1. I was born in 99' so, of course I can't tell...

    What I can tell is that my father had ATYCLB CD in his car in 2000, and because of him playing it over and over was that I got into U2, I later learned that he was a fan (not hardcore like me hahah) that had gone to both ZooTV and Popmart

    Overall he was a big rock & roll fan that passed me his 80s rock love

  2. I think it's crazy that fans in general don't consider HTDAAB, it won Grammys, it's got 4/5 radio hits
  3. HTDAAB is not a bad album, it’s got quite a few good songs on it but I generally agree with Bono’s take on that album. I regard ATYCLB much higher and I actually think it was a much better album than a simple sum of its parts…

    "I think they're the best collection of songs we've put together, there's no weak songs on that album. But it still isn't as an album...the whole isn't greater than the sum of its parts and that fucking annoys me." - Bono on How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb in 2005
  4. Originally posted by Bonu:HTDAAB is not a bad album, it’s got quite a few good songs on it but I generally agree with Bono’s take on that album. I regard ATYCLB much higher and I actually think it was a much better album than a simple sum of its parts…

    "I think they're the best collection of songs we've put together, there's no weak songs on that album. But it still isn't as an album...the whole isn't greater than the sum of its parts and that fucking annoys me." - Bono on How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb in 2005
    I tend to disagree with Bono, the "side B" of ATYCLB is very unbalanced compared to "side A", HTDAAB is more cohesive, the "worst" songs aren't that far behind the hits, in ATYCLB the hits are too grandiose and the rest gets overshadowed, although I like New York and Grace for example
  5. Originally posted by juandicorrea:[..]
    War into Unforgettable Fire into Joshua Tree is an amazing and mind-blowing run and change in style/sonics if you think about it

    how did that felt in the fanbase back then?


    I became a fan in 1988-1989, so can’t tell from first hand, but I think all of those albums were kept within general rock idiom, so none of them alienated U2 fans and their number was only growing. Alienating some of the fans only happened when Achtung Baby came out. But I vaguely remember hearing big TJT hits on the radio in 1987-88 and some of the fans grumbling that U2 was getting similar to the likes of Bon Jovi or Def Leppard. I think it was more result of U2 becoming a really huge band, not the music itself. There apparently have been some hard core fans that were thinking that U2 was selling out at the time of TJT and R&H.

    I also remember that many local bands were created in many different parts of the world in late 80’s that were very much inspired by U2 music. In Poland there was a band called ZIYO, inspired by U2, whose singer looked like Bono and I remember they were generally regarded a Polish U2 at the time. Do you remember such bands in late 80’s in your countries as well?





    On the first song singer looks like late 80’s Bono, on the second he sounds like Bono 🙂
  6. I think the singles actually sum up why ATYCLB is better, at least imo. If you compare song for song HTDAAB just falls short of the quality of its predecessor. The first 5 songs on ATYCLB is there strongest opening to an album behind AB and JT. Yes the 2nd half of ATYCLB starts to have more of a mixed quality about it but I’d still have tracks 6-12 on ATYCLB over the equivalent on HTDAAB.
  7. Originally posted by Bonu:HTDAAB is not a bad album, it’s got quite a few good songs on it but I generally agree with Bono’s take on that album. I regard ATYCLB much higher and I actually think it was a much better album than a simple sum of its parts…

    "I think they're the best collection of songs we've put together, there's no weak songs on that album. But it still isn't as an album...the whole isn't greater than the sum of its parts and that fucking annoys me." - Bono on How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb in 2005
    I've seen this quote alot, but always wondered what interview it came from. Google vaguely mentions Rolling Stone but no proof of that is found
  8. Originally posted by marik:[..]
    I've seen this quote alot, but always wondered what interview it came from. Google vaguely mentions Rolling Stone but no proof of that is found
    It might be from the Vertigo tour programme. I'll have to dig mine out.
  9. Originally posted by juandicorrea:I was born in 99' so, of course I can't tell...

    What I can tell is that my father had ATYCLB CD in his car in 2000, and because of him playing it over and over was that I got into U2, I later learned that he was a fan (not hardcore like me hahah) that had gone to both ZooTV and Popmart

    Overall he was a big rock & roll fan that passed me his 80s rock love
    If a person was a 'hard core' fan back in the 80's they would be looked up upon with much more suspicion by the general public back then than in 2026. JMHO.
  10. RIP Moya Brennan ( Clannad ) whose death was announced today