1. Is this recency bias?
  2. By extension of the song being less than a month old then it is recency bias by default for sure.

    My feelings are my feelings however, and this song makes me feel something. I am not hitting it on repeat either like I would with a new and catchy song (not that there have been many of those in recent times) but this song has gone deeper than skin deep and that has not happened often over the last decade.

    Time will tell. I will say though, if this is the level of song that gets bumped to an EP rather than being retained for the full album then I take this to be a hopeful sign.
  3. Originally posted by miryclay:Think about it:
    We, when we are newborn babies, we first get into melodies and music before we can even learn words and learn to talk.


    It also reminds me of this part of From the Sky Down.

    [image]


    I was talking with a colleague last night about that idea, that music and melodies are of the first things we get into

    I have not seen From The Sky Down so I'll have to now 🙂 Thanks!
  4. Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
    By extension of the song being less than a month old then it is recency bias by default for sure.

    My feelings are my feelings however, and this song makes me feel something. I am not hitting it on repeat either like I would with a new and catchy song (not that there have been many of those in recent times) but this song has gone deeper than skin deep and that has not happened often over the last decade.

    Time will tell. I will say though, if this is the level of song that gets bumped to an EP rather than being retained for the full album then I take this to be a hopeful sign.
    That's a great point -- the fact that it's on an EP rather than being kept for the album is a really good sign for what the quality of the album must be like. It's hard to imagine the album having songs that are better than Tears of Things. If it does, it's possible it could be a top 5 U2 album.
  5. Originally posted by BloodyValentine:[..]
    That's a great point -- the fact that it's on an EP rather than being kept for the album is a really good sign for what the quality of the album must be like. It's hard to imagine the album having songs that are better than Tears of Things. If it does, it's possible it could be a top 5 U2 album.
    Definitely!
  6. Just when you think their creative oasis has been swallowed by the desert, they woke up this absolute gem out of the finest marble.

    The constant shouting about America through songs like American Soul, American Orbituary and The Blackout gave me the cringiest feeling that they were becoming the Big Orange Monster in order to defeat it...
    Something Bono always dispised.

    Shouting goes away, it's only temporary.
    But silent songs like these contain ideas that evolve from a tiny little river into a widespread ocean thanks to the flood of a powerful message: we humans only have a short amount of time on earth - the things we create usually surpass us.
    Why does almost every generation relapse into the same habits of violence, grief and suffering? When do we learn?
    "There's no start to this story, and I can see no end"

    The pace and slow buildup with subtle changes per new layer make this an intricate and actually rather complex masterpiece, that's at first disguised as a simple and soft song on acoustic guitar and almost whispered lines.
    Telling what Michelangelo's David might have already seen through the ages, combined with the band's anchorpoints in life (faith, music, love and friendship) make it both personal and generic at the same time - what a clever way of storystelling.

    As soon as Mussolini came to see him (absolute class of calling the other one the shadow and not by his name!) it really lifts off: "Before the roar, before the blast..." is sung with such a melancholic rage within every single syllable that it hits me harder than a 1000 star-spangled megaphones ever could.

    And then there's the roaring solo from our alchemist - simple yet all-encompassing as ever. It's like it's pulling you through all of mankind's history within this casade of notes. Plottwist: it's not something to be proud of...
    When we start to act like God and talk instead of listen, it all just ends in tears.

    This song could in fact very well become a timeless classic.
    However, the tragedy to me is that it's not because of it's genius - which it is - but because our children and grandchildren will probably live through similar experiences... David would cry if he could, over and over again.

    Hopefully U2 still has a wide enough platform in order to make this naked song reach out to enough people that are actually prepared to listen - maybe even people in charge.
    It has touched me more than all news-bulletins of the last years combined, which I didn't think would ever happen again.

    Thank you Adam, Dave, Larry and Paul.
  7. Lovely words. I mirror your thoughts entirely. A stunner of a song.
  8. Originally posted by BelgianBono:Just when you think their creative oasis has been swallowed by the desert, they woke up this absolute gem out of the finest marble.

    The constant shouting about America through songs like American Soul, American Orbituary and The Blackout gave me the cringiest feeling that they were becoming the Big Orange Monster in order to defeat it...
    Something Bono always dispised.

    Shouting goes away, it's only temporary.
    But silent songs like these contain ideas that evolve from a tiny little river into a widespread ocean thanks to the flood of a powerful message: we humans only have a short amount of time on earth - the things we create usually surpass us.
    Why does almost every generation relapse into the same habits of violence, grief and suffering? When do we learn?
    "There's no start to this story, and I can see no end"

    The pace and slow buildup with subtle changes per new layer make this an intricate and actually rather complex masterpiece, that's at first disguised as a simple and soft song on acoustic guitar and almost whispered lines.
    Telling what Michelangelo's David might have already seen through the ages, combined with the band's anchorpoints in life (faith, music, love and friendship) make it both personal and generic at the same time - what a clever way of storystelling.

    As soon as Mussolini came to see him (absolute class of calling the other one the shadow and not by his name!) it really lifts off: "Before the roar, before the blast..." is sung with such a melancholic rage within every single syllable that it hits me harder than a 1000 star-spangled megaphones ever could.

    And then there's the roaring solo from our alchemist - simple yet all-encompassing as ever. It's like it's pulling you through all of mankind's history within this casade of notes. Plottwist: it's not something to be proud of...
    When we start to act like God and talk instead of listen, it all just ends in tears.

    This song could in fact very well become a timeless classic.
    However, the tragedy to me is that it's not because of it's genius - which it is - but because our children and grandchildren will probably live through similar experiences... David would cry if he could, over and over again.

