1. Just asking myself these questions

    Are U2 still relevant? As a big fan I have to say no - but they still generate interest like the Stones and Springsteen because of their legacy. We have to remember that the next generation don't really care and just see anyone above the age of 30 as old and dull (not to generalise but you get my point)

    Did U2 change the world? No - they were a sticking plaster on a gushing vein but that is not their fault as rock'n'roll can change the world but only briefly before the world turns once again. Fans should NEVER put their idols on a pedestal - especially those fans with a faith as nothing should be bigger than your faith. Me? I am without faith so this doesn't concern me. The rise of 'influencers' is another 'faith' that lost people will adhere to because of their innate proclivity to follow

    Will U2 write another masterpiece? It is most probably within them but because of their self-imposed insecurities it means that the risk and the daring of a wild animal that is needed to write a masterpiece will be tamed and compliant

    Does it bother me as a fan to see my favourite group release some dodgy pop-oriented music? Yes it bloody does! I see it as dad-dancing and a bit embarrassing tbh I want a grandad that is cool and doesn't give a shit not one who listens to all the latest 'kids' music

    Did U2 change my life? Damn straight they did! Not through their faith or their charitable actions though, but through the people I've met and the places I've been to following the band. Travel and meeting people does broaden the mind and I have made many friends and seen many places that I wouldn't have. And me and my partner holding each other as we simply sway and sing along to our favourite band singing our favourite songs under a blood red sky - magic
  2. Originally posted by RedSky:Just asking myself these questions

    Are U2 still relevant? As a big fan I have to say no - but they still generate interest like the Stones and Springsteen because of their legacy. We have to remember that the next generation don't really care and just see anyone above the age of 30 as old and dull (not to generalise but you get my point)

    Did U2 change the world? No - they were a sticking plaster on a gushing vein but that is not their fault as rock'n'roll can change the world but only briefly before the world turns once again. Fans should NEVER put their idols on a pedestal - especially those fans with a faith as nothing should be bigger than your faith. Me? I am without faith so this doesn't concern me. The rise of 'influencers' is another 'faith' that lost people will adhere to because of their innate proclivity to follow

    Will U2 write another masterpiece? It is most probably within them but because of their self-imposed insecurities it means that the risk and the daring of a wild animal that is needed to write a masterpiece will be tamed and compliant

    Does it bother me as a fan to see my favourite group release some dodgy pop-oriented music? Yes it bloody does! I see it as dad-dancing and a bit embarrassing tbh I want a grandad that is cool and doesn't give a shit not one who listens to all the latest 'kids' music

    Did U2 change my life? Damn straight they did! Not through their faith or their charitable actions though, but through the people I've met and the places I've been to following the band. Travel and meeting people does broaden the mind and I have made many friends and seen many places that I wouldn't have. And me and my partner holding each other as we simply sway and sing along to our favourite band singing our favourite songs under a blood red sky - magic
    So Sweetest Thing bothered you? That’s the most poppy song they’ve ever released. Lemon.. is a pop song, a weird one, but it’s a pop song. U2 have always made pop songs, but you really mean to say is you don’t like it when they make pop songs that sound like the era that they’re made. I think people mistake them making pop songs as an attempt to seem relevant, when in actuality maybe they just really like writing pop melodies.
  3. Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
    So Sweetest Thing bothered you? That’s the most poppy song they’ve ever released. Lemon.. is a pop song, a weird one, but it’s a pop song. U2 have always made pop songs, but you really mean to say is you don’t like it when they make pop songs that sound like the era that they’re made. I think people mistake them making pop songs as an attempt to seem relevant, when in actuality maybe they just really like writing pop melodies.


    I say 'pop-oriented' with 'pop' being in its original context of 'popular music' ergo what is deemed the most popular music of the time

    Sweetest Thing, though melodic, I wouldn't say it is 'pop' in that context. And on a personal level - I find it overly saccharine

    Lemon I would argue again is not pop - if we tried to categorise it then maybe one of the more left-field dance genres would suit

    But you hit on a valid point in that yes I do not want the band to sound like the 'popular' artists of the day especially when those artists are vapid and transient

    Writing a melody is a totally different thing - a melody can be in any musical genre not necessarily confined to pop

    I think we all know when something sounds cheesy and awful to when something sounds amazing - melodious or not

    Regarding you thinking the band 'just like writing pop melodies' then that is just your personal conclusion - it is not based in fact though some evidence of popular music is apparent in their work

    But if we look at all their work you can safely say the majority is not 'pop' in its original meaning

    I write songs and I love it when I construct a hook or a melody that people can enjoy - but, though melodic, it is definitely not pop

    But we could argue all day to what is and isn't 'pop' - my argument's foundation is built upon my opinion of what pop is
  4. Personally, I'm convinced it will be released at the end of September or beginning of October, with an album release in November.
  5. Me too
  6. I think so too, but then why the image appeared?
  7. They input the song into ASCAP already - which they would not do unless it was going to be released soon. And add that in with the filming for the song and rumors from trusted sources to it being released soon - it should definitely be out way before September.

    Most likely just a little bit of a delay to finalize something that is taking a bit longer than expected to finish - album details, media appearances, etc.
  8. I honestly wouldn't rule U2 out with the younger crowd, because I keep seeing videos on YouTube and Instagram where Gen Z have discovered them for the first time, and think they're amazing.

    Tons of Gen Z go to see artists who precede U2, such as Paul McCartney, Elton John, Queen, and Billy Joel.

    It wouldn't surprise me in the slightest if U2 win them over on their return, and I have a feeling every generation is going to 'give them their flowers' this time around.

    It's not something I personally need or want as a fan, and I actually find it quite ironic when it happens, but it always seems to happen eventually with artists who stick around long enough!

    Back to Street of Dreams - maybe that image we saw was just a placeholder and we weren't supposed to see it?

    I loved the vibe of the photo, but surely they take tons of photos at once, and that wasn't exactly the most flattering shot of each of their faces, so I'd be surprised if that was chosen for a release!

    I'm just so keen to see all four of them together on stage again, even for one song, because it feels like an absolute lifetime!
  9. They could push a lot of new things on TikTok or something to try and go viral.

    That's what the singles charts contains now.
  10. A selfish part of me doesn't want a bunch of casuals who discovered them on TikTok at the next tour but that's only because I desperately want to see them again, and don't want to miss out!
  11. I don't think there's any danger of missing out.
  12. I think U2 is still very capable of producing a big hit across a wide range of age demographics.

    The music sells itself. A hit song is a hit song…

    Doesn’t matter who the band or artist is or how old they are. If the song is “hit” worthy it will be a hit.

    And you can do all the promotion / pushing of a song or album you want, but if the quality is not there it does not matter, it won’t gain traction. And vice versa - you don’t have to do much promotion for hit songs to get traction. The general public does it for you these days.