1. Originally posted by miryclay:[..]
    It is always interesting when a new release drops that we can re-appraise the previous releases. Even EI has caused me to look at DOA differently.
    Agreed. DOA sounds a lot better now treated as the first side of the LP, Easter Lily being the second. Together they make great U2 album, number 6 currently on my band’s best albums list.
  2. It’s very difficult to try not to make comments like ‘best u2 music in ….. years’ when I’m enjoying these songs so much. This is so much better than anything I thought they were capable of at this stage of their career. With both EP’s it feels like the band have poured everything into them and I can only expect that to continue for the album now. They’ve set a high bar for the album but why not go and raise it even higher. In their mid 60’s and still going strong.
  3. I think it is a decent offering , but nothing radical and still stuck in the " Songs Of " sound. I understand the praise but I have seen this time and again on this forum where it's laid on thick in the early days of a release and then months / years later it's trash.
  4. Originally posted by badirishcharlie:I think it is a decent offering , but nothing radical and still stuck in the " Songs Of " sound. I understand the praise but I have seen this time and again on this forum where it's laid on thick in the early days of a release and then months / years later it's trash.
    It is always difficult with new material to tell how good it really is. There is that initial excitement that can sometimes cloud our judgment. When it comes to commenting on it though all we can do is express how we feel about the material now. Whether that holds up in years to come remains to be seen.
  5. Originally posted by badirishcharlie:I think it is a decent offering , but nothing radical and still stuck in the " Songs Of " sound. I understand the praise but I have seen this time and again on this forum where it's laid on thick in the early days of a release and then months / years later it's trash.
    Days of Ash lost its hype, and Easter Lily is way better. I don't think I'll ever go back to American Obituary, Wildpeace, or Yours Eternally. Not even Song of the Future, as much as I loved it at the beginning and the state of the world and Iran call for it. Might go back to One Life at A Time, but it was never my favorite from DOA.

    All said, Tears of Things remains a Masterpiece.

    Trying to be more objective here with Easter Lily:
    -I like elements of Song for Hal, and I think it's touching emotionally. But don't love it as much as people are praising it. Nothing new or groundbreaking from the band.
    -I love In A Life and I'm looking forward to hear it live!
    -I don't like Scars, although I like its instrumental part and it's a cute message.
    -I love Resurrection Song. It's a beautiful song and also looking forward to hearing it live next year.
    -Easter Parade, beautiful, but would be hard to play live.
    -Coexist, beautiful too.

    Will all of these new songs stand the test of time? Not really
    But Resurrection Song, In A Life, and Coexist could
  6. I still think that the two EPs, taken together, are the best work the band has released since, at least, ATYCLB. Will I change my mind? Who knows?

    But the buzz here and elsewhere suggests that a lot of people feel there is something different about this latest stuff, something that has been missing for ages.
  7. It’s interesting to see the differences between these two records. Obviously “American Obituary” beyond the lyric, is a very straight ahead U2 rock song. But stuff like “Tears” and “Song Of The Future” paint a really interesting picture of where the band could be going to sonically that’s new fertile ground. Whereas the Easter lily record, with the exception of “CoExist”, feels like an exercise in the band being unabashedly U2. The riff in “In A Life” and “Scars” is so U2 that it’s almost what a computer would create if you asked it to give you a U2 riff. And that’s not an insult. It’s nice to see the band being willing to say “ this is kind of what we do”. I like both records a lot, for me days of Ash just barely gets an edge because I feel like “Tears” it’s so ridiculously strong. But it’s all really good material, and it makes me very optimistic that if these are our “outtakes”, we must be in for something very special in the fall
  8. So rumour going around … I will just post what I have seen in a few places now:

    🚨🚨SONGS OF ASCENT COMING MAY 2026? 🚨🚨

    There's a theory that U2 will release their new record production by May and this theory has an impressive logical base that fits perfectly with the band's spiritual narrative.

    If we analyze the Days of Ash pattern released on Ash Wednesday and Easter Lily appearing just before Easter it is clear that the group is following the liturgical calendar with surgical precision.

    The six-week interval between releases leads us straight to the Ascension festival (May 14). For a band that has been mentioning the Songs of Ascent project as their great work pending transcendence this coincidence seems more of a planned strategy than a mere coincidence.

    U2 has always been adept at using symbolology to add depth to their music and this would be the way to close their trilogy of records (Songs of Innocence, Songs of Experience and Songs of Ascent).