    Hopefully U2 still has a wide enough platform in order to make this naked song reach out to enough people that are actually prepared to listen - maybe even people in charge.
    It has touched me more than all news-bulletins of the last years combined, which I didn't think would ever happen again.

    Thank you Adam, Dave, Larry and Paul.
    Your depth, humanistic view and detailed understanding on the craft and subject matter of this song is admirable and commendable.

    Thank you for sharing your writings and contributing to the discussion of this masterpiece. As some have said, this is a piece of art in the form of music which we could certainly dedicate a full University Semester curriculum to its in-depth discussion.

    Me, and I am sure our fellow U2 brothers and sisters here, agree with your analysis. Thank you very much, and let's keep the conversation and our love and appreciation for true art, always ongoing!
  9. Originally posted by BelgianBono:Just when you think their creative oasis has been swallowed by the desert, they woke up this absolute gem out of the finest marble.

    The constant shouting about America through songs like American Soul, American Orbituary and The Blackout gave me the cringiest feeling that they were becoming the Big Orange Monster in order to defeat it...
    Something Bono always dispised.

    Shouting goes away, it's only temporary.
    But silent songs like these contain ideas that evolve from a tiny little river into a widespread ocean thanks to the flood of a powerful message: we humans only have a short amount of time on earth - the things we create usually surpass us.
    Why does almost every generation relapse into the same habits of violence, grief and suffering? When do we learn?
    "There's no start to this story, and I can see no end"

    The pace and slow buildup with subtle changes per new layer make this an intricate and actually rather complex masterpiece, that's at first disguised as a simple and soft song on acoustic guitar and almost whispered lines.
    Telling what Michelangelo's David might have already seen through the ages, combined with the band's anchorpoints in life (faith, music, love and friendship) make it both personal and generic at the same time - what a clever way of storystelling.

    As soon as Mussolini came to see him (absolute class of calling the other one the shadow and not by his name!) it really lifts off: "Before the roar, before the blast..." is sung with such a melancholic rage within every single syllable that it hits me harder than a 1000 star-spangled megaphones ever could.

    And then there's the roaring solo from our alchemist - simple yet all-encompassing as ever. It's like it's pulling you through all of mankind's history within this casade of notes. Plottwist: it's not something to be proud of...
    When we start to act like God and talk instead of listen, it all just ends in tears.

    This song could in fact very well become a timeless classic.
    However, the tragedy to me is that it's not because of it's genius - which it is - but because our children and grandchildren will probably live through similar experiences... David would cry if he could, over and over again.

    Hopefully U2 still has a wide enough platform in order to make this naked song reach out to enough people that are actually prepared to listen - maybe even people in charge.
    It has touched me more than all news-bulletins of the last years combined, which I didn't think would ever happen again.

    Thank you Adam, Dave, Larry and Paul.
    The only good America song U2 did was Bullet The Blue Sky and all it says is "outside is America". And the California and NY songs were dead terrible.
  10. Originally posted by tchezao:[..]
    The only good America song U2 did was Bullet The Blue Sky and all it says is "outside is America". And the California and NY songs were dead terrible.
    It’s a controversial statement. What about Heartland or In God’s Country? New York and California aren’t bad either…
  11. Originally posted by BelgianBono:Just when you think their creative oasis has been swallowed by the desert, they woke up this absolute gem out of the finest marble.

    The constant shouting about America through songs like American Soul, American Orbituary and The Blackout gave me the cringiest feeling that they were becoming the Big Orange Monster in order to defeat it...
    Something Bono always dispised.

    Shouting goes away, it's only temporary.
    But silent songs like these contain ideas that evolve from a tiny little river into a widespread ocean thanks to the flood of a powerful message: we humans only have a short amount of time on earth - the things we create usually surpass us.
    Why does almost every generation relapse into the same habits of violence, grief and suffering? When do we learn?
    "There's no start to this story, and I can see no end"

    The pace and slow buildup with subtle changes per new layer make this an intricate and actually rather complex masterpiece, that's at first disguised as a simple and soft song on acoustic guitar and almost whispered lines.
    Telling what Michelangelo's David might have already seen through the ages, combined with the band's anchorpoints in life (faith, music, love and friendship) make it both personal and generic at the same time - what a clever way of storystelling.

    As soon as Mussolini came to see him (absolute class of calling the other one the shadow and not by his name!) it really lifts off: "Before the roar, before the blast..." is sung with such a melancholic rage within every single syllable that it hits me harder than a 1000 star-spangled megaphones ever could.

    And then there's the roaring solo from our alchemist - simple yet all-encompassing as ever. It's like it's pulling you through all of mankind's history within this casade of notes. Plottwist: it's not something to be proud of...
    When we start to act like God and talk instead of listen, it all just ends in tears.

    This song could in fact very well become a timeless classic.
    However, the tragedy to me is that it's not because of it's genius - which it is - but because our children and grandchildren will probably live through similar experiences... David would cry if he could, over and over again.

    Hopefully U2 still has a wide enough platform in order to make this naked song reach out to enough people that are actually prepared to listen - maybe even people in charge.
    It has touched me more than all news-bulletins of the last years combined, which I didn't think would ever happen again.

    Thank you Adam, Dave, Larry and Paul.
    Wonderfully put. Thank you for sharing!
  12. Originally posted by Bonu:[..]
    It’s a controversial statement. What about Heartland or In God’s Country? New York and California aren’t bad either…
    New York is one of the songs I go back to you from ATYCLB. Especially the Farmclub & Irving Plaza shows. Edge's solo is fantastic. I don't see the appeal of California especially the studio version.