Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
Isn’t pop radio mode exactly what a lead single should be? There is a tour to sell and they’ll need/want the airplay. The EP’s gave us flavours of what direction they can (and maybe want) to go in but they are still clearly still hamstrung by labels or management who can still call seemingly calm the shots and steer the band they way they want them to go. Baffling stuff.
But the entire body of work might offer a direction that is far removed from whatever the lead single turns out to be. I just home for a cohesive album with themes that run through it.
Not sure where you get they are "clearly still hamstrung by labels or management" - from what I see of the band they are clearly in the drivers seat at this point in their career and steering this bus down the road, maybe more so than ever before.
Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
Not sure where you get they are "clearly still hamstrung by labels or management" - from what I see of the band they are clearly in the drivers seat at this point in their career and steering this bus down the road, maybe more so than ever before.
I mean in the senses of not getting out of the Sphere shows until Larry was ready, the legacy tours of JT and seemingly now parking the direction of the recent EP’s to put out what might well be slightly more watered down music in the hope of chasing streams and radio to make sure a big tour sells. I could throw the recycled Covid project of Songs of Surrender in there too.
The EP stuff confuses me. Very interesting stuff amongst them, almost a passion project and a direction that I would love to have seen them follow through with a small theatre style tour perhaps but will it have sold? I can’t judge what I haven’t heard yet but I would be sorely disappointed if this upcoming album turns out to be more half baked happy meal songs.
I live in hope and I am happy to be patient. I just don’t in my heart of hearts think the band should be chasing radio and stadiums at this point in their career. They either want it or this is the direction they have been sold. If this is what they want in their mid sixties then I hope it works for them.
Originally posted by germcevoy:[..]
I mean in the senses of not getting out of the Sphere shows until Larry was ready, the legacy tours of JT and seemingly now parking the direction of the recent EP’s to put out what might well be slightly more watered down music in the hope of chasing streams and radio to make sure a big tour sells. I could throw the recycled Covid project of Songs of Surrender in there too.
The EP stuff confuses me. Very interesting stuff amongst them, almost a passion project and a direction that I would love to have seen them follow through with a small theatre style tour perhaps but will it have sold? I can’t judge what I haven’t heard yet but I would be sorely disappointed if this upcoming album turns out to be more half baked happy meal songs.
I live in hope and I am happy to be patient. I just don’t in my heart of hearts think the band should be chasing radio and stadiums at this point in their career. They either want it or this is the direction they have been sold. If this is what they want in their mid sixties then I hope it works for them.
Sphere shows:
Band signed contract before they knew Larry was out, Larry had the opportunity to have surgery and told the band to go ahead and play. The whole launch of the venue was built around U2. Pulling out would have been messy, and we saw the Sphere didn't have another act lined up for a while. Yeah this one was likely contract driven. But I do think had Larry said no to them performing they would have pulled out.
Joshua Tree Tour 2017:
The initial plan came from the need to complete a contract for Live Nation, which was done and is now behind them. That touring contract came to completion in 2020. The band were under no obligation to do the last two legs of the 2017 tour, nor was there an obligation to do the 2019 tour. Yes the Joshua Tree 2017 tour was to appease the folks at Live Nation. But the band had just postponed the album by a year, and had asked for an already planned arena tour to be scuttled. They initially threw out the idea of doing just two shows as an appeasement because of that cancellation. Later it grew into two legs. The fact that it ended with five legs and a lengthy trek through Asia / Australia in 2019 wasn't at the demand of Live Nation. Those tend to be a losing money proposition. Probably would have preferred to see another leg in the US or Europe instead. The later addition of South America and then 2019 signals they are charting their own path. (Yes there is a new arrangement in place for touring, but I do believe it is less restrictive in what demands have to be met.)
Songs of Surrender
* These projects are notorious bad sellers and no one at the label really wanted it. They were pushing for a collection of hits, the original hits. But they threw their weight behind it and promoted it anyway as it was what U2 wanted to put out. This is one that also signals to me that U2's making their own choices right now...Both Bono and the Edge made comments around that album suggesting they were free to do what they want when they wanted as well.
The album this fall has always been the goal. The EPs were thrown together more recently as they knew the songs would sit for years if they waited for another album and then a two year tour. They wanted to get that material out. And it's more a 'bonus' to what they've been working on for these last few years. The album they are putting together has always been the primary plan that they have been working towards. Timing wise a small tour would have been nice, but it would have almost certainly delayed the album further...and it's part of a bigger release strategy that is going to hit us this fall...there's a lot of moving pieces on this one.
Originally posted by germcevoy:Your closeness to the situation and wider analysis always add a lot of additional context. Lots to mull as always. Thank you.
I really see a band that is charting their own course right now, for good or bad. And I think it's going to lead to some exciting times ahead...like these EPs, and a couple of other projects coming up. I don't think they are as restricted as they have been in the past.
That is the impression I get too. Especially driven by the EP’s. I had hoped the Bono book tour might have seen an appeal in some smaller venue stuff but perhaps in future.
If the band are in control of what they have set out then I shall just roll with it and see how the plotted course plays out.
Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
Yeah, I don’t understand that sentiment either, didn’t he experience tour have upwards of eight songs a night from the new record?
Towards the end of the tour, when it hit Europe, it really shifted more towards an "Achtung Baby" vibe during parts of the show. But the band also continued to add songs from the new album on that leg, with "Summer of Love" first appearing on the second leg, and "Landlady" coming in towards the end. But they also worked in that "Dirty Day" / "Zoo Station" / "Fly" / "Stay" / "Wild Horses" section to replace some of the tracks from SOI.
I'm torn between also loving the idea of a smaller venue tour featuring more of the EPs material...but also always preferring U2 in stadiums when I've seen them live.
Regarding Street of Dreams - is this a show opener? Play a few songs in? Excited to hear it live in a big setting regardless.
I'm torn between also loving the idea of a smaller venue tour featuring more of the EPs material...but also always preferring U2 in stadiums when I've seen them live.
Regarding Street of Dreams - is this a show opener? Play a few songs in? Excited to hear it live in a big setting regardless.
It was mentioned that the band will start the tour in Latin America, so I think it’ll have to be in stadiums. About them playing big hits when they do stadium shows, on the Vertigo Tour most of the setlist was songs from HTDAAB, and on 360º NLOTH was the second most played album, even after the band dropped 3 or 4 songs for the new leg of the tour.
Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
Not sure where you get they are "clearly still hamstrung by labels or management" - from what I see of the band they are clearly in the drivers seat at this point in their career and steering this bus down the road, maybe more so than ever before.
Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]
I really see a band that is charting their own course right now, for good or bad. And I think it's going to lead to some exciting times ahead...like these EPs, and a couple of other projects coming up. I don't think they are as restricted as they have been in the past.
Thanks U2 Wanderer
Could you give a little more info on the “other projects coming up” teaser? Should we be thinking more music beyond the album (maybe the Eno sci-fi project? More EPs? Or maybe documentaries, etc? Seems like there is plenty of music to draw from and they aren’t getting younger so in my mind I feel like we could see a few U2 projects over the next year but I don’t want to get my hopes up
One idea I had was maybe the album this fall has that carnival, joyous vibe with a latino bent to propel the South American tour, and then a more sober album or EP comes out prior to the European/US leg of the tour. Again going back to the multiple projects comment