This is a great point. They could have rested a long time ago, but they continue to eff around with shit. Good for them.
We don't need an infinite recycling of the same old same old....which is what some people seem to want....
Originally posted by BelgianBono:[..]
Thank you for sharing these insights.
You're hitting some very important and true points here:
These guys are mid-60 and still searching for new ground.
They could've just keep on playing the hits à la Simple Minds or releasing music from the old blueprints, but no. That's not sufficient.
Plus, what's indeed more important is that the long-time concern of "being relevant" doesn't matter to them anymore.
Tbh, I still don't know what to think of this EP, as it's so different indeed.
My brain just doesn't connect all the dots yet (could be me).
But you can tell these songs come from another deep and both univeral, yet personal level that's very important to them.
Not just the typical love/death/friendship themes (SOI) or criticism about the world (DOA), but something deeper.
Happy to try and dig in during the next weeks/months.
I've been a U2 since I heard New Year's Day on MTV. Causal at first. Achtung Baby was my WOW! moment.
I find someting I like from all periods. Even Songs of Surrender.
Originally posted by ChcgMat:Also, side note: at least they've had a long enough career that almost every generation of fan has a favorite "era". But as a long time fan, I can say they've provided me with years of joy and entertainment. In my mind, I've got my money's worth and they are free to do whatever they want.
Exactly they've done it all multiple times I do expect a more uplifting album than the last few, Bono is obsessed with making a more joyful type of Record as a some of their music can be quite often dark,emotional and introspective, but if the 2 EPs are anything to go by it's exciting times ahead regardless.
Re: Coexist. I know some people do not care for this song, but this song is the first in almost thirty years to give me hope. Since ATYCLB. one of my biggest complaints is their chasing radio hits and trying to stay relevant.
In this time they were following the influence of bands who were influenced by them. U2 were good, but were no longer THE influencer. I had wished that U2 would to quote them, "get out of their own way" and Coexist is exactly that. It's the experimental U2 I've missed, who is not chasing hits, but instead going down a road to see where it goes and not overthinking it for years on end.
And I would say that they have plenty left to prove (as these EPs demonstrate).
There is no point in going for anything but greatness in your art, especially if you have already achieved it. No one (excepting us diehard loyalists) needs another mediocre U2 album. Whereas the world always needs a masterpiece.
Originally posted by h3ath:Re: Coexist. I know some people do not care for this song, but this song is the first in almost thirty years to give me hope. Since ATYCLB. one of my biggest complaints is their chasing radio hits and trying to stay relevant.
In this time they were following the influence of bands who were influenced by them. U2 were good, but were no longer THE influencer. I had wished that U2 would to quote them, "get out of their own way" and Coexist is exactly that. It's the experimental U2 I've missed, who is not chasing hits, but instead going down a road to see where it goes and not overthinking it for years on end.
It's not experimental U2 at all. It's just a soundscape by Brian Eno with Bono singing. Edge, Larry and Adam have no involvement to this song.
And for a fan to say they don't need a masterpiece - well I think every fan would like one don't you think?
But as I've said - this is my opinion and for me they do need something to make me go WOW! as for the last 26 years I've just said 'that's good and that's very good' but most of the time I've just said 'that's okay or not that good'
So (for me) if it's not great then it's another wasted opportunity before they call it a day - and when that happens we will definitely not get a masterpiece will we
Scars probably still my favourite from the EP but have been finding myself going back to In A Life a lot. Resurrection Song has really grown on me too! Not too fussed about Easter Parade or Coexist - but not grumbling, really looking forward to the album based on the two EPs on the whole.
Just for the record, I am loving both EPs - U2 haven’t sounded so fresh and band-like in years. Not that all of their post 04 work is crap - on the contrary. I think NLOTH has many excellent songs. I am a fan of most of SOI. I still like some of the best SOE songs. But, I think, they had lost some of their sparkle in those two albums, especially SOE. Now the sparkle is back. And it really came, twice over, as a surprise. What a treat. Thank you U2!
Originally posted by juandicorrea:This next album will be great, they are aiming for excellence one last time. This EP proves they're on their way into that
Hum, hard to bet on that. These are probably the outtakes that in end the b-sides were always better than the final album(minus achtung baby). Think of Atomic Bomb were the result of removing all the good songs and leaving the terrible ones. Or NLOTH so bad it doesn't even have a b-side.