1. Originally posted by tchezao:Song for Hal (whoever Hal is), is one of the best things I've ever heard in 20 years. This song brings me a mix of emotions like, a world without U2 or the last things we hold on in this life - your beloved ones, our Youth, and the things we grew up with.

    I don't know why U2 released such a great album, I mean, we all know U2 DON'T release what we actually want to hear.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hal_Willner
  2. Originally posted by richie:u2wanderer1 - have you heard any news from the U2 camp or Universal about a physical version of the Propaganda magazine and / or a CD version of Easter Lily? I'd find it strange if the fan club gift isn't now enhanced to include these to sit side-by-side with the Days of Ash CD and Propaganda?


    There's no plans made yet from what I understand. They went from work on putting the Easter Lily digital package and Propaganda together, straight into finishing off the album and getting it to the label so it was ready to go for later this year. I suspect they'll make some decisions on the rest soon. (I do not expect Universal will do another issue of Propaganda, and that if anything was done on that front it would be entirely through the fan club.) It was about a month after "Days of Ash" that they made a number of decisions about that release, so if they do the same, it'll be early May before we hear much.


  3. Oh wow, so they actually finished the album it sounds like. Cool.
  4. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]


    There's no plans made yet from what I understand. They went from work on putting the Easter Lily digital package and Propaganda together, straight into finishing off the album and getting it to the label so it was ready to go for later this year. I suspect they'll make some decisions on the rest soon. (I do not expect Universal will do another issue of Propaganda, and that if anything was done on that front it would be entirely through the fan club.) It was about a month after "Days of Ash" that they made a number of decisions about that release, so if they do the same, it'll be early May before we hear much.
    Excellent - thanks for the update as always Aaron.
  5. I think with Easter lily they’ve given us something special. I want to say masterpiece, that’s what I’m thinking anyway but probably far too early to make claims like that. I really enjoy Days of Ash, I was relieved the band still had that sort of quality in them. However, Easter Lily is on another level. I feel like I’m going to be coming back to this one for many years to come.
  6. This little EP deserves the Grammys and every other Prize!
    U2 gave us real Music, something other artists couldn't give us in the last two years at least!
  7. hope there is another EP and a little experimental this time, world gotta now how great they are
  8. May 14, 2026 aka Ascension Day would not be a bad date for another EP with songs of ascent :-)
  9. EP titled Ascension would be amazing!
  10. Originally posted by tuf392664:I think with Easter lily they’ve given us something special. I want to say masterpiece, that’s what I’m thinking anyway but probably far too early to make claims like that. I really enjoy Days of Ash, I was relieved the band still had that sort of quality in them. However, Easter Lily is on another level. I feel like I’m going to be coming back to this one for many years to come.
    This
  11. Originally posted by tuf392664:I think with Easter lily they’ve given us something special. I want to say masterpiece, that’s what I’m thinking anyway but probably far too early to make claims like that. I really enjoy Days of Ash, I was relieved the band still had that sort of quality in them. However, Easter Lily is on another level. I feel like I’m going to be coming back to this one for many years to come.
    Firstly, I totally respect your opinion and all taste is subjective

    To me personally, AB and TJT (and you could possibly throw Z and P in there too as I've already said quite a lot 😉 ) can be deemed 'masterpieces'

    For these 2 EPs to be considered masterpieces then you'd also have to rate ATYCLB and HTDAAB as masterpieces - I don't but you might

    But those albums are my personal yardstick
  12. Originally posted by RedSky:[..]
    Firstly, I totally respect your opinion and all taste is subjective

    To me personally, AB and TJT (and you could possibly throw Z and P in there too as I've already said quite a lot 😉 ) can be deemed 'masterpieces'

    For these 2 EPs to be considered masterpieces then you'd also have to rate ATYCLB and HTDAAB as masterpieces - I don't but you might

    But those albums are my personal yardstick
    I completely respect your opinion too and it’s an interesting discussion about what makes a masterpiece and what albums can be considered as such.

    I’m in agreement about Achtung Baby and Joshua Tree being the yardstick as you call it. I do think albums that aren’t quite as good as those can be masterpieces but they do have to be very strong.

    Days of Ash I don’t think meets the standard despite being very good. HTDAAB and Pop I would say are the same.

    Zooropa, ATYCLB and Easter Lily are closer to the standard I think. Easter Lily has to its advantage that it’s shorter, something I’ve always been in favour of rather than being determined to stick 10-12 songs on an album when the overall quality drops as a result. Zooropa doesn’t suffer as much as ATYCLB for being longer. Having said all that I’d still like to put all 3 in the masterpiece category but accept it’s open to debate.