1. Bono said he loves the energy of vertigo and elevation. It was a big surprise when Jt17 started and vertigo was absent.

    I am curious if any SOI/E singles will continue to be played
  2. Why is it that people think U2 is all about uplifting anthems?

    Their music of the 80s lacked anything that could be called an uplifting anthem until Pride, which was itself more a song of painful longing than purely positive. And nothing else on that album qualifies. Streets & ISHFWILF are both songs of deep spiritual longing, not triumph or cheery optimism. With or Without You is pure anguish. Desire, All I Want is You, Angel of Harlem? Nope. Not a single uplifting anthem in the bunch.

    As I hear it, there isn't a single uplifting anthem in all of their 90s output.

    I contend that Beautiful Day marks the beginning of the "uplifting anthem" era.

    So is this misunderstanding/stereotype built on ATYCLB and the lesser songs of these last two decades?
  3. BD per Bono is about a person losing everything while never been happier. *shrug*

    Compared to rest of 90s I think MW or EBTTRT arent uplifting?
  4. The U2 anthem era really started with Pride, and it became established with JT. ATYCLB and onward brought the "uplifting" side

    Edit... In hindsight, I think their iconic "anthemic" sound really began with SBS on UABRS.
  5. Originally posted by dstankie:Why is it that people think U2 is all about uplifting anthems?

    Their music of the 80s lacked anything that could be called an uplifting anthem until Pride, which was itself more a song of painful longing than purely positive. And nothing else on that album qualifies. Streets & ISHFWILF are both songs of deep spiritual longing, not triumph or cheery optimism. With or Without You is pure anguish. Desire, All I Want is You, Angel of Harlem? Nope. Not a single uplifting anthem in the bunch.

    As I hear it, there isn't a single uplifting anthem in all of their 90s output.

    I contend that Beautiful Day marks the beginning of the "uplifting anthem" era.

    So is this misunderstanding/stereotype built on ATYCLB and the lesser songs of these last two decades?
    I think fans/people can often wrongly translate an 'uplifting' sound to mean one of an uplifting composition - hence that cliché

    U2 are definitely anthemic - an artist can be anthemic both with an uplifting or dark 'message' within the lyrics so that's understandable

    I think the church - although I am without faith - has many an uplifting hymn with a (what we would judge) righteous moralistic message so with that ISHFWILF would qualify as uplifting in my opinion
  6. Those are all good points. Still, it seems to me that the true "anthems" are few and far between in those first two decades. And that none of them are glibly "uplifting."

    I guess "anthemic" has come to mean simply a big, energized sound with lots of feeling behind it. In that sense, most of U2 (and lots of other rock music) is "anthemic". But then, doesn't the word become kind of meaningless?

    I don't even know why this is on my mind...

    I think that, on the one hand it's because I feel like the band's music has been unfairly pigeonholed and criticized.

    And, I hate to admit, because a decent amount of latter-day U2 seems a bit too much like a caricature of golden-age U2 (including, please don't hate me, Street of Dreams). Which maybe means that I worry that the cliche take on U2's music has become at least a decent bit accurate.

    Ugh, I just realized I can't handled it when U2 sounds like they've been inspired by Coldplay (instead of the other way around)...
  7. There is definitely a bit of self-parody within the band - whether they realise it or not

    And we have to remember that any word or term describing the band or their music is assigned to them by the 'viewer' and not directly assigned by the band themselves

    In a way, U2 are what we or the media makes them out to be/tells them what they are - which is a bit unfair on the band because they will unfortunately become pigeonholed, as you say, but frustratingly without having a say in that process

    And I know what you mean about the Coldplay similarities BUT Coldplay did say that they were influenced by U2 so if U2 get inspiration from Coldplay then aren't U2, in a round-about way, being influenced by themselves
  8. watched HMTMKMKM again and wow, just think about how badass they were at the time probably
  9. They were that badass at the time! For those of you who weren't alive then, it's really hard to convey how killer U2 was. They were immense in the late 80s with one vibe, and then COMPLETELY CHANGED that vibe and were just as immense in the 90s.

    That, in a nutshell, is why old curmudgeon's like me can be so hard on them in recent years. We remember what it was like at the heights.
  10. I think they were badass because they were SO BIG that they thought they could do anything

    Maybe they got too arrogant - but to me that was their best time

    Their arrogance turned into insecurity but their song-writing talent was still there and massive commercial success still followed

    Yes U2 were SO BIG in the 90s but the early 2000s with ATYCLB and then the awesome single Vertigo they did regain that crown and reached those heights again but since then it's been good but not great

    As much as the 90s were my favourite period you have to concede that that early 2000 resurgence was a turning point for the band when they had lost a bit of confidence

    As much as we don't like to think about it - millionaire musicians still need the reassurance of fame and they need (like a drug) to be liked (sadly)
  11. I just watched the music video for All I Want Is You for the first time. Can someone explain the ending. Who died? The girl he liked and her boyfriend?