1. Originally posted by Shimitz:As of the moment, I feel like SoD is one of their finest.
    Love the cadence of the verses. The production is top notch imo! Love it!
    How can a chewgummi Black Eyed Peace Pop song be better than Velvet Dress, Mofo, Gone, Stay, Dirty Day, Book Of Your Heart, Mercy, Bad, So Sruel, Acrobat, Love Is Blindness, Love Is All We Have Left, Heartland, Trying To Throw....😮

    The track is just a silly song and their worst ever together with Stand Up Comedy....
  2. After a few more listens it is catchy and growing on me. However, I would suggest a restructure to the song. Have the melody of the verses like the intro melody before the chorus, not just shouty platitudes. A more lengthy solo before the bridge as the sudden change is slightly jarring.

    Anyway, the tune is here to stay. I've been listening to it along with the EPs and it's okay alongside them. It's a throwaway fun single, I'm still keen to hear the new album and of course see the band live again.
  3. The intro and outro are great and beautiful !!
    Chorus is alright and very catchy
    Bridge is terrible, terrible
    Verses are bad
    Solo is cool, but too safe.

    Overall:
    It’s fun, has very cool elements, but it’s not such a solid song.

    5.8/10

    It could be worse, like American Obituary, or American Soul, or Get On Your Boots.

    How can they do such great songs and such average songs at the same time? It’s beyond my understanding. But I’ll just enjoy they’re still around and giving us new songs 🙂

    I hear people saying « release Silencio » and I remember one person here said it sounds like Volcano. I hope that person is wrong, another Volcano would be sad.

    Still very excited about the album! Because the intro and outro are beautiful and differenr! But, really concerned on how they can do such amazing songs like Tears of Things, Resurrection Song and at the same time American Obituary.

    It’s the same as the absurdity of putting Little Things and Landlady in the same Album as American Soul, Get Out Of Your Own Way, and Best Thing About Me. (And then leaving Book of Your Heart and Ordinary Love out)
  4. Originally posted by Peterrrrr:[..]
    How can a chewgummi Black Eyed Peace Pop song be better than Velvet Dress, Mofo, Gone, Stay, Dirty Day, Book Of Your Heart, Mercy, Bad, So Sruel, Acrobat, Love Is Blindness, Love Is All We Have Left, Heartland, Trying To Throw....😮

    The track is just a silly song and their worst ever together with Stand Up Comedy....
    Stand Up Comedy is a good song eh!
    It’s more solid than this one
  5. I'm not sure about the SOD. Intro is OK, chorus is OK but it's asking for proper verses. Then it would be a nice pop-rock song.
    Maybe EPs were made for the fans and this one is for TikTok kids...
  6. Problem of Stand Up Comedy is silly lyrics. Problems of Street Of Dreams are numerous. Song’s saving grace is Adam’s bass line. It’s not one of the greatest he’s ever done but it’s good enough, sounds great placed high in the mix and has summer reggae vibes to it that I probably last heard from this band on the War album. That’s a positive and I’m now trying to be as positive as the song itself 🙂
  7. first words out of my mouth today? "La Calle". well done U2, you’ve done it again.
  8. A U2 lead single has (had?) two jobs: to get people's attention and to give a preview of their new project. Think With or Without You or The Fly. It goes without saying that it should also be a strong song.

    I think that Beautiful Day was the last lead single that actually accomplished these things. Vertigo was probably the last lead single that got people's attention and was a strong song, but it didn't really match the sound/feel of the rest of its album. Since then...

    Is this a strong song? Will it demand anyone's attention? If it's a preview of the album to come, how do you feel about that?
  9. Originally posted by justinpushplay:Oh grow up. If you wanna live in the past, then get the hell out of here and go listen to the unforgettable fire on repeat. No one’s taking anything away from you. And no one’s making you listen. You are more than welcome to pretend U2 doesn’t make new music if you want to. But stop pretending that casting dispersions and half cock opinions are the same thing as facts because they’re not. It’s not the band’s job to be what you want it to be when you want it to be.
    Ignoring the unnecessary incivility, I would argue that The Unforgettable Fire is a timeless work of art and if you want to "live in the past", listening to that album on repeat is as likely to keep you in the past as it is to put you in the future or the present. That album is simply outside of time. I have never heard another album like it even to this day and I doubt I ever will.

    Also it's understandable that this purposely repetitive song is disappointing to anyone over the age of 12. But then again U2 has never been good at singles, with a few exceptions.

    They're more of an album band.

    Hopefully the second single will be less irritating.
  10. We all know U2 have a pretty horrendous track record of picking lead singles. But every time they do this I just wonder - is their read of their own songs this bizarre? Are they surrounded by sycophants that are unwilling or afraid to tell them their choice is awful? It’s so strange to me.

    SOD is at very best an upbeat sounding filler track on any album they’ve ever made.
  11. Originally posted by ap5:Are they surrounded by sycophants that are unwilling or afraid to tell them their choice is awful?
    Yeah, can't believe Brian Eno approved this.

    Unless they just played him the spacey intro, hit stop, and were like "no need to hear the rest -- it's more of the same".
  12. Originally posted by BloodyValentine:[..]
    Yeah, can't believe Brian Eno approved this.

    Unless they just played him the spacey intro, hit stop, and were like "no need to hear the rest -- it's more of the same".
    Who said Brian Eno even heard this?