    This possible LP titled Songs of Ascent would represent the arrival and culmination of this emotional journey that begins with chaos and loss. The structure of ashes resurrection and ascension is too coherent to pass up.

    If confirmed this launch in May 2026 would consolidate as a key year where the group finally manages to unite its meditative past with its current urgency. It's a very solid hypothesis that respects the history and thematic obsessions of U2


    This sounds very plausible.

    U2wanderer, have you heard this one!? If no is this a plausible thing?
  9. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:So rumour going around … I will just post what I have seen in a few places now:

    🚨🚨SONGS OF ASCENT COMING MAY 2026? 🚨🚨

    There's a theory that U2 will release their new record production by May and this theory has an impressive logical base that fits perfectly with the band's spiritual narrative.

    If we analyze the Days of Ash pattern released on Ash Wednesday and Easter Lily appearing just before Easter it is clear that the group is following the liturgical calendar with surgical precision.

    The six-week interval between releases leads us straight to the Ascension festival (May 14). For a band that has been mentioning the Songs of Ascent project as their great work pending transcendence this coincidence seems more of a planned strategy than a mere coincidence.

    U2 has always been adept at using symbolology to add depth to their music and this would be the way to close their trilogy of records (Songs of Innocence, Songs of Experience and Songs of Ascent).

    This possible LP titled Songs of Ascent would represent the arrival and culmination of this emotional journey that begins with chaos and loss. The structure of ashes resurrection and ascension is too coherent to pass up.

    If confirmed this launch in May 2026 would consolidate as a key year where the group finally manages to unite its meditative past with its current urgency. It's a very solid hypothesis that respects the history and thematic obsessions of U2


    This sounds very plausible.

    U2wanderer, have you heard this one!? If no is this a plausible thing?
    U2W have said the Songs of... series has ended. It will not be Songs of Ascent. Besides that, U2 themselves said with both EP releases the new album will be released in fall.

    I wouldn't rule out a third EP in May or June
  10. Most likely the remaining SOA songs good enough for release will be put out in a 3rd EP titled Ascension or Ascent or whatever.
  11. It's a great theory. But four things...

    1. Bono has said "Songs of..." is no longer being done. He made several appearances during the promotion of "HTDAAB" where he claimed he's moving on from that idea. So even if that material comes out some day, it would likely be under a different title.

    2. A lot of people are hyping up a possible album in May. The album will be out this Fall. Likely in September. So even if they were to release something for the Ascension I doubt it would be a full length LP.

    3. There is some evidence that the songs once due for "Songs of Ascent" have been used on the current two EPs. "The Tears of Things" almost certainly did. And some of "Easter Lily" feels like it could come from there as well.

    4. As of Friday I was told there was no plans for another EP, that gears were shifting to get ready to launch the single next. Does that rule out a third EP? No, they went back and forth on when to do Easter Lily or if they would at all. But I am able to say, based on the conversations I have had, I don't believe right now they are planning a third EP. They have a lot to do before a single comes out. Artwork, remixes, a video featuring the band, promotional appearances some of which will be pre-taped, interviews with the press etc. They are working on finalizing elements of the record as well. There is a lot of work that went into "Days of Ash" and "Easter Lily", pulling off a third isn't impossible, but I believe that work will switch to the new single.
  12. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:So rumour going around … I will just post what I have seen in a few places now:

    🚨🚨SONGS OF ASCENT COMING MAY 2026? 🚨🚨

    There's a theory that U2 will release their new record production by May and this theory has an impressive logical base that fits perfectly with the band's spiritual narrative.

    If we analyze the Days of Ash pattern released on Ash Wednesday and Easter Lily appearing just before Easter it is clear that the group is following the liturgical calendar with surgical precision.

    The six-week interval between releases leads us straight to the Ascension festival (May 14). For a band that has been mentioning the Songs of Ascent project as their great work pending transcendence this coincidence seems more of a planned strategy than a mere coincidence.

    U2 has always been adept at using symbolology to add depth to their music and this would be the way to close their trilogy of records (Songs of Innocence, Songs of Experience and Songs of Ascent).

    This possible LP titled Songs of Ascent would represent the arrival and culmination of this emotional journey that begins with chaos and loss. The structure of ashes resurrection and ascension is too coherent to pass up.

    If confirmed this launch in May 2026 would consolidate as a key year where the group finally manages to unite its meditative past with its current urgency. It's a very solid hypothesis that respects the history and thematic obsessions of U2


    This sounds very plausible.

    U2wanderer, have you heard this one!? If no is this a plausible thing?
    Written by AI? Lol.