1. Originally posted by miryclay:[..]
    The music suggests the feeling. An abrupt riff would imply sudden changes. Whereas SOD is a wash, kinda how life happens.
    Maybe just the music with no lyrics at the intro and outro would be better. I don’t know, just really dislike the bits of the song as they are just now. Trying not to be a critic and a right downer but I would have enjoyed a shorter song without they bits.
  2. What bothers me the most about SOD is not any particular part of the song but the fact that it’s stitched together like a Frankenstein from all the different pieces that don’t suit each other and sound like taken from five different songs that they had been working on. It also unfolds too quickly and with no particular logic to it. Song starts with gentle gospel intro but before it starts to mean anything we already hear the guitar, drums and then bass kicking in without any real build up and then we hear the chorus without any logic to it. All of this takes 40 seconds. Too fast to mean anything real other than that they desperately wanted to have a hit.
  3. Originally posted by Bonu:What bothers me the most about SOD is not any particular part of the song but the fact that it’s stitched together like a Frankenstein from all the different pieces that don’t suit each other and sound like taken from five different songs that they had been working on.


    They have form with this. ‘Your the best thing’ has entered the chat.

    That song ( even though I love it ) was musically confusing as all hell. It was definitely three different songs stitched together.
  4. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:[..]


    They have form with this. ‘Your the best thing’ has entered the chat.

    That song ( even though I love it ) was musically confusing as all hell. It was definitely three different songs stitched together.
    So they bettered themselves cause now it’s at least five different songs: gospel intro/outro, instruments kicking in part, chorus, bridge and guitar solo. It’s like a checklist of a song.
  5. I like it. Nice intro and chorus, okish verse. I like Jacknife Lee production.
  6. Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
    The knives are out from the usual suspects 👀,
    Weirdly it's a better single than Boots, Miracle of Joey Ramone You're the best thing, Staring at the sun, Walk on, Numb.

    Eh?
  7. I’m not a musicologist (perhaps someone with a little more knowledge than I can put me right) but on the guitar (from the chords someone has posted on Ultimate Guitar) it looks like it’s in the key of E (capo 2nd fret) though Edge isn’t playing it this way. The intro/outro and the main body of the song are in this key, but the end of the bridge goes outside the key (and then back in) and sounds very Beatles like to my ear (there’s a 7th chord in there which Edge doesn’t tend to play). To me it doesn’t sound quite as Frankinsong as Best Thing did which has a really clunky bit in after the chorus when it goes back to the verse.
  8. Originally posted by Bonu:What bothers me the most about SOD is not any particular part of the song but the fact that it’s stitched together like a Frankenstein from all the different pieces that don’t suit each other and sound like taken from five different songs that they had been working on. It also unfolds too quickly and with no particular logic to it. Song starts with gentle gospel intro but before it starts to mean anything we already hear the guitar, drums and then bass kicking in without any real build up and then we hear the chorus without any logic to it. All of this takes 40 seconds. Too fast to mean anything real other than that they desperately wanted to have a hit.
    They have always liked an abrupt transition in a song. It is their way of adding more dynamic / more power to the song.

    The transitions will always sound strange at first listen, but once you hear a song over and over again, the transitions kind of blend better as your mind gets used to it. The transition into the verses sounded jarring at first to me, but after a few listens, it sounds fine and makes sense to me.

    The band has listened to these songs over and over again and probably tweaked them countless ways, so what sounds strange to us might sound totally normal to them in the studio since they have heard it so many times. They are able to sit with the songs over time and see what leaves the longest impression.
  9. Originally posted by U2Sonny:[..]
    They have always liked an abrupt transition in a song. It is their way of adding more dynamic / more power to the song.

    The transitions will always sound strange at first listen, but once you hear a song over and over again, the transitions kind of blend better as your mind gets used to it. The transition into the verses sounded jarring at first to me, but after a few listens, it sounds fine and makes sense to me.

    The band has listened to these songs over and over again and probably tweaked them countless ways, so what sounds strange to us might sound totally normal to them in the studio since they have heard it so many times. They are able to sit with the songs over time and see what leaves the longest impression.
    Good point, your ears do get used to the music after a while. The same for a band and producers in a studio who have lived with a song long enough to not feel how jarring a change could be, such is the way with stitching different bit together. The Beatles 'A Day In A Life' is a classic example of how it's done well. That tune was like a blueprint for prog rock, and such songs that transition like David Bowie's 'Station To Station' and U2's 'Zooropa'.

    SOD suffers being too short for the changes to happen more smoothly, that said after a few days the tune is growing on me and it's been listened to a good few times.
  10. As someone said after a few listens,it’s possible the start and end seques from one song into another, on the album. Or even with the start / end the same it’s in the middle of a 3 song run. After a few listens I’m getting used to it,still stand by my initial thought of I’m waiting for it to go somewhere,never seems to take off.
  11. Originally posted by tuf392664:The more I listen to it I think the thing bothering me most is that intro, and outro I guess. I’d rather it just fade in to the little riff and stop abruptly at the end prior to the ‘god hear me shout’ bit . The rest of it is fine, nothing special but decent.
    Same here. Don't like those spheric sounds in that song.