    I love you more
    Than hate loves war
    (War, war)

    We love you more than hate loves war

    I am not mad at you, Lord
    You're the reason I was there
    Could you stop a heart from breaking
    By having it not care?
    Could you stop a bullet in midair?

    She says…
    The power of the people is so much stronger than the people in power
    The power of the people is so much stronger than the people in power
    The power of the people is so much stronger than the people in power

    In the streets with children playing
    In the churches where they're praying
    School teachers are explaining
    America, America
    The power of the people!

    We love you more (we say, we say) than hate loves war
    I love you more (I say, I say) than hate loves war

    https://u2start.com/songs/1368
  2. I like the lyric, I like the energy. The arrangement is a shambles though.
  3. Guitar straight from Pop is awesome to hear
  4. Doesn't come close to songs like GOYB or YTBTAM, but I think it's on par or even better than The Miracle (Of Joey Ramone). It's a good song, has a 90s vibe, kinda Holy Joe. Doesn't pretend to be anything more, and it delivers.
  5. The lyric delivery and melody on American Obituary sounds very similar to Happiness from How to Reassemble an Atomic Bomb.
  6. That was my initial thought, too.
  7. As bad as American Soul? no
    Useful live next tour? yes
  8. My thoughts exactly. So much better than American Soul.

    I really like the "I love you more than hate loves war" refrain and the bridge lyrics ("I am not mad at you, Lord...") And Edge's guitar!
  9. At least they won't play it outside of USA.

    I'd hope lol.
  10. I'm starting to think that they might avoid the USA come touring season or at least cover the ROW first.
  11. I hate to say this, and am glad some folks like this one, but if an 8th grade U2 cover band tried to write their own original protest song, it would be American Obituary. It is so obviously cobbled together in a rush. Just abysmal. Banal lyrics, weird arrangement. I’m stunned the band viewed this as worthy of putting out. It’s the ying to American Soul’s yang. Let both of those tunes be left in the dustbin of the U2 catalog.

    To mention AO in the same breath as a SBS or Please is just an incredible disservice to those incredibly crafted and beautiful songs.

    Drop this song from the EP and I think you’d have a VERY complete and moving collection of contemporary political songs.
  12. Can't they do an extended Canadian/Mexico tour as part of North America first? 😛