1. Are we saying September for the album then… 50 years and all?
  2. There are numerous differences between the Spotify streaming version and the video.
  3. It's fine to have critiques about the lead single, but I think seasoned fans don’t take it that seriously and just enjoy the moment. The last time I genuinely LOVED a lead single was "Vertigo". I liked the song and I don’t think it says anything about the rest of the album. Learn to enjoy the moment without the bitterness.
  4. Originally posted by hedyzera:It's fine to have critiques about the lead single, but I think seasoned fans don’t take it that seriously and just enjoy the moment. The last time I genuinely LOVED a lead single was "Vertigo". I liked the song and I don’t think it says anything about the rest of the album. Learn to enjoy the moment without the bitterness.
    Tone can really be lost or misunderstood on a forum. I don't think anybody is necessarily being truly bitter or angry - hopefully not, anyway! I've been re-reading Surrender, and I'm paraphrasing, but Bono says something along the lines of it being a lot to ask for people (fans/audience) to come along with you on your experiments. I don't think U2 would be offended by our opinions! We're all just saying what we think/feel, it's all good! There was another quote from Paul McGuiness (again, paraphrasing) basically saying that being a fan of a band is like following a sports team - you want them to do well. I would imagine we're all invested in U2 to some degree, so if somebody doesn't like the single, it's probably because they're disappointed, rather than just hating!
  5. Disappointed is a good word for it. This band mean a lot to me. I’ve been a fan for around 30 years. I want them to win. & with the 2 EPs especially EL I was excited for the album. But SOD is a real let down. I have been looking forward to hearing the full song before voicing my opinions but after hearing the snippets in the various teasers etc. over the past few weeks I’m asking myself what more is there. This song could be 10 seconds long because the hook is all there is to it. There is nothing else. You basically had the song in the teaser. There was nothing to wait for. As per U2 they don’t really do ‘bridges’ all that well & plonk something in the middle that sounds like it’s been grafted in from another song entirely & the solo if that what you call it is so meek & does absolutely nowhere. As I think a few others have notes the song really just goes nowhere. I haven’t bothered to work out the chords on guitar yet but at a guess it’s just a few chords all the way through. Dinamiclly it’s not particularly interesting either. Sting has a great line on this - he talks about wanting to be surprised musically & this just isn’t surprising. The video is fine and nice to see the and together but with the grainy finish it could be a video from any U2 album of the last 20+ years & they are still basically rehashing The Streets video concept. So in summary disappointing - I hope there is better on the rest of the LP be use this is ‘meh’


  6. A really good observation, will be interesting to see what happens during touring.
  7. One suggestion: Edge could have maybe used a different approach for the solo than the slide which is been done many times.
  8. As someone who survived open-heart surgery in May, and wasn't sure I'd be here for this, I'm thankful for U2's new music. Yes, there are elements from old songs, but they're used differently and blended with new elements to create something fresh.
  9. Originally posted by ndmaxfield:As someone who survived open-heart surgery in May, and wasn't sure I'd be here for this, I'm thankful for U2's new music. Yes, there are elements from old songs, but they're used differently and blended with new elements to create something fresh.
    Amen brother. Thanks for sharing your personal perspective. I am glad you are still with us!
  10. Originally posted by Reach1985:Disappointed is a good word for it. This band mean a lot to me. I’ve been a fan for around 30 years. I want them to win. & with the 2 EPs especially EL I was excited for the album. But SOD is a real let down. I have been looking forward to hearing the full song before voicing my opinions but after hearing the snippets in the various teasers etc. over the past few weeks I’m asking myself what more is there. This song could be 10 seconds long because the hook is all there is to it. There is nothing else. You basically had the song in the teaser. There was nothing to wait for. As per U2 they don’t really do ‘bridges’ all that well & plonk something in the middle that sounds like it’s been grafted in from another song entirely & the solo if that what you call it is so meek & does absolutely nowhere. As I think a few others have notes the song really just goes nowhere. I haven’t bothered to work out the chords on guitar yet but at a guess it’s just a few chords all the way through. Dinamiclly it’s not particularly interesting either. Sting has a great line on this - he talks about wanting to be surprised musically & this just isn’t surprising. The video is fine and nice to see the and together but with the grainy finish it could be a video from any U2 album of the last 20+ years & they are still basically rehashing The Streets video concept. So in summary disappointing - I hope there is better on the rest of the LP be use this is ‘meh’
    I think the album overall will be good and if people don’t like the single that doesn’t mean the whole album will be bad. The goal of a single is to create more of an audience not just cater to the fans. All my friends who are into music in general love it. I think that’s a good thing!