Originally posted by dstankie:What more do you want RedSky? (not being flippant, I'm genuinely curious)
It's a good question - and it's all subjective
I might feel Zooropa (the song) was an amazing epic piece of work whereas someone else might think that it's slow and overly long - it's all just opinions and I'm sharing mine
(To me) there's something lacking - the creativity is there, the musicianship is there, the boys are there, but it doesn't grab me by the b*llocks
The 2 EPs are good but not great - so I guess I want greatness
And we all know what is truly great in a U2 sense: AB TJT - and for me Z and P
And before people say 'Oh who wants another AB or JT' that's not the point - the point is those albums couldn't be more different musically but they all stand up as great pieces of work
ATYCLB was a good album but not great and all the albums after that have never reached the apex of their best work - some albums touching the nadir fans might say
So - for me personally - I want to be excited by the music and not just find it good/well done/meaningful/interesting
I want to hear something and shout out 'WOW!'
For me to describe that to you is impossible - but when I heard (say) TJT for the first time I shouted 'WOW! when I heard AB for the first time I shouted 'WOW!'
So it's not that I want them to go back and record the past - I want the new stuff to make me shout 'WOW!' and so far it makes me think that it's good but not great
I'll still enjoy hearing the band create new stuff - but sonically I want that 'WOW!'
Again, only my opinion, but I feel a lot of the fans seem to be (overly) happy with 'good'
Originally posted by Pauln:Taken from an X post by U2Chile translated
I don’t feel like Easter Lily is just an EP. I listen to it as a complete work, short in duration but immense in intent. And that’s why, for me, it absolutely deserves to be called a masterpiece.
What impresses me most is that U2 didn’t just put together six loose songs: they crafted a journey. The EP starts in absence, moves through friendship, accepts the wound, risks love, turns into prayer, and ends by confronting that prayer with the world’s pain. That’s no accident. That’s emotional architecture.
“Song for Hal” opens the record right where it should: in grief. Not with spectacle, not with grandiosity, but with that strange silence left by someone important when they’re gone. The EP kicks off by telling you something basic and brutal: to talk about renewal, you first have to face the loss head-on.
“In A Life” does something beautiful: it doesn’t respond to grief with self-sufficiency, but with friendship. It doesn’t present friendship as ornament or nostalgia, but as a way of connecting with the other even in the strange, the surreal, the difficult. As if to say: no one gets through a life alone, and certainly not a broken life.
“Scars” is where the EP stops asking permission. There, U2 doesn’t romanticize the wound: it accepts it. Scars don’t appear as something to hide, but as marks of truth. And that strikes me as deeply honest, because renewal that doesn’t pass through the wound isn’t renewal: it’s makeup.
Then comes “Resurrection Song,” which for me is the heart of the EP. That song understands something essential: resurrection doesn’t start with religious certainty; it starts when you stop obeying fear. Loving again, trusting again, opening up again: that’s where new life begins. Not as a slogan, but as a risk.
“Easter Parade” takes everything that came before and transforms it into ritual. We’re no longer just in the emotional, but in the spiritual. But not from triumphalism, from humility. There’s inner death, there’s loss of fear, there’s a plea for mercy. It doesn’t sound like cheap victory. It sounds like real rebirth.
And then comes “COEXIST (I Will Bless The Lord At All Times?)”, which for me is what finally elevates the EP. Because it refuses to close on a comfortable note. After talking about friendship, wound, love, and resurrection, U2 brings it all back to the hardest place: the real world, children trapped in war, faith tested by horror. It’s a brave ending, because it doesn’t turn hope into anesthesia.
That’s why I say Easter Lily has everything I expected from U2. It has spiritual ambition, but no arrogance. It has moral awareness, but no pamphleteering. It has intimacy, but no isolation. It has faith, but a questioned, wounded, human faith. And above all, it has something that doesn’t always appear even in great artists: necessity.
This EP doesn’t sound like a band trying to seem relevant. It sounds like a band that still has something true to say.
For me, that’s the difference between a good release and a masterpiece: a masterpiece doesn’t just get listened to. It also orders you from the inside.
And Easter Lily does exactly that.
@U2
@fansofu2
@U2Chile
Originally posted by RedSky:[..]
It's a good question - and it's all subjective
I might feel Zooropa (the song) was an amazing epic piece of work whereas someone else might think that it's slow and overly long - it's all just opinions and I'm sharing mine
(To me) there's something lacking - the creativity is there, the musicianship is there, the boys are there, but it doesn't grab me by the b*llocks
The 2 EPs are good but not great - so I guess I want greatness
And we all know what is truly great in a U2 sense: AB TJT - and for me Z and P
And before people say 'Oh who wants another AB or JT' that's not the point - the point is those albums couldn't be more different musically but they all stand up as great pieces of work
ATYCLB was a good album but not great and all the albums after that have never reached the apex of their best work - some albums touching the nadir fans might say
So - for me personally - I want to be excited by the music and not just find it good/well done/meaningful/interesting
I want to hear something and shout out 'WOW!'
For me to describe that to you is impossible - but when I heard (say) TJT for the first time I shouted 'WOW! when I heard AB for the first time I shouted 'WOW!'
So it's not that I want them to go back and record the past - I want the new stuff to make me shout 'WOW!' and so far it makes me think that it's good but not great
I'll still enjoy hearing the band create new stuff - but sonically I want that 'WOW!'
Again, only my opinion, but I feel a lot of the fans seem to be (overly) happy with 'good'
cheers mate
Originally posted by dstankie:[..]
I get what you mean exactly. I don't think I will ever again have the experiences that I had with JT and AB. I was the right age for both--still just developing my musical tastes. In both cases my first reaction wasn't "wow" but "what the heck is this?", since they didn't sound like what I thought I could expect from U2. But in both cases it didn't take too long to realize they were sublime. They were each both completely fulfilled, unique artistic visions that still move us to this day, from the first song to the last.
I too still rate the rest of the 90s stuff very highly and feel like ATYCLB, while having lots of great songs, was somehow the beginning of the long latter phase of the band that mostly didn't live up to what came before.
I'm not claiming that Easter Lily is on the level of JT and AB. What excites me about it (and Days of Ash to be honest) is that there is a joyful ease to them. These songs don't sound overly "assembled" or fussed over. To me it sounds like the band is suddenly able to access elements of their past music at will and make songs that are not merely derivative but are living creative expressions.
If you had told me 35 years ago that the band I obsessively loved would release something so inspiring and alive when I was more than half a century old, I don't think I would have believed you. I do think there are elements of greatness here. I think there are songs here that are not embarrassed to be played alongside their classics. But that aside, this just sounds like (or maybe just has the spirit of) U2 again, as I knew and loved them through several phases and stages of exploration.
In short, I feel joy listening to these songs and think to myself, "now where has this band been?"
Originally posted by ChcgMat:Also, side note: at least they've had a long enough career that almost every generation of fan has a favorite "era". But as a long time fan, I can say they've provided me with years of joy and entertainment. In my mind, I've got my money's worth and they are free to do whatever they want